QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Ruiz-Diaz

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Ruiz-Diaz [2025] NSWPICMP 440

CLAIMANT:

Ruiz-Diaz

INSURER:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Gary Victor Patterson

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Dr Mohammed Assem

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Dr Christopher Oates

DATE OF DECISION:

23 June 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; review of Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC); claimant was involved in a motor vehicle accident in Arndell Park; claimant was driving a Ford Transit single-cab utility vehicle; claimant was sitting on a cushion; was positioned quite high in his seat; claimant’s vehicle was stationary in the left turn lane, his left hand was on the steering wheel, his right elbow was resting on the windowsill; claimant remembers the back of his head striking the rear glass panel; Held – Medical Assessor found that a soft-tissue injury to the right elbow including a tendon tear is a threshold injury; panel was satisfied by MRI scan that tear was pre-existing; no matter of principle; MAC revoked; new certificate issued.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE

REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF THRESHOLD INJURY

Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 (the Act)

1.     The Panel revokes the certificate dated 8 October 2024 and issues a new certificate determining that:

(a)    The following injury caused by the motor accident:

·         cervical spine – soft tissue injury,

is a THRESHOLD INJURY for the purposes of the Act.

(b)    The following injury caused by the motor accident:

·         right elbow – soft tissue injury,

is a THRESHOLD INJURY for the purposes of the Act.


PERSONAL INJURY COMMISSION

MOTOR ACCIDENTS DIVISION

REVIEW OF MEDICAL ASSESSMENT

Matter number:

R-M21676/24-02-1

Claimant:

Enrique Ruiz-Diaz

Insurer:

QBE

Accident date:

11 February 2022

Review Panel:

General Member Gary Victor Patterson

Medical Assessor Mohammed Assem

Medical Assessor Christopher Oates

Date of determination:

23 June 2025

CERTIFICATE

REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF THRESHOLD INJURY

Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 (the Act)

  1. The Panel revokes the certificate dated 8 October 2024 and issues a new certificate determining that:

    (a)    The following injury caused by the motor accident:

    ·cervical spine – soft tissue injury,

    is a THRESHOLD INJURY for the purposes of the Act.

    (b)    The following injury caused by the motor accident:

    ·right elbow – soft tissue injury,

    is a THRESHOLD INJURY for the purposes of the Act.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. The claimant was involved in a motor vehicle accident on 17 March 2020. The accident occurred on Holbeche Road at the intersection with Doonside Road in Arndell Park. The claimant was driving west intending to turn left from Holbeche Road onto Doonside Road. While that intersection is controlled by traffic lights, there is a separate left turn lane which permits a left turn at any time, with care.

  2. The claimant was driving a Ford Transit single-cab utility vehicle. He had just delivered some air-conditioning parts to a client. His wife was in the passenger seat. The claimant was sitting on a cushion, and so…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Ruiz-Diaz and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Ruiz-Diaz, the claimant sought a review of a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The claimant, who was driving a Ford Transit single-cab utility vehicle, was involved in a motor vehicle accident in Arndell Park. The claimant was sitting on a cushion positioned quite high in his seat, with his left hand on the steering wheel and his right elbow resting on the windowsill. The claimant's vehicle was stationary in the left turn lane at the time of the accident, and he remembers the back of his head striking the rear glass panel. The primary issue for the court was to determine whether the claimant's right elbow injury was a threshold injury and whether it was pre-existing.

The court examined the evidence provided by the claimant, including reports from Dr Uthum Dias, an occupational physician, and Dr Charles New, an orthopaedic and spinal surgeon. The medical reports highlighted the claimant's ongoing symptoms and the findings from physical examinations and MRI scans. Dr Dias found that the claimant sustained a persistent aggravation of degenerative cervical spondylosis, loss of range of movement of both shoulders, and a right elbow osteochondral impaction injury. Dr New confirmed the claimant's debilitating pain and loss of range of movement in various parts of his body. The MRI scan showed a partial thickness common extensor tendon tear in the claimant's right elbow, which was assessed as pre-existing. The court concluded that the panel was satisfied by the MRI evidence that the tear in the claimant's right elbow was pre-existing.

The court determined that there was no matter of principle involved in the assessment and subsequent revocation of the claimant's Medical Assessment Certificate. The court issued a new certificate, acknowledging that the claimant's soft-tissue injury to the right elbow, including the tendon tear, was not a threshold injury due to its pre-existing nature. The court's decision focused on the accuracy of the medical assessment and the evidence provided to support the revocation of the initial certificate. The claimant's claims regarding other injuries, such as those to his neck, lower back, shoulders, and right middle finger, were not the subject of the court's ruling in this specific instance.

The court's final orders were to revoke the initial Medical Assessment Certificate and issue a new certificate, reflecting the determination that the right elbow injury was pre-existing and not a threshold injury under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The claimant provided statements dated 28 September 2023 and 16 November 2023 which the Panel has considered:“CLAIMANT’S QUALIFIED EXPERT MEDICAL EVIDENCEa. Report of Dr Uthum Dias, occupational physician, to the claimant’s lawyers.Dr Dias records the claimant said he did not have any previous injuries or known pre-existing conditions affecting his neck, lower back, shoulders, elbows or hands prior to the subject accident. The claimant said that, prior to the subject accident, he was pain free and asymptomatic in all of the abovementioned areas. He led a fit and healthy active lifestyle.Dr Dias records that the claimant continued to suffer from debilitating symptoms of pain, stiffness and discomfort affecting his neck, lower back, shoulders and right middle finger on a continual basis over the three years since the subject accident.Dr Dias records that the claimant’s symptoms of neck pain were associated with persisting radicular symptoms radiating down his left upper limb to his left hand on a consistent basis over the course of the past three years. The claimant informed Dr Dias that his right elbow condition slowly resolved over the past three years. His right elbow is currently pain-free and asymptomatic. Dr Dias refers to the various treatments that the claimant has received since the accident from practitioners in various specialties. Dr Dias recorded that the claimant was not undergoing any specialist medical treatment, for his accident-related injuries, at the time of his assessment.Dr Dias described his physical examination of the claimant’s cervical spine, thoracic spine, lumbar spine, shoulders, left elbow and right hand, including neurological examination of the upper and lower limbs.Under the heading DIAGNOSIS, Dr Dias states as follows:· He has sustained a persistent aggravation of previously asymptomatic degenerative cervical spondylosis, with an associated persisting left C7 radiculopathy and associated loss of range of movement of both shoulders, secondary to an acute musculoligamentous strain with an associated C6/C7 disc protrusion (Whiplash Associated Disorder Level III). · His loss of range of movement of his right and left shoulders does not, in my opinion, reflect in a pathology in his right and left shoulder regions, but rather reflects referred pain from his cervical spine condition.· He has sustained a persistent aggravation of previously asymptomatic degenerative lumbar spondylosis, secondary to an acute musculoligamentous strain.· He suffers from chronic right middle finger MCP joint pain and discomfort, secondary to an acute ligamentous strain.· He sustained an acute right elbow osteochondral impaction injury to the capitellum, with an associated partial thickness common extensor tendon tear, as a result of the subject accident.Dr Dias says that the claimant’s right elbow injury has resolved. He says that the claimant’s prognosis is relatively poor. He opines as to the claimant’s fitness for work and future treatment needs which are not relevant for the Panel’s consideration.Dr Dias assesses 15% whole person impairment (WPI) for the cervicothoracic spine, 5% WPI for the lumbosacral spine, 6% WPI for the right shoulder, 7% WPI for the left shoulder and 0% WPI for the right middle finger, giving a total WPI of 30%, using the Combined Values Chart.b. Report dated 15 February 2022 by Dr Charles New, orthopaedic and spinal surgeon, to the claimant’s lawyers.Under the heading PAIN DIABILITY ASSESSMENT, Dr New states as follows:“He has debilitating pain in his cervical, thoracic and lumbar spine as well as bilateral radicular pain. The left arm is worse than the right. He has radicular pain into the C6/C7 nerve root distribution in his left hand. He describes the pain as an aching, stabbing pain with pins and needles, exacerbated by changing positions, sneezing, prolonged sitting, lifting and bending.”Under the heading EXAMINATION, Dr New records as follows:Cervical spine – formal examination shows painful movement of his cervical spine in flexion, extension, lateral bending and rotation limited by pain, with a loss of approximately 25% of his normal range of movement.He has tenderness over his cervical spine at the cervicothoracic junction.Upper limb examination notes reflex is normal, no clonus, negative Hoffman’s sign. He has no demonstrable weakness in his upper limbsShoulder – he has a near full range of movement in his shoulder in flexion 130°, extension 30°, abduction, adduction, external and internal rotation limited by approximately 25% because of pain in both shoulders.Lumbar spine – He has pain over the full extent of the lumbar spine and minor decrease in range of movement of his lumbar spine with loss of approximately 20% of range of movement. He has a normal neurological examination of his lower limbs with the exception of absent left ankle jerk. He has a negative clonus. It is noted that he has a normal right ankle jerk.He has no loss of sensation in either upper or lower limb.The patient was compliant and cooperative throughout the taking of the history and examination. There was no suggestion of over-reaction or exaggeration. Under the heading RADIOLOGY, Dr New reports as follows:

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established