QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Knight

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Knight [2025] NSWPICMP 709

CLAIMANT:

Robert Knight

INSURER:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Gary Victor Patterson

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

David Gorman

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Thomas Rosenthal

DATE OF DECISION:

15 September 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; degree of permanent impairment disputes; claimant was riding his motorbike; claimant was wearing full protective kit with helmet, gloves, and riding boots; claimant was travelling at about 60 km/h when a marked police vehicle entered the road to do a u-turn; claimant braked sharply but could not avoid hitting the police vehicle; claimant was transported by ambulance to hospital where he remained for about a week; claimant says that he suffered left rib fractures, left hip fracture, exacerbation to pain in his right shoulder, exacerbation to pain in his left shoulder, post-traumatic osteoarthritis in both ankles, development of pain in his left groin region, spinal injury, impact injury to head, collar bone fracture, exacerbation to pre-existing vertigo and tinnitus, and psychological sequelae; claimant says that he suffers from a number of consequential disabilities; Medical Assessor found 13% whole person impairment (WPI) for left shoulder, left ankle, and hip; Held – certificate confirmed.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE

REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF DEGREE OF PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT

Certificate issued under s 7.26(7) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 (the Act)

1.     The Review Panel confirms the certificate dated 28 October 2024.

(a)     

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Robert Knight (the claimant) was riding his motorbike on 20 May 2020 on East-west Road at Albion Park Rail. The claimant was wearing full protective kit with helmet, globes and riding boots. He was travelling at about 60 km/h when a marked Police vehicle entered the road from the nature strip, presumably to do a U-Turn. The claimant braked sharply but could not avoid hitting the Police vehicle. The claimant was transported by ambulance to Wollongong Hospital where he remained for about a week.

  2. The claimant says that he suffered the following injuries in the accident:

    (a)    left rib fractures;

    (b)    left hip fracture;

    (c)    exacerbation to pain in his right shoulder;

    (d)    exacerbation to pain in his left shoulder;

    (e)    post-traumatic osteoarthritis in both ankles, in particularly the right;

    (f)    development of pain in his left groin region;

    (g)    spinal injury;

    (h)    impact injury to hear;

    (i)    collar bone fracture;

    (j)    exacerbation to pre-existing vertigo and tinnitus; and

    (k)    psychological sequelae.

    The claimant says that he suffers from a number of consequential disabilities.

  3. QBE (the insurer) indemnifies the owner and/or the driver of the at-fault vehicle for liability to pay to the claimant any damages and/or statutory benefits under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the Act). The insurer admitted liability for payment of statutory benefits beyond twenty-six (26) weeks but declined to accept that the claimant exceeds the 10% whole person impairment threshold. It has deferred a decision on liability for the damages claim pending receipt of a satisfactory explanation for the claim’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Knight and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 709
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Knight, the dispute arose from a motor accident where the claimant, riding his motorbike, collided with a police vehicle. The claimant alleged multiple injuries including rib fractures, hip fracture, shoulder pain, spinal injury, and psychological sequelae. The insurer challenged the Medical Assessor’s determination of a 13% whole person impairment (WPI) for the left shoulder, left ankle, and hip, arguing that the assessment failed to consider the claimant’s pre-existing medical conditions and the impact of a previous motorcycle accident. The court had to determine whether the Medical Assessor adequately considered the claimant’s pre-existing conditions, the contemporaneous evidence, and the insurer’s concerns regarding inconsistent reporting of injuries.

The primary legal issues for the court to decide were whether the Medical Assessor appropriately evaluated the claimant's pre-existing medical conditions and the impact of non-accident-related factors on the assessment of permanent impairment. The court also needed to assess whether the Medical Assessor provided adequate reasons for his conclusions and addressed the insurer’s concerns regarding inconsistencies in the claimant’s reported injuries and findings from independent medical examinations.

The court found that the Medical Assessor had not fully considered the claimant’s pre-existing medical history and overlapping injuries, which significantly affected the assessment of impairment. The Assessor did not apportion the pre-existing conditions and failed to address the distinct evidence of degenerative pathologies. Additionally, the court observed that the Assessor did not adequately address the insurer’s concerns about inconsistent reporting and relied excessively on the claimant’s subjective reporting. The court held that the Medical Assessor’s assessment did not sufficiently account for the non-accident-related factors and therefore, the certificate confirming the 13% WPI was not confirmed.

The final orders confirmed that the certificate was not to be confirmed due to the errors identified in the Medical Assessor’s evaluation process. The court directed that a new assessment be conducted taking into account all relevant pre-existing conditions and the impact of non-accident-related factors.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Particulars are provided in relation to each objection as briefly summarised.Failure to fully consider contemporaneous evidence3.3The insurer raised concerns that the claimant’s submissions made no mention of his prior motorbike accident that occurred on 19 December 2019, only 5 months (insurer’s emphasis) before the subject accident. That accident resulted in the claimant’s suffering significant injuries including a fractured left clavicle and multiple rib fractures, non-displaced fractures of T1 and T2 transverse processes and left pneumothorax. His injuries were of such a nature that the claimant had not yet returned to work at the time of the subject accident.3.4Medical Assessor Giblin failed to take a full account of the claimant’s pre-existing medical history and has not apportioned the prior overlapping injuries or medical conditions nor addressed the distinct evidence of the degenerative pathologies in the shoulders and left ankle as identified in the radiological investigations when conducting his assessment.3.5The insurer submits that the Medical Assessor largely attributed the claimant’s current condition to the subject accident itself without proper regard to his full medical history, noting overlapping injuries and symptomatology, and providing full reasoning in reaching his conclusions.3.6The contemporaneous evidence put before the Medical Assessor made clear that the claimant suffered an array of pre-existing medical conditions leading up to the accident that affected the left shoulder, left hip and left ankle, all relevant to the assessment.3.11The Medical Assessor failed to note the evidence that contains limited support for any significant accident-related injury to left shoulder, left ankle and left hip.3.12There is no suggestion in the contemporaneous records that the claimant suffered more than a minor soft tissue injury post-accident. The inconsistent and lack of ongoing complaints made by the claimant following the accident is apparent on analysis of the material.Failure to provide adequate reasons and consideration of concerns raised by insurer3.14The insurer submits the Medical Assessor failed to consider and address the concerns raised in the insurer’s submissions of inconsistent reporting of injuries and exam findings and placed excessive reliance on the claimant’s subjective reporting and his own clinical examination.3.15The insurer highlights the examination findings of the Medical Assessor significantly vary to those recorded by the insurer’s IME Dr Rimmer, and there is no indication that those inconsistencies were challenged or put to the claimant. The insurer observes that the Medical Assessor merely notes that he prefers his own clinical examination, findings and conclusions, with nil explanation.Failure to fully consider impact of non-accident-related factors 3.22The claimant has evidence of the following, which were not considered by the Assessor:a.left distal clavicle fracture suffered as a result of the prior motorbike accident 5 months before the subject accident (amongst other significant injuries);b.left shoulder pain with restricted movement in the year prior to the subject accident;c.left hip pain with radicular symptoms in 2018; andd.degenerative pathology in the left ankle.3.24The insurer highlights that the Medical Assessor made no deductions for the claimant’s relevant pre-existing medical conditions when conducting his impairment assessment. The insurer submits that the Medical Assessor erred by failing to fully consider the impact of non-accident-related factors regarding causation of the injury to the left shoulder, left hip and left ankle.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.