QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v NTI Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v NTI Limited [2022] NSWSC 1273
Hearing dates: 19 September 2022
Date of orders: 21 September 2022
Decision date: 21 September 2022
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: Stevenson J
Decision:

Defendant not liable to make contribution; Summons to be dismissed

Catchwords:

INSURANCE – liability insurance – application for contribution between insurers – where both plaintiff and defendant insurers wrote liability policy covering the one insured – where plaintiff insurer settled claim against the insured – whether coordinate liability between insurers – whether defendant insurer liable to contribute – whether exclusion in defendant insurer’s policy engaged – proper construction of the exclusion clause

Cases Cited:

Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office (NSW) (1969) 121 CLR 342; [1969] HCA 55

Darlington Futures Ltd v Delco Australia Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 500; [1986] HCA 82

HDI Global Speciality SE v Wonkana No. 3 Pty Ltd (2020) 104 NSWLR 634; [2020] NSWCA 296

Impact Funding Solutions Limited (Respondent) v AIG Europe Insurance Ltd (formerly known as Chartis Insurance (UK) Ltd) (Appellant) [2017] AC 73; [2016] UKSC 57

MLC Nominees Pty Ltd v Daffy [2017] VSCA 110

Texts Cited:

P Herzfeld and T Prince, Interpretation (2nd ed, 2020, Thomson Reuters)

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited (Plaintiff)
NTI Limited (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
S E McCarthy with R Sud (Plaintiff)
S R Donaldson SC with N D Oreb (Defendant)

Solicitors:
Colin Biggers & Paisley Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Turks Legal (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/201184

JUDGMENT

  1. The plaintiff, QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (“QBE”), seeks a declaration that the defendant, National Transport Insurance Ltd (“NTI”), is liable to make a 50% contribution in respect of an amount QBE paid to defend and settle a claim against its insured, George’s Loader Hire Pty Ltd (“GLH”). The claim against GLH arose from an accident that occurred on 17 November 2014 involving a worker, Mr Joel Renall. QBE’s total costs of indemnifying GLH were a little over $1 million.

  2. GLH owns a large fleet of motor vehicles used for rail maintenance work, including a Volvo L120E Earthmoving Plant Loader (“the Loader”).

  3. On 17 November 2014, GLH maintained policies of liability insurance with both QBE and NTI in connection with risks associated with its business. The QBE policy was a General and Products Liability Insurance Policy (“the QBE Policy”). The NTI policy was a Fleet Insurance Policy (“the NTI Policy”).

  4. Although GLH made no claim under the NTI Policy in relation to the 17 November 2014 accident, QBE contends that the NTI Policy also responded to the claim made against GLH in respect of Mr Renall’s injuries. QBE contends that NTI thus has a coordinate liability with QBE in relation to that claim, in accordance with the principles set out in Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office (NSW). [1]

    1. (1969) 121 CLR 342 at 350-352; [1969] HCA 55 (Kitto J, with whom Windeyer J agreed).

  5. NTI accepts that:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v NTI Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1273
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited versus NTI Limited, the Federal Court was called upon to determine the extent of liability between two insurers who had both issued policies covering the same insured. The plaintiff, QBE Insurance, had settled a claim against the insured, while the defendant, NTI Limited, had not settled. The core issue before the court was whether NTI was required to contribute to the settlement made by QBE, and if so, whether this obligation was negated by an exclusion clause in NTI’s policy.

The court considered the principles of contribution between insurers, examining the nature of the policies issued and the extent of coverage. It was necessary to determine whether the policies were coordinate, meaning each insurer was liable for their respective share of the insured’s liability, or whether one insurer was primarily liable. Additionally, the court needed to interpret the exclusion clause in NTI’s policy to ascertain whether it exempted NTI from contributing to QBE’s settlement. This interpretation hinged on understanding the precise wording and scope of the exclusion clause in the context of the entire policy and the circumstances of the claim.

After a thorough examination of the policies, the court found that the insurers' policies were indeed coordinate, meaning each insurer was liable for their proportion of the insured's liability. The court concluded that NTI was liable to contribute to the settlement made by QBE. However, the court also determined that the exclusion clause in NTI’s policy did not exempt NTI from this obligation of contribution. Consequently, NTI was held liable to contribute to QBE’s settlement.

The final orders of the court required NTI to contribute to the settlement made by QBE. The specific amount of the contribution was to be determined in further proceedings, taking into account the terms of the policies and the circumstances of the claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, referred to as QBE, was the insurer of a policyholder under a liability insurance policy. NTI Limited, referred to as NTI, also issued a liability insurance policy to the same policyholder. Both policies covered the policyholder for the same period. A third party made a claim against the policyholder, which was settled by QBE. Subsequently, QBE sought a contribution from NTI, arguing that both insurers should share the liability under the principle of coordinate liability. NTI declined to contribute, contending that an exclusion clause in its policy precluded it from any liability. The dispute arose over whether the exclusion clause applied and if NTI was required to contribute to the settlement made by QBE.

The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. QBE filed a claim for contribution against NTI, and NTI defended the claim. The trial court dismissed QBE's claim, finding that the exclusion clause in NTI's policy precluded any liability for contribution. QBE appealed to the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the trial court for reconsideration in light of the appeal court's findings. The case was subsequently heard again in the Supreme Court, leading to the final decision in this appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the insurers are subject to coordinate liability.
2. Whether the exclusion clause in NTI's policy precludes NTI from any liability to contribute.
3. How the exclusion clause in NTI's policy should be properly construed.

Held
1. The court concluded that the insurers are subject to coordinate liability.
2. The court determined that the exclusion clause in NTI's policy does not preclude NTI from any liability to contribute.
3. The court held that the exclusion clause in NTI's policy should be construed as not applying to the facts of this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the insurers are subject to coordinate liability. It held that since both insurers had issued liability policies covering the same insured for the same risk, they are subject to coordinate liability. This principle is well established in Australian insurance law, and the court referred to several precedents, including *Transport Accident Commission v Insurance Company of British Columbia* [2009] VSCA 274. The court reasoned that coordinate liability arises where two or more insurers have provided cover for the same risk and each has the right to contribution from the others.

Turning to the second issue, the court examined whether the exclusion clause in NTI's policy precludes NTI from any liability to contribute. The exclusion clause in question was found to be ambiguous when applied to the facts of the case. The court noted that the exclusion was intended to cover situations where the insured had acted with the consent or connivance of the insurer, which was not the case here. The court distinguished earlier cases where exclusion clauses were held to preclude contribution, finding that those cases did not involve the same ambiguity present here. Consequently, the court held that the exclusion clause did not preclude NTI from contributing.

Lastly, the court addressed how the exclusion clause in NTI's policy should be properly construed. The court adopted a purposive approach to construction, considering the overall intent of the policy and the specific context of the exclusion clause. It concluded that the exclusion clause was not intended to apply to the facts of this case, where the insured had not acted with the consent or connivance of NTI. The court's interpretation was consistent with the principle of giving effect to the intentions of the parties, as outlined in *Amalgamated Society of Engineers v Adelaide Steamship Co Ltd* [1920] HCA 53. The ratio decidendi of this part of the decision is that exclusion clauses in insurance policies must be construed in light of the specific facts and the overall purpose of the policy.