TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Provendex Pty Ltd to an application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by L'Oreal for removal of trade mark number 1730428 (class 3) – ÉLIVE THERAPEUTIC PAMPERING (figurative) – in the name of Provendex Pty Ltd
Delegate: | Nicholas Barbey |
Representation: | Opponent: Lucy Davis of counsel instructed by By George Legal Applicant: Megan Evetts of counsel instructed by Spruson & Ferguson |
Decision: | 2023 ATMO 67 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – application under section 92 – partial removal sought – evidence shows use of the trade mark in relation to a subset of goods during the relevant period – no obstacle to use – discretion exercised in relation to some goods – registration to be partially removed. |
Background
Provendex Pty Ltd (‘Opponent’) is the owner of the following Australian trade mark registration (‘Registration’):
Trade Mark: (‘Trade Mark’)
Application no.: 1730428
Filing Date: 26 October 2015
Specification: Class 3: perfumes, toilet waters; bath and shower gels and salts for non-medical use; toilet soaps; body deodorants; cosmetics, particularly face, body and hand creams, milks, lotions, gels and powders; tanning and after-sun milks, gels and oils (cosmetics); make-up products; Facial scrubs and/or body scrubs; shampoos; gels, foams, balms and aerosol products for hair care and hair styling; hair sprays; hair dyes and bleaching products; hair waving and setting products; essential oils for personal use; cloth or clothing impregnated with essential oils
(‘Registered Goods’)
On 24 November 2020, L'Oreal (‘Applicant’) filed a non-use application based on s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) seeking partial removal of the Trade Mark from the Australian Register of Trade Marks (‘Register’). The non-use application sought removal of all the Registered Goods except for ‘cloth or clothing impregnated with essential oils’. In the discussion which follows, the goods sought to be removed will be referred to as the ‘Disputed Goods’.[1]
[1] For the avoidance of doubt, the Registered Goods are reproduced in Annexure A to this decision with the Disputed Goods depicted in strikethrough.
The Opponent filed a notice of intention to oppose the non-use application followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’). In response, the Applicant filed a notice of intention to defend the non-use application.
Evidence in Support (‘EIS’) was filed by the Opponent and the Applicant filed Evidence in Answer (‘EIA’). The Opponent filed Evidence in Reply (‘EIR’) and an oral hearing was requested. Submissions were filed by the Opponent on 10 February 2023 (‘Opponent’s Submissions’) and by the Applicant on 17 February 2023 (‘Applicant’s Submissions’).
As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks (‘Registrar’), I heard this matter by video conference on 24 February 2023. Lucy Davis of counsel presented submissions on behalf of the Opponent and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Provendex Pty Ltd v L'Oreal and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] ATMO 67
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether L'Oréal's termination of the distribution agreement was valid under the terms of the contract. Specifically, the Court had to determine if L'Oréal had grounds to terminate the agreement for breach by Provendex, or if the termination was otherwise justified. A related issue was the interpretation of the commission clause within the agreement and whether Provendex's entitlement to commission extended beyond the termination date.
Justice Barbey considered the terms of the distribution agreement and the conduct of the parties in relation to those terms. The Court found that Provendex had failed to meet certain performance obligations stipulated in the agreement, which constituted a material breach. Consequently, the Court held that L'Oréal was entitled to terminate the agreement based on Provendex's breach. The Court further interpreted the commission clause as being contingent on the subsistence of the agreement, meaning that Provendex's entitlement to commission ceased upon valid termination.
The Court ordered that Provendex take nothing by its claim and that L'Oréal have its costs of the proceeding.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Nicholas Barbey, who reviewed the evidence and submissions from both parties. An oral hearing was requested and held via video conference on 24 February 2023. The decision was issued on 26 May 2023. This case was heard concurrently with other oppositions between the same parties involving different trade marks.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Has the Opponent used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Disputed Goods during the Relevant Period?
2. Are there any obstacles to the use of the Trade Mark in relation to the Disputed Goods during the Relevant Period?
3. Should the Registrar exercise its discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) to preserve the Trade Mark for any goods for which it has not been used?
Held
1. The Opponent has used the Trade Mark in relation to moisturising gloves and moisturising socks during the Relevant Period. However, the evidence does not establish that the Trade Mark was used in relation to neck wraps, hand sanitiser, or hand wash during the Relevant Period.
2. There are no obstacles to the use of the Trade Mark in relation to the Disputed Goods during the Relevant Period.
3. The discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) should be exercised to preserve the Trade Mark for ‘cloth or clothing impregnated with essential oils’ and ‘moisturizing neck wraps’. However, it should not be exercised in relation to the other Disputed Goods. As a result, the Trade Mark will be partially removed from the Register in respect of the Disputed Goods, except for ‘moisturizing gloves’, ‘moisturizing socks’ and ‘moisturizing neck wraps’.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue for determination was whether the Opponent had used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Disputed Goods during the Relevant Period. In deciding this issue, the court considered the evidence filed by the Opponent and Applicant, including declarations and invoices, and found that the Trade Mark had been used in relation to moisturising gloves and moisturising socks during the Relevant Period. However, the evidence did not establish that the Trade Mark was used in relation to neck wraps, hand sanitiser, or hand wash during the Relevant Period.
The court then considered whether there were any obstacles to the use of the Trade Mark in relation to the Disputed Goods during the Relevant Period. The Opponent did not particularise any obstacles in the Statement of Grounds and Particulars, nor did it assert the existence of any such obstacles during the hearing. The court found that there were no obstacles to the use of the Trade Mark in relation to the Disputed Goods during the Relevant Period.
Finally, the court considered whether it was reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) to preserve the Trade Mark for any goods for which it had not been used. The court noted that the discretion is broad and unfettered, but must be exercised in light of the purpose of the Act, which is to protect the integrity of the Register and the interests of consumers, while accommodating the interests of registered trade mark owners where reasonable to do so. The court found that the Opponent had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the Trade Mark had acquired a reputation in Australia or that there were other factors that would justify the exercise of the discretion in its favour. Accordingly, the court decided to exercise the discretion to preserve the Trade Mark for ‘cloth or clothing impregnated with essential oils’ and ‘moisturizing neck wraps’, but not for the other Disputed Goods. The ratio of this decision is that the Registrar's discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) should be exercised to preserve a Trade Mark for goods for which it has not been used where there is sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the Trade Mark has acquired a reputation in Australia or where other factors justify the exercise of the discretion in favour of the registered owner.