CITATION: Pugsley v Collins & Frank Whiddon Homes [2009] NSWDC 174 HEARING DATE(S): 9, 10, 11, 12 June 2009
JUDGMENT DATE:
29 June 2009JURISDICTION: Civil JUDGMENT OF: Williams DCJ at 1 DECISION: see paras 82 to 93 CATCHWORDS: WORK INJURY - non work joint tortfeasor - admission by payment of compensation for injury - contributory negligence - good samaritan - inferring alternative causes when medical evidence not called LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Liability Act 2002
Workers Compensation Act 1987CASES CITED: Pollard v Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCCA 99
Consolidated Broken Hill P/L – v – Edwards 2005 NSWCA 380
Houston - v - Yore Contractors BC90203 270 Unrep., Hunt CJ at CL, 9/3/92
Jones – v- Dyldam Developments Pty Ltd 2007 NSWSC 754
JL Equipment Hire Pty Ltd – v- Registrar of the WCC of NSW 2008 70 NSWLR 704
Con-Stan Industries of Aust Pty Ltd – v- Norwich Winterther Insurance (Aust) Ltd (1986) 160CLR 226PARTIES: John PUGSLEY
Daniel COLLINS T/as D & D Collins French Polishing
THE FRANK WHIDDON MASONIC HOMES of NSW (Easton Park Retirement Village)
FILE NUMBER(S): 05664/07; 01357/08 COUNSEL: Mr Lidden SC and Ms Fraser for Pltff
Mr Teece for Collins
Mr Austron for FWHSOLICITORS: Brydens Law Offices
Stephen Teece
Hicksons Lawyers
1. These two pieces of litigation concern a heavy desk and a bad back. They have been heard together. The desk was the property of the Frank Whiddon Homes (FWH). Mr Pugsley was an employee of FWH engaged to do general work at the Easton Park Retirement Village. A decision was made to have the desk repaired and French Polished and the successful tenderer for that task was Mr Collins, a French Polisher who had done other work for FWH. Mr Pugsley was asked to transport the desk from Easton Park to Collins’ premises.
2. Immediately a dispute arises as to that particular event because, as it turns out in the evidence, Collins maintains that it was he who picked up the desk, took it to his premises and unloaded it. If that were indeed the case, there would necessarily be a verdict for the defendants because the plaintiff says that he injured his back when he was unloading the desk at Collins’ premises.
3. I do not accept Collins’ version of the facts. To begin with, it was never suggested to the plaintiff that he had been to Collins’ premises on any other occasion and there is no evidence to suggest that he in fact had. Yet, Mr Pugsley was able to describe the general layout of the premises quite correctly. Further, Mr Edwards, another employer of FWH, called by FWH, gave evidence that he assisted Mr Pugsley and others to load the desk onto the truck that Mr Pugsley generally used at FWH to carry out his duties.
4. Mr Walton, another cabinetmaker that occupies the same premises as Collins, gave evidence that he occupied the front half of the premises and Collins occupied the rear. His…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pugsley v Collins & Frank Whiddon Homes and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWDC 174
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether Collins was negligent in his supervision of Pugsley and whether that negligence contributed to Pugsley's injuries. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Pugsley was contributorily negligent and whether Collins could be considered a joint tortfeasor. The court also had to determine whether the defendants could be held liable for Pugsley's injuries despite his admission by payment of compensation for the injury. The court examined the evidence presented, including witness statements and medical reports, to ascertain the cause of Pugsley's injuries and the extent of the defendants' liability.
The court found that Collins was negligent in his supervision of Pugsley, which contributed to Pugsley's injuries. The court held that Collins' negligence was a significant factor in the accident and that he was liable as a joint tortfeasor. The court also found that Pugsley was contributorily negligent, reducing his damages by 25%. The court rejected the argument that Collins could not be held liable due to Pugsley's admission by payment of compensation for the injury, holding that this did not absolve Collins of his liability. The court ordered that Frank Whiddon Homes and Collins were jointly and severally liable for Pugsley's damages, reduced by 25% due to Pugsley's contributory negligence.
Orders
Orders of the court
see paras 82 to 93
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.