QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Manfre

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Manfre [2022] NSWPIC 266

CLAIMANT: Josephine Manfre
INSURER: QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited
MEMBER: Susan McTegg

DATE OF DECISION:

3 June 2022

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Approval of settlement; section 6.23 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; non-economic loss; claimant now 62 years of age; serious accident; non-economic loss only; fracture of C2 (hangman’s fracture); fracture right transverse process C7; fracture right transverse process T1; fractured ribs; strain lumbar spine; fracture transfers process at L2/3 and L4; right haemothorax; subcutaneous emphysema right chest wall; right knee pain; psychological symptoms (largely resolved);  constant pain neck, back and both legs; easily tired; no longer able to care for grandchildren 5 days a week; Held– settlement of claim for damages for non-economic loss approved in the sum of $200,000. 

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1. This proposed settlement is approved.

2.      The proposed settlement is approved under s 6.23(2)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

Introduction

  1. On 27 April 2019 Josephine Manfre (the claimant) sustained serious injury in a motor vehicle accident (the accident).

  2. Ms Manfre has made a claim against QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited (the insurer) of the at fault vehicle, for lump sum damages.

  3. On 29 March 2022 the insurer accepted liability for the claim for common law claim for damages.

  4. The insurer has accepted that Ms Manfre had non-minor injuries and pursuant to Division 3.4 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) she is entitled to payment of reasonable treatment and care for the rest of her life for her accident caused injuries.

  5. Ms Manfre sustained the following injuries in the accident:

    ·        fracture of the C2 vertebral body;

    ·        fracture right transverse process C7; 

    ·        fracture right transverse process T1;

    ·        multiple fractured ribs bilaterally;

    ·        musculoligamentous strain lumbar spine;

    ·        fractures involving the right transverse process at L2/3 and 4;

    ·        small right haemothorax with contusion;

    ·        subcutaneous emphysema right chest wall;

    ·        right knee pain;

    ·        seatbelt bruising; and

    ·        musculoligamentous strain cervical spine.

  6. The insurer has conceded Ms Manfre has sustained a whole person impairment (WPI) of greater than 10%. This means Ms Manfre is entitled to recover damages for non-economic loss.

  7. Ms Manfre and the insurer have agreed to settle the claim for lump sum damages for the sum of $200,000. Because Ms Manfre is not represented by a lawyer, her settlement must be approved in accordance with the MAI Act.

  8. The insurer lodged the application for approval of the settlement, and it was referred to me for consideration.

  9. I held a teleconference on 3 June 2022 at 9 am. Ms Manfre appeared accompanied by her daughter Louisa Manfre and the insurer was represented by Mr Martin Cope.

Jurisdiction of the Personal Injury Commission

  1. The Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) was established on 1 March 2021 and the Dispute Resolution Service was abolished by cl 3 of Part 2, Division 2, Schedule 1 to the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020.

  2. I am…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Manfre and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, as insurer of the defendant in a motor accident claim, sought approval of a settlement for the claimant's non-economic loss. The claimant, who was 62 years old at the time of the accident, had suffered a serious injury resulting in a fracture of C2 (known as a hangman’s fracture), a fracture of the right transverse process C7, and other related injuries. The accident had left the claimant with constant pain in the neck, back, and both legs, along with psychological symptoms that had largely resolved. The claimant was no longer able to care for her grandchildren five days a week. The court had to decide whether the settlement amount of $200,000 for non-economic loss was appropriate under the circumstances.

The court considered whether the settlement amount was fair and reasonable under section 6.23 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The claimant’s injuries were severe, leading to significant ongoing physical and psychological impacts. The court noted that the claimant had lost the ability to care for her grandchildren, which was a substantial part of her daily life. The court examined the nature of the injuries, the claimant’s age, and the impact of the accident on her life. It also considered the claimant's capacity to manage her ongoing pain and the limitations imposed by the injuries.

After weighing the evidence and the arguments presented, the court concluded that the settlement amount of $200,000 was appropriate for the non-economic loss suffered by the claimant. The court found that the amount reflected the severity of the injuries and their impact on the claimant's life, taking into account her age and the limitations on her ability to care for her grandchildren. The settlement was approved as fair and reasonable under the relevant statutory provisions.

The court ordered that the settlement of $200,000 for non-economic loss be approved. This amount was to be paid to the claimant, covering her losses resulting from the motor accident. The decision ensured that the claimant received compensation that adequately reflected her suffering and the impact of the injuries on her daily life.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claimant in this case was involved in a serious motor accident, resulting in significant injuries. At the time of the accident, the claimant was 62 years old. The injuries sustained included a fracture of C2, commonly referred to as a hangman’s fracture, a fracture of the right transverse process at C7, a fracture of the right transverse process at T1, fractured ribs, a strain of the lumbar spine, and fractures at the transverse processes at L2/3 and L4. The claimant also suffered from a right haemothorax, subcutaneous emphysema in the right chest wall, and persistent pain in the neck, back, and both legs. Psychological symptoms were present but had largely resolved by the time of the settlement application. The claimant reported experiencing constant pain and was easily tired, impacting their ability to care for their grandchildren five days a week.

This case involved an application to the court for the approval of a settlement under section 6.23 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The matter was heard by the court following a settlement proposal for damages related to non-economic loss. Prior to this application, the claimant had not sought approval from the court for the settlement amount. The application was made directly to the court for its approval or rejection.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed settlement amount of $200,000 for non-economic loss is appropriate and should be approved by the court.

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed settlement amount of $200,000 for non-economic loss is appropriate and should be approved by the court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the provisions of section 6.23 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 in determining the appropriateness of the settlement amount. This section provides that the court may approve a settlement where it considers the settlement amount to be fair and reasonable, having regard to all the circumstances of the case. The court noted that the claimant, who is now 62 years of age, was involved in a serious accident resulting in multiple injuries including a fracture of C2 (hangman’s fracture), fractures of the transverse processes at C7, T1, and L2/3 and L4, fractured ribs, strain of the lumbar spine, right haemothorax, subcutaneous emphysema of the right chest wall, and right knee pain. The claimant also experienced psychological symptoms, which have largely resolved, but continues to suffer from constant pain in the neck, back, and both legs, fatigue, and is no longer able to care for grandchildren five days a week. The court recognised the severity and long-term impact of these injuries on the claimant's quality of life and daily activities. The court also noted that the settlement amount of $200,000 falls within the range of amounts previously approved by the courts for similar types of injuries and circumstances. Having considered all the circumstances, the court concluded that the settlement amount was fair and reasonable and approved the settlement of the claim for damages for non-economic loss in the sum of $200,000.