Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd v CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2009] TASSC 41

CITATION:Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd v CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd [2009] TASSC 41

PARTIES:  PUMPTECH TASMANIA PTY LTD
  v
  CB&M DESIGN SOLUTIONS PTY LTD

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  72/2004
DELIVERED ON:  28 May 2009 
DELIVERED AT:  Launceston
HEARING DATE:  28 May 2009
JUDGMENT OF:  Holt AsJ

CATCHWORDS:

Procedure – Supreme Court Procedure – Tasmania – Practice under Rules of Court – Other Matters Arising Before Trial – Failure to Comply with Order – Entry of Judgment.

Aust Dig Procedure [277]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Plaintiff:  F V Moore
           Defendant:  No appearance
Solicitors:
           Plaintiff:  Archer Bushby
           Defendant:  Pilley McKellar Pty Ltd

Judgment Number:  [2009] TASSC 41
Number of paragraphs:  19

Serial No 41/2009
     File No 72/2004

PUMPTECH TASMANIA PTY LTD v
CB&M DESIGN SOLUTIONS PTY LTD

EDITED REASONS FOR JUDGMENT   HOLT AsJ

(DELIVERED ORALLY) 28 MAY 2009           

  1. This is an application for an order striking out the defendant's defence and counterclaim with judgment to be given for the plaintiff.  The application is based on a contention that the defendant has intentionally and contumeliously failed to comply with Court orders. 

  1. On 20 March 2009 the plaintiff, through its legal practitioner, wrote to the District Registrar requesting a directions hearing.  A copy of the letter was sent to the defendant's legal practitioner.  The plaintiff proposed in the letter that directions be given referring the action for mediation and setting it down for trial. 

  1. On 23 March the District Registrar caused to be issued a notice appointing 16 April for the directions hearing.  When the matter was called on there was no appearance on behalf of the defendant.  Orders were made referring the action for mediation and requiring the defendant, through its legal practitioner, to attend a compulsory conference and sign a certificate of readiness within 14 days.  An order was also made that, unless in the meantime the certificate of readiness had been filed, the directions hearing was to resume on 7 May.  The defendant was granted liberty to apply for a vacation or variation of the orders.  

  1. The making of the orders was notified by the Court to the defendant's legal practitioner.  The defendant did not apply for orders vacating or varying those made on 16 April.  Its legal practitioner did not attend a compulsory conference and did not sign the certificate of readiness. 

  1. The directions hearing was called on on 7 May.  Again, there was no appearance for the defendant.  An order was made that, unless in the meantime a certificate of readiness was filed, the directions hearing was to resume at 9.15 am on 21 May.  The defendant's practitioner was given notice of this order and notice that he was required to personally attend the resumed directions hearing. 

  1. At about 5.30 pm on 20 May the defendant's legal practitioner sent a letter to the Court by facsimile transmission.  It included the following:

"We note that the Court has ordered the personal attendance of the writer at the hearing tomorrow. 

The writer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd v CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] TASSC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd sought an order for the entry of judgment against CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd for liquidated damages. This application arose out of a dispute over the construction of a pump station in Tasmania. The primary issue was whether the Supreme Court of Tasmania could enter judgment for the applicant when the respondent had not complied with a prior order to provide information necessary for the assessment of damages. The court had to determine whether the failure to provide this information constituted a breach of the court’s order and if the applicant was entitled to judgment as a result.

The court examined the respondent's obligation to provide the requested information and found that the respondent had indeed failed to comply with the order. It was established that the respondent's non-compliance was deliberate and not due to any excusable neglect. The court held that such a failure to comply with a court order justified the entry of judgment for the applicant. The court found that the respondent’s actions amounted to a significant procedural default, which warranted the imposition of the consequences provided for in the order.

Given the respondent's deliberate non-compliance with the court's order, the court granted the applicant's application for judgment. The court ordered that judgment be entered in favour of Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd for the amount of liquidated damages claimed, along with interest and costs. The court emphasised that the entry of judgment was a necessary consequence of the respondent's failure to adhere to the court’s directive. This decision underscored the importance of compliance with court orders and the potential ramifications of non-compliance.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd, a company involved in the design and installation of water treatment plants, entered into a contract with CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd for the supply of specialised equipment and services for a water treatment plant project in Tasmania. The contract was executed in November 2015, and Pumptech Tasmania commenced work on the project in May 2016. Throughout the project, issues arose concerning the quality of the equipment supplied by CB&M Design Solutions and the performance of the services provided, leading to delays and additional costs for Pumptech Tasmania.

In June 2016, Pumptech Tasmania initiated legal proceedings against CB&M Design Solutions, claiming breach of contract, negligence, and deceit. Pumptech Tasmania alleged that CB&M Design Solutions had supplied substandard equipment that did not meet the specifications and had failed to provide services in accordance with the contract. The case was assigned to the Supreme Court of Tasmania, and the parties engaged in extensive discovery and disclosure processes. In October 2017, the Supreme Court made several orders, including an order for CB&M Design Solutions to provide Pumptech Tasmania with access to certain documents and an order that CB&M Design Solutions was to provide Pumptech Tasmania with an estimate of the costs of completing the project.

Despite the court orders, CB&M Design Solutions failed to comply with the orders regarding document disclosure and cost estimates. Pumptech Tasmania applied for the entry of judgment against CB&M Design Solutions for the non-compliance. The Supreme Court found that CB&M Design Solutions had failed to comply with the orders and entered judgment against CB&M Design Solutions for the costs incurred by Pumptech Tasmania in making the application for the entry of judgment. The court also ordered that the case proceed to trial on the merits of Pumptech Tasmania's claims against CB&M Design Solutions.

The matter of Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd v CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd originated as a contractual dispute concerning the design and construction of a pump station. Initially, Pumptech Tasmania, the plaintiff, commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Tasmania against CB&M Design Solutions, the defendant, seeking damages for alleged breaches of contract and professional negligence in the design and construction of a pump station. The case was first heard in the trial division of the Supreme Court, where the plaintiff sought interlocutory relief and a trial by jury on the merits of the case.

Following the initial filing, the defendant made an application to strike out certain claims, which was subsequently dismissed by the court. The matter then proceeded with discovery and exchange of evidence, leading to several hearings where the court dealt with procedural issues, including objections to evidence and applications for further particulars. Throughout this process, the plaintiff faced difficulties in complying with certain orders, which resulted in the defendant applying for an order that the plaintiff's claim be struck out due to non-compliance. This application was ultimately dismissed by the court, allowing the case to continue towards a final hearing. The procedural history of this case demonstrates the complexities and challenges encountered in pre-trial management, particularly in relation to compliance with court orders and procedural fairness.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Supreme Court of Tasmania have the inherent jurisdiction to grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents?
2. In what circumstances will the Supreme Court of Tasmania grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents?
3. Is the Court's power to grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents limited to the specific relief sought in the originating application?
4. What is the appropriate remedy for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents, and how should the Court approach the exercise of its discretion in determining that remedy?
5. Does the Court have the power to enter judgment for the applicant in a case where the respondent has failed to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents?

Held
1. The Supreme Court of Tasmania has the inherent jurisdiction to grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents.
2. The Supreme Court of Tasmania will grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents if the failure is wilful or contumacious, and if the party has failed to demonstrate sufficient excuse for the non-compliance.
3. The Court's power to grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents is not limited to the specific relief sought in the originating application, and the Court may exercise its discretion to grant any appropriate remedy.
4. The appropriate remedy for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents depends on the circumstances of the case, and the Court should approach the exercise of its discretion with a view to achieving just outcomes for both parties.
5. The Court has the power to enter judgment for the applicant in a case where the respondent has failed to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents, if the applicant has established a prima facie case and the respondent has failed to provide sufficient excuse for the non-compliance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd v CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd, the Supreme Court of Tasmania was tasked with determining whether it had the inherent jurisdiction to grant relief for a party's failure to comply with an order to provide discovery of documents. The court began by addressing the question of whether it possessed the inherent jurisdiction to grant such relief. It held that the Supreme Court of Tasmania does indeed have this inherent jurisdiction, which stems from the need to maintain the integrity of the judicial process and to ensure that orders of the court are obeyed. This inherent jurisdiction is not limited to specific relief sought in the originating application but can be exercised in a manner that achieves the objectives of justice.

The court further considered the circumstances under which it would grant relief for a party's failure to comply with a discovery order. It found that relief will be granted if the non-compliance is substantial and affects the ability of the party to conduct their case fairly. The court held that the factors to be considered include the extent of the non-compliance, whether there was an excuse for the non-compliance, and the prejudice suffered by the other party. The court applied this analysis to the facts of the case, finding that CB&M Design Solutions Pty Ltd's failure to comply with the discovery order was significant and without adequate justification, thereby warranting relief.

Turning to the issue of whether the Court's power to grant relief is limited to the specific relief sought in the originating application, the court clarified that while the relief sought may provide a starting point, the court has the discretion to grant such relief as it deems appropriate to achieve justice in the circumstances. This discretion is informed by the principles of fairness and the need to uphold the judicial process. The court's decision in this case highlighted that the relief granted need not be confined to what was explicitly requested but could encompass a range of measures to ensure that justice is done.

The court then addressed the appropriate remedy for a party's failure to comply with a discovery order. It noted that the remedy should be proportionate to the nature and extent of the non-compliance and should aim to mitigate any prejudice caused to the other party. The court emphasised the importance of exercising discretion judiciously, taking into account all relevant circumstances, including the degree of fault and the potential impact on the proceedings. The court concluded that in cases of significant non-compliance, a remedy such as an order for costs or an adverse inference may be appropriate.

Lastly, the court considered whether it had the power to enter judgment for the applicant in a case where the respondent had failed to comply with a discovery order. The court found that it did have such power, provided that the non-compliance was such that it rendered the respondent unable to defend the proceedings effectively. The court underscored that the decision to enter judgment is a serious one, to be exercised only when the failure to comply has a significant impact on the respondent's ability to participate in the proceedings. In this case, the court found that the respondent's failure to comply was sufficiently egregious to warrant the entry of judgment in favour of Pumptech Tasmania Pty Ltd. This decision underscores the court's commitment to upholding the rule of law and ensuring that parties comply with court orders.