Appeal Panel - Internal
CITATION: PW v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital & ors (EOD) [2007] NSWADTAP 36 PARTIES: APPELLANT
PW
FIRST RESPONDENT
Royal Prince Alfred Hospital
SECOND RESPONDENT
Sydney South West Area Health Service
THIRD RESPONDENT
State of New South Wales (NSW Department of Health)FILE NUMBER: 079010 HEARING DATES: 10 May 2007 SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 10 May 2007
DATE OF DECISION:
16 July 2007BEFORE: O'Connor K - DCJ (President); Rees N - Judicial Member; Lowe A - Non Judicial Member CATCHWORDS: Anti-Discrimination Act - transgender discrimination - refusal of service - the first element, provision of an actual service - not proven - no contravention - Anti-Discrimination Act - s38M - characterisation of service by Tribunal - matter of fact - no error MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter FILE NUMBER UNDER APPEAL: 041031 DATE OF DECISION UNDER APPEAL: 02/05/2007 LEGISLATION CITED: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Anti-Discrimination Act 1977
Health Services Act 1997CASES CITED: PW v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital & ors [2007] NSWADT 31
Lloyd v Veterinary Surgeons Investigating Committee (2005) 64 NSWLR 245
Waters v Public Transport Corporation (1991) 173 CLR 349
Waters and IW v City of Perth (1997) 191 CLR 1REPRESENTATION: APPELLANT
FIRST, SECOND AND THIRD RESPONDENTS
In person
C Ronalds SC instructed by K Thomas, solicitor, Department of HealthORDERS: Appeal dismissed
REASONS FOR DECISION
1 The appellant, PW, was born a male. For the last ten years she has lived as a woman. She has been diagnosed as having gender dysphoria. It is not disputed that she is a transgender person.
2 In October 2002 the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (RPAH) refused (and continues to refuse) to provide her with sexual reassignment surgery on a public patient basis. The relevant regional health authority, the Sydney South West Area Health Service (SSWAHS) has also refused PW’s request. In January 2003 PW made a complaint to the Anti-Discrimination Board (the ADB) against RPAH, the SSWAHS and the State of New South Wales under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (the Act) alleging that the refusal contravened s 38M of the Act. After investigation, the ADB decided that the complaint was unlikely to be resolved by conciliation. In accordance with the wishes of PW, in February 2004 the President referred the complaint to the Tribunal.
3 Section 38 M provides relevantly:
4 The three respondents deny that their refusal contravened this provision. They accept that sexual reassignment surgery could be provided by a public hospital to public patients. Their position throughout the proceedings has simply been that sexual reassignment surgery is not among the services offered by public hospitals in New South Wales to public patients. The result is…
‘ 38M Provision of goods and services
It is unlawful for a person who provides (whether or not for payment) … services to discriminate against another person on transgender grounds:
(a) by refusing to provide the person with those … services, or
(b) in the terms on which the other person is provided with those … services.’
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read PW v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital & ors (EOD) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWADTAP 36
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central issue before the court was whether the hospital's refusal to provide a gynaecology service to PW constituted a contravention of the Anti-Discrimination Act. The court needed to determine whether the service provided by the hospital met the definition of 'service' under the Act, and whether the refusal was based on PW's gender identity or another lawful reason. The court found that the characterisation of the service by the Tribunal was a matter of fact, and the Tribunal's conclusion that the hospital's refusal did not constitute a contravention of the Act was not in error. The court held that the hospital's refusal to provide a gynaecology service to PW was not discriminatory as it was based on a legitimate medical assessment rather than her gender identity.
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the Tribunal's decision that the hospital's refusal to provide a gynaecology service to PW did not contravene the Anti-Discrimination Act. The court held that the characterisation of the service by the Tribunal was a matter of fact, and there was no error in the Tribunal's decision. The court found that the hospital's refusal was based on a legitimate medical assessment rather than PW's gender identity, and therefore did not constitute discrimination under the Act. The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Tribunal was upheld.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed