Purcell v Public Curator of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
31 CLR 220

PURCELL AND OTHERS

THE PUBLIC CURATOR OF QUEENSLAND RESPONDENT

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Distress - Company - Debenture creating floating charge-Default - of payment-

Possession of company's assets taken by receiver appointed by debenture-holder- Distress for rent by landlord of premises leased to company - Rent in arrears BRISBANE,

for over two years-Company's property offered for sale by receiver-Interim injunction - Priority of claim - Companies Acts Amendment Act 1909 (Qd.) (9 Edw. VII. No. 13), sec. 18*-Companies (Winding-up) Act 1892 (Qd.) (56 Sept. 6.

Vict. No. 24), sec. 21-Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd.) (38 Vict. No. 5), secs. 143. 145.

Sec. 18 of the Companies Acts Amendment Act of 1909 (Qd.) does not adopt the scheme of distribution of assets appropriate to a winding up or an insol- vency; nor has it any reference to the general rights of creditors inter se: the section does not take away any existing right or prescribe any new right, but merely fixes a special obligation on any person availing himself of it. * Sec. 18 of the Companies Acts

shall be paid forthwith out of any assets Amendment Act of 1909 (Qd.) pro-

coming to the receiver or other person vides :- (1) Where either a receiver

taking possession as aforesaid in prior- is appointed on behalf of the holders of

ity to any claim for principal or interest any debentures of a company secured

in respect of the debentures. (2) The by a floating charge, or possession is

periods of time mentioned in the said taken by or on behalf of those deben-

provisions of the said Acts shall be ture-holders of any property comprised

reckoned from the date of the appoint in or subject to the charge, then, if the

ment of the receiver or of possession company is not at the time in course of

being taken as aforesaid, as the case being wound up, the debts which in

may be. (3) Any payments made every winding up are under the pro-

under this section shall be recouped as visions of the Companies Acts, 1863 to

far as may be out of the assets of the 1896, relating to preferential payments

company available for payment of to be paid in priority to all other debts,

general creditors.

31 CLR 221

Therefore, where a receiver appointed by the holders of a debenture creating a floating charge on the undertaking of a company took possession of the company's assets pursuant to the terms of the debenture, the right of the land- lord of the company to distrain for rent due by the company was not affected by the section.

Per Higgins J. (and semble per Knox C.J. and Gavan Duffy J.): Sec. 21 of the Companies (Winding-up) Act of 1892 (Qd.) refers to sec. 143 of the Insolvency Act of 1874 (Qd.); sec. 145 of the latter Act does not contain rules 'for determining the respective priorities of creditors," and is not imported into…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Purcell v Public Curator of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1922] HCA 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the priority of claims between a landlord and debenture-holders of a company. The appellants, debenture-holders of the Rockhampton Newspaper Co. Ltd., appointed a receiver who took possession of the company's assets due to default in payments. Subsequently, the respondent, the Public Curator of Queensland, acting as executor for a deceased landlord, initiated distress proceedings for over two years of unpaid rent. The debenture-holders sought a declaration that the landlord's claim for rent was limited to three months prior to the receiver's appointment and rent accrued thereafter, and an injunction to restrain the distress.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the appointment of a receiver by debenture-holders, under a floating charge, and the receiver's subsequent taking of possession of the company's assets, extinguished or limited the landlord's common law right to distrain for arrears of rent. This involved interpreting the interplay between the landlord's statutory and common law rights and the provisions of the *Companies Acts Amendment Act 1909* (Qd.), the *Companies (Winding-up) Act 1892* (Qd.), and the *Insolvency Act 1874* (Qd.).

The court held that section 18 of the *Companies Acts Amendment Act 1909* (Qd.) did not alter the landlord's right to distrain. This section, which mandates preferential payments by a receiver, was found not to adopt the distribution scheme of a winding-up or insolvency, nor did it affect the general rights of creditors inter se. Instead, it imposed a specific obligation on the receiver to pay certain debts in priority to the debenture-holders' claims, with a right to recoupment from the company's assets. The court reasoned that this section did not take away any existing right or prescribe a new one for other creditors, but merely fixed a special obligation on those availing themselves of its provisions. Furthermore, the court determined that section 21 of the *Companies (Winding-up) Act 1892* (Qd.), which refers to insolvency rules for determining creditor priorities, did not import section 145 of the *Insolvency Act 1874* (Qd.) into this context, as section 145 deals with the landlord's rights in insolvency, not general creditor priorities. A landlord's right to distrain was considered a common law privilege, not a secured debt, and was not affected by the statutory provisions concerning preferential payments or the appointment of a receiver when the company was not in liquidation.

The appeal was dismissed, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The landlord was therefore entitled to proceed with the distress for the full amount of rent due, notwithstanding the appointment of the receiver and the debenture-holders' claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established