PYVW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

PYVW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 3978 (29 October 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/2724

Re:PYVW

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndVBMK

JOINED PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member Dr J Henderson

Date:29 October 2021

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision, being the decision of the AAT1 dated 9 April 2020, is set aside. In substitution the Tribunal decides:

(a)The existing percentage of care determination is revoked;

(b)From 17 December 2018 the Applicant is determined to have provided 94% care and the Other Party is determined to have provided 6% care of the child; and

(c)The application day is 17 December 2018.

............[Sgd]............................................................

Member Dr J Henderson

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care – whether existing determination of care should be revoked – actual care – extent of care – inconsistent evidence – conflicting evidence – inconsistent dates provided by the Other Party – no pattern of care – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 5(2), 49, 50, 54B, 54F, 54FA, 54G, 54H

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 16(2AB), 16(2AC)

CASES

P v Child Support Registrar [2012] FCA 1398

P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98

Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] AATA 562

Polec and Staker (2011) 253 FLR 339

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide – Chapter 2.2.1

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member Dr J Henderson

29 October 2021

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant is the mother and the Other Party (OP) is the father of a child born in 2003.

  2. In this application the Applicant is seeking review of a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division (AAT1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal), made on 9 April 2020 (AAT1 Decision), in the General Division of the Tribunal (AAT2).

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant and the OP are the separated parents of the child.

  4. A child support case was first registered on 17 February 2003, with the Applicant as the receiving parent and the OP as the paying parent (T24/213).

  5. Subsequently, on 8 November 2018, the assessment was amended such that the OP was the receiving parent and the Applicant was the paying parent (T4/34). The Child Support Agency (Agency) determined on that date that each parent’s care of the child had changed from 22 August 2018, with the Applicant having 0% care of the child and the OP having 100% care (T5/35).

  6. On 9…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PYVW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3978
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of a child support Registrar's decision regarding the percentage of care of a child. The parties involved were the Applicant and the Other Party (OP), with the Child Support Registrar as the respondent. The core dispute revolved around whether there had been a change in the actual care arrangements for the child, necessitating a revocation of an existing care determination.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the existing care determination, made on 9 November 2018, which allocated 72% care to the Applicant and 28% to the OP, should be revoked. If revocation was deemed necessary, the Tribunal also had to ascertain the date from which such revocation should take effect and the actual percentages of care each party had from that date. The Tribunal was guided by sections 49 and 50 of the *Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989* (Cth), which require a determination of care percentage based on actual care and the absence of a pattern of care, or a pattern considered appropriate in the circumstances.

The Tribunal found the Applicant to be an honest witness, though her memory of specific dates was not entirely reliable. In contrast, the OP did not appear at the hearing, and his written evidence was found to be inconsistent and unreliable. Specifically, the OP provided conflicting dates for periods of care, including a holiday in December 2018 and a trip to Queensland in February to March 2019, which were contradicted by other evidence such as travel itineraries. The OP also admitted to not communicating disruptions to the care arrangements with the Applicant. Given these inconsistencies and the lack of corroborating evidence for the OP's asserted periods of care, the Tribunal was reluctant to accept his claims.

The Tribunal concluded that the OP's evidence did not demonstrate a consistent pattern of care and contained significant inaccuracies. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous decision and substituted it with a new determination that the existing care determination should be revoked. The Tribunal found that the OP's actual care percentage had significantly dropped and did not reflect the existing determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal found the Applicant to be an honest witness, who was genuinely trying to recall the dates that the child had spent with the OP to the best of her ability. However, the Tribunal finds that, with the exception of April 2019, the Applicant’s memory is not reliable.Other Party’s Evidence The OP provided the following written evidence:(a)Email dated 23 April 2019, with attachments (T11); and(b)Application for First Review dated 17 February 2020, with attachments (T22). The OP did not appear at the hearing. The Tribunal has noted the evidence provided by the OP to the Tribunal in the AAT1 Decision.CONSIDERATION Neither party contends that there was a written agreement, court order or parenting plan in the relevant period. The Tribunal is required to consider the percentage of care based on actual care. The parties agree that there were changes to the usual care arrangement in December 2018 and February 2019. The Applicant says that there was a significant drop in care by the OP and the usual pattern did not resume. The OP’s position seems to be that there was a disruption to the usual pattern of care in February 2019, but that it initially applied to the time he spent in Queensland in February to March 2019. There were other work trips in 2019 that also disrupted the previous arrangement. The OP admits that he did not communicate with the Applicant about this disruption, its anticipated duration, or the possible need for future disruptions to the usual arrangement to accommodate his work trips. The records reflect that:(a)On 13 March 2019, the OP advised the Registrar that he did not have records on hand of his precise care during the previous December, January or February (T20/119). (b)On 10 April 2019, the Applicant advised the Registrar that the OP had only had care on 11 nights since December 2018, and provided the following dates (T20/119):(i)13, 14, 15, 16, 26 December 2018; (ii)2, 3, 18 January 2019; (iii)2, 3 February 2019; (iv)23, 27 March 2019; and (v)3, 10 April 2019. (c)On 15 April 2019, the OP advised that he had overnight care of the child on the following dates:(i)10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 22, 23, 26 December 2018; (ii)2, 4, 5, 16, 18, 19, 23, 30 January 2019; (iii)1, 2, 6, 16, 22, 23 February 2019; (iv)1, 2, 6, 13, 15, 16, 20, 27, 29, 30 March 2019; and (v)3, 10, 12, 13 April 2019. At stated above, the OP was in Queensland from late February to early March and it is not disputed that the child did not go with him, therefore, at least three of the dates in [49] above are not correct. The Tribunal notes that the OP advised the Registrar on 15 April 2019 that the dates 10 to 16 December 2018 had comprised “8 nights as on holiday with dad” (T23/195). That assertion is not consistent with the itinerary contained in the evidence showing the duration of the trip was 13 to 17 December 2018. The itinerary is consistent with the Applicant’s evidence that the child spent five nights with the OP over that period, although the Tribunal notes that the Applicant was under the impression that only four of those nights were spent in Bali, and the final night was spent at the OP’s home.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The OP sought review of the Objection Decision by the AAT1. On 9 April 2020, the AAT1 set aside the Objection Decision and substituted it with the decision that there was no change in care on 17 December 2018 (T2/10). In other words, the AAT1 reversed the Objection Decision and restored the existing care determination, and subsequently the Original Decision (AAT1 Decision). This is the Reviewable Decision before the Tribunal. On 8 May 2020, the Applicant applied to the AAT2 for review of the AAT1 Decision (T1/1). ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION The issues currently before the Tribunal are:(a)Firstly, should the existing care determination be revoked, that is the determination that was made on 9 November 2018, that the Applicant had 72% care of the child and VBMK had 28% care.(b)If the existing care determination is revoked, it will be necessary for the Tribunal to consider from what date the determination should be revoked and what percentage of care the Applicant and the OP each have, or had, of the child from that date. (c)If the Tribunal varies or sets aside the decision under review, it will also need to consider the date from which its decision should have effect for the purposes of the child support assessment. The Tribunal notes that if, and only if, it is established that the AAT1 Decision should be revoked and replaced, that the remaining issues fall for consideration. LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK The relevant legislation is contained within the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (the Assessment Act) and the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act). The relevant policy is contained in the Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide (the Guide). While the Tribunal is not bound by law to apply the Guide, it should have regard to it and follow it unless there are cogent reasons not to do so (see P v Child Support Registrar [2012] FCA 1398 at [3] and Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634). Determination of percentage of care Sections 49 and 50 of the Assessment Act set out when a determination of percentage of care must be made. In determining a percentage of care under these sections, the Registrar is to be satisfied that the person has no pattern of care or a pattern of care that the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances (ss 49(1)(a) and 50(1)(a)). Where a percentage of care determination has been made under s 49 or s 50 of the Assessment Act in respect of a particular care period, a new percentage of care determination cannot be made unless the existing percentage determination is revoked (Subdivision C of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act). Subdivision C of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act provides for the circumstances where the existing care determination must be revoked and where the existing care determination may be revoked. Relevantly:(a)Section 54F of the Assessment Act provides that the existing care determination must be revoked if there is a change to the responsible person’s costs percentage. Section 54F states:(1)The Registrar must revoke a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care (the existing percentage of care) for a child made under section 49 or 50 if:(a)the Registrar or Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, that the care of the child that is actually taking place does not correspond with the responsible person’s existing percentage of care for the child; and(b) the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person’s cost percentage for the child would change if the Registrar were to determine, under section 49 or 50, another percentage to be the person’s percentage of care for the child; and(c) section 54G does not apply …(b)Section 54G of the Assessment Act provides that the existing care determination must be revoked where, under the new care percentage determination, one of the parents who was previously assessed to have at least regular care of the child is now determined to have less than regular care of the child despite the child being made available to them by the other parent. In this context, regular care is defined to be at least 14% of the care of the child (s 5(2) of the Assessment Act). (c)Section 54H of the Assessment Act provides that the existing care determination may be revoked if the Registrar is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, that the existing percentage of care determination does not reflect the care that is actually taking place; the Registrar is satisfied that a new percentage of care determined under s 49 or s 50 would not be the same as the person’s existing percentage of care; and s 54F, 54FA and 54G of the Assessment Act do not apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The OP did not appear at the hearing. The Tribunal has noted the evidence provided by the OP to the Tribunal in the AAT1 Decision.CONSIDERATION Neither party contends that there was a written agreement, court order or parenting plan in the relevant period. The Tribunal is required to consider the percentage of care based on actual care. The parties agree that there were changes to the usual care arrangement in December 2018 and February 2019. The Applicant says that there was a significant drop in care by the OP and the usual pattern did not resume. The OP’s position seems to be that there was a disruption to the usual pattern of care in February 2019, but that it initially applied to the time he spent in Queensland in February to March 2019. There were other work trips in 2019 that also disrupted the previous arrangement. The OP admits that he did not communicate with the Applicant about this disruption, its anticipated duration, or the possible need for future disruptions to the usual arrangement to accommodate his work trips. The records reflect that:(a)On 13 March 2019, the OP advised the Registrar that he did not have records on hand of his precise care during the previous December, January or February (T20/119). (b)On 10 April 2019, the Applicant advised the Registrar that the OP had only had care on 11 nights since December 2018, and provided the following dates (T20/119):(i)13, 14, 15, 16, 26 December 2018; (ii)2, 3, 18 January 2019; (iii)2, 3 February 2019; (iv)23, 27 March 2019; and (v)3, 10 April 2019. (c)On 15 April 2019, the OP advised that he had overnight care of the child on the following dates:(i)10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 22, 23, 26 December 2018; (ii)2, 4, 5, 16, 18, 19, 23, 30 January 2019; (iii)1, 2, 6, 16, 22, 23 February 2019; (iv)1, 2, 6, 13, 15, 16, 20, 27, 29, 30 March 2019; and (v)3, 10, 12, 13 April 2019. At stated above, the OP was in Queensland from late February to early March and it is not disputed that the child did not go with him, therefore, at least three of the dates in [49] above are not correct. The Tribunal notes that the OP advised the Registrar on 15 April 2019 that the dates 10 to 16 December 2018 had comprised “8 nights as on holiday with dad” (T23/195). That assertion is not consistent with the itinerary contained in the evidence showing the duration of the trip was 13 to 17 December 2018. The itinerary is consistent with the Applicant’s evidence that the child spent five nights with the OP over that period, although the Tribunal notes that the Applicant was under the impression that only four of those nights were spent in Bali, and the final night was spent at the OP’s home. It is not clear why the OP did not consult the itinerary to refresh his memory on the Bali dates before giving them to the Registrar. Nor is it clear why the OP provided incorrect dates of contact in March. The Tribunal finds it unlikely that the OP had genuinely forgotten his trip to Queensland only a month after his return. In the circumstances, the Tribunal is reluctant to accept the OP’s assertion that the child spent any of these dates in the care of the OP without some corroborating evidence.