PYYM and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

PYYM and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2018] AATA 4670 (19 December 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/2622

Re:PYYM

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndPLWQ

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Date:19 December 2018

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision of Social Services and Child Support Division and substitutes it with the finding that the percentage of care for Child MA is determined to have been, from 20 May 2016, at the rate of 20% for PYYM and 80% for PLWQ.

The effective date of such a determination is from 13 April 2017.

...........................[sgd].............................................

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care –– actual care – care period – irregular care arrangement – non parent carer – delegated care – inconsistent evidence establishing nights of care –decision under review set aside and substituted

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Shi and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Child Support Guide, version 4.36, 5 November 2018

REASONS FOR DECISION

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

19 December 2018

  1. The matter before the Tribunal relates to the calculation of the percentage of care for Child MA which should be accorded to his father PYYM (the Applicant) under the provisions of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (the Act).

    BACKGROUND

    (a)PYYM and PLWQ are respectively the father and mother of Child MA who was born in 2006 and is now 12 years of age. In evidence PYYM stated that the couple started to live together towards the end of 2005 or early in 2006 about six months before the birth of Child MA. They finally separated when Child MA was about three years of age.

    (b)On 6 June 2006 the Child Support Agency made a determination that PYYM was to start paying child support to PLWQ.[1] Payments were to be made directly from the father to the mother. This payment level was varied in August 2015.[2] At some stage (unspecified in the documentation but asserted to be in mid-2017) payment arrangements were varied so that payments are now made via the Child Support Registrar.

    (c)From the time of Child MA’s birth until May 2016 his mother (PLWQ) was assessed under the Act as having 100% care for him.

    (d)On 20 May 2016 PYYM notified the Child Support Registrar (the Registrar) that he was providing 104 nights support for Child MA each year and that he had been doing so since the couple’s separation.[3] This claim was disputed by the mother.[4]

    (e)As a result of investigations by the Registrar a decision was made, on 23 June 2016,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PYYM and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4670
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal concerning the percentage of care for Child MA, a child born in 2006. The applicant, PYYM (the father), sought to have his percentage of care for Child MA varied under the *Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989*. The dispute arose after PYYM notified the Child Support Registrar that he was providing 104 nights of care annually, a claim disputed by the child's mother, PLWQ. Previous decisions by the Registrar and the Tribunal had varied, with an initial decision awarding PYYM 14% care, which was then set aside by the Tribunal to award PYYM 0% care.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the percentage of care PYYM had for Child MA during the 12-month period following his lodgement of a claim on 20 May 2016. This involved assessing the extent of actual care provided by PYYM, considering evidence of delegated care arrangements where a non-parent carer provided care under arrangements made by a parent, and resolving inconsistencies in the evidence presented by both parties regarding the commencement and duration of care arrangements.

The Tribunal applied the principles outlined in the Child Support Guide regarding the determination of care, which includes assessing the extent of control a person has over a child and their responsibility for making decisions regarding the child's activities and arrangements for their needs, including delegated care. The Tribunal found PYYM to be a truthful and credible witness. While acknowledging inconsistencies in the evidence, particularly regarding the precise start date of delegated care by PYYM's mother, the Tribunal was persuaded that Friday night care arrangements were in place from at least October 2016. The Tribunal set aside the previous decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division and substituted a finding that PYYM had 20% of the care for Child MA from 20 May 2016, with the effective date of this determination being 13 April 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter before the Tribunal relates to the calculation of the percentage of care for Child MA which should be accorded to his father PYYM (the Applicant) under the provisions of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (the Act).BACKGROUND(a)PYYM and PLWQ are respectively the father and mother of Child MA who was born in 2006 and is now 12 years of age. In evidence PYYM stated that the couple started to live together towards the end of 2005 or early in 2006 about six months before the birth of Child MA. They finally separated when Child MA was about three years of age.(b)On 6 June 2006 the Child Support Agency made a determination that PYYM was to start paying child support to PLWQ.[1] Payments were to be made directly from the father to the mother. This payment level was varied in August 2015.[2] At some stage (unspecified in the documentation but asserted to be in mid-2017) payment arrangements were varied so that payments are now made via the Child Support Registrar.(c)From the time of Child MA’s birth until May 2016 his mother (PLWQ) was assessed under the Act as having 100% care for him.(d)On 20 May 2016 PYYM notified the Child Support Registrar (the Registrar) that he was providing 104 nights support for Child MA each year and that he had been doing so since the couple’s separation.[3] This claim was disputed by the mother.[4](e)As a result of investigations by the Registrar a decision was made, on 23 June 2016, not to vary the percentage of care assigned between the parents.[5](f)On 13 April 2017 PYYM lodged an objection claiming that he had care of Child MA for two nights per weekend (Friday and Saturday), equivalent to 28% of care and providing documents in support of this claim.[6] Again, these claims were disputed by the mother.[7](g)After further assessment by the Registrar, on 15 June 2017, an objections officer made a decision to set aside the original decision of June 2016 and instead award PYYM 14% of the care of Child MA, such a decision to be taken as having effect from 13 April 2017.[8] This had the effect, inter alia, of reducing the child support payment calculated and payable by PYYM to PLWQ. [Percentage claims are calculated with reference to a Table set out in Part 2.2.1 of the Department’s Child Support Guide and is based on the number of nights in a year for which the individual has control and support of the child.](h)PYYM was not satisfied with the decision of the objections officer and appealed that determination to the Social Services and Child Support Division of this Tribunal (AAT1).(i)On December 14, 2017 the AAT1 set aside the decision of the objections officer and determined that PYYM was not entitled to any change in the child care percentage (being 0%) as established in May 2016.[9](j)On 11 May 2018 PYYM lodged an appeal against the decision of the AAT1 with this Tribunal.[1] Section 37 - T Documents at [107]. The Tribunal is not required to reconcile apparently contradictory evidence that child support payments commenced in June 2006 (one month after the birth of Child MA) with PYYM’s sworn evidence that the couple separated in June 2009 when the child was three years of age.[2] Ibid at [110]-[111].[3] Ibid at [120]-[121].[4] Ibid at [122].[5] Ibid at [131].[6] Ibid at [155].[7] Ibid at [168]-[216].[8] Ibid at [96]-[100].[9] Ibid at [6]-[9].THE ISSUE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It must be noted that most of the material supplied by PLWQ relates to contemporary arrangements rather than to the relevant period (May 2016 – April 2017) which is of concern to the Tribunal.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL It was unfortunate that PLWQ declined to appear before the Tribunal, either in person or by telephone, however the Tribunal understands her reluctance to do so. It has had the benefit of her written submissions and was able to test a number of her claims and assertions by direct questions put to PYYM. PYYM gave sworn evidence and answered questions from both the representative of the Registrar and from the Tribunal. The Tribunal found him to be a truthful and credible witness.A KEY MATTER AT ISSUE PYYM states that his mother started to provide (delegated) care for Child MA from late 2015 and so this pattern of care was in place as at 20 May 2016. PLWQ disputes this and states that such arrangements did not commence until perhaps the early part of 2017. The Tribunal does not accept this assertion by PLWQ since there is independent evidence that this arrangement was in place at least by October 2016. There is no definitive way to resolve this contradiction. The written testimony of PYYM’s mother is at best ambiguous referring only to an arrangement in “the years between 2015-2016,”[17] and statements from his brother and new partner fail to clarify the matter one way or another. However the Tribunal is persuaded that the Friday night arrangements were in place at least from October 2016 and may well have been in place much earlier.[17] Applicant’s Submission at Tab [1].FINDINGS The current state of arrangements between the parties is both unsatisfactory and fluid and there are several matters of ongoing contention. However that is a matter for resolution other than before this Tribunal. The Tribunal’s responsibility is to find, on the evidence before it at the date of the hearing,[18] what percentage of care PYYM had for Child MA in the 12 month period following his lodgement of claim on 20 May 2016.[18] Shi and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31 at [37]. Care provided by a “non-parent carer”[19] and by a “parent carer” may be accumulated to the credit of the parent concerned where it is they who have made the arrangements for the care of the child in question. This is referred to as “delegated care.”[19] The term used in the Child Support Guide at 2.2.1, relevantly under the heading “Care period”. The basis for this is set out in the Child Support Guide which, at 2.2.1 under the heading ”Determining whether care exists” states, inter alia:“In most cases, it will be relatively clear whether and to what extent a person is caring for a child. However, where there is doubt, the Registrar will consider whichever of the following are relevant to the particular case:* To what extent the person has control of the child, including having overall responsibility for the child and making:* major decisions relating to who the child spends time with and the child’s health, education, discipline, recreational and/or social activities, and* arrangements for others to meet the needs of the child (delegated care).”[20] (emphasis added)[20] A similar reference to “delegated care” may be found in Family Assistance Guide 2.1.1.60 Change of Care of an FTB Child

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Registrar informed the Tribunal that it “adopts a neutral position in respect of the evidence and contentions of the father and mother that the Tribunal should prefer. Accordingly, the Registrar makes no submission in relation to the correct and preferable decision.”[22][22] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [53].DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision of Social Services and Child Support Division and substitutes it with the finding that the percentage of care for Child MA is determined to have been, from 20 May 2016, at the rate of 20% for PYYM and 80% for PLWQ. The effective date of such a determination is from 13 April 2017.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.