QBCC v Ken McKay Homes Pty Ltd ACN 108 466 404

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

MAGISTRATES COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  QBCC v Ken McKay Homes Pty Ltd ACN 108 466 404
[2024] QMC 8
PARTIES:  QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
COMMISSION
(Plaintiff/Applicant)
v
KEN MCKAY HOMES PTY LTD
ACN 108 466 404
(First Defendant/Respondent)
AND
KENNETH THOMAS KCKAY
(Second Defendant/Respondent)
AND
STRUCTERRE WBA PTY LTD
ACN 115 038 429
(First Third Party)
AND
INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED
ABN 11 000 016 722
(Second Third Party)
FILE NO/S:  M665/23
DIVISION:  Civil
PROCEEDING:  Interlocutory Application filed 20 March 2024
ORIGINATING 
COURT:  Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:  20 June 2024
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  17 May 2024
MAGISTRATE:  Magistrate Hay
ORDER: 
[1]  The plaintiff’s application for summary judgment is

dismissed.

[2]      The defendants are granted leave to file and serve a second, further amended defence.

COUNSEL:  N M Cooke of Counsel for the Plaintiff/Applicant
A J Tindall of Counsel for the Defendants/Respondents
SOLICITORS:  Gadens Lawyers for the Plaintiff/Applicant
Robinson Locke Litigation Lawyers for the
Defendants/Respondents

1.   The plaintiff applies to strike out the Further Amended Defence, and for summary

judgment against the defendants.

2.   The defendants apply to file a Second Further Amended Defence and resist the

summary judgment application on the grounds that the claim approved by the QBCC

was not a “payment on a claim under the statutory insurance scheme” within the

meaning of phrase as expressed in s. 71 of the Queensland Building and Construction

Commission Act 1991 (‘QBCC Act’). The defendants argue that the payment was for

subsidence damage arising from design and inspection work performed by an engineer

engaged by the consumer, and that was specifically excluded under the relevant policy

wording.

3.    The plaintiff contends that the defendants are precluded from raising these issues as a

defence to the plaintiff’s claim due to the operation of s. 71(1) of the QBCC Act.

The Law

4. On an application for summary judgment under r. 292 of the UCPR the court must

consider two contentions. First, that there is no real prospect of successfully defending

the claim. Second, that there is no need for a trial.

5. Section 71(1) of the QBCC Act deems payments made by the plaintiff “on a claim

under the statutory insurance scheme” to be recoverable as a debt. Section 71(1) gives

the plaintiff the option of recovering the debt from the building contractor, “or any

other person through whose fault the claim arose.”

6.    The plaintiff submits that the defendants ought to have sought a merits review of the

payment decision in QCAT, the time for which has now passed.

7. It is settled law that a payment sought to be recovered as a debt by the QBCC that falls

outside the statutory insurance scheme, including the scope of a policy, will give rise

to a fact capable of being a defence to the debt claimed.

8.    In the 2015 unreported Court of Appeal decision in Samimi v QBCC Boddice J, with

whom McMurdo P and Morrison JA agreed, observed that the phrase “… ‘on a claim

under the insurance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBCC v Ken McKay Homes Pty Ltd ACN 108 466 404 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QMC 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Magistrates Court of Queensland heard an interlocutory application from the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) against Ken McKay Homes Pty Ltd and others. The QBCC sought summary judgment against the defendants for recovery of payments made under the statutory insurance scheme. The defendants, in turn, applied to file a second further amended defence, arguing that the payments in question were not covered under the insurance policy. The central legal issue was whether the payments made by the QBCC for subsidence damage, allegedly caused by an engineer engaged by the homeowner, were recoverable under section 71 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (QBCC Act). The defendants contended that these payments were outside the scope of the insurance scheme, specifically excluded by clause 7.4(c) of the insurance policy, which precluded coverage for failures by persons other than the building contractor’s agents, including engineers engaged by the homeowner. The court considered the relevant authorities, including the Court of Appeal decisions in Samimi and Turcinovic, which established that factual issues regarding the scope of the insurance policy could be raised as a defence. The court held that the defendants had raised a triable issue, as the exclusion of engineer-related inspections under clause 7.4(c) of the policy could potentially exclude the QBCC’s claim. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s application for summary judgment and granted the defendants leave to file a second further amended defence limited to the specific exclusions under clause 7.4(c) of the insurance policy.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established