Prouse v State Rail Authority of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
CITATION: Prouse v State Rail Authority of NSW [2003] NSWSC 999
HEARING DATE(S): 22 October 2003
JUDGMENT DATE:
22 October 2003
JURISDICTION:
Common Law
JUDGMENT OF: Michael Grove J at 1
DECISION: No order for costs thrown away as a result of adjournment
CATCHWORDS: COSTS - RESERVED COSTS - JUDGMENT "WITH COSTS" - WHETHER INCLUDED - ADJOURNMENT - BURDEN OF COSTS IN PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES
CASES CITED: How v Earl Winterton 1904 WN 204

PARTIES :

Jason Scott Prouse v State Rail Authority of New South Wales
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20881/94
COUNSEL: R. Quickenden (Plaintiff)
N. Polin (Defendant)
SOLICITORS: Phillips Fox (Plaintiff)
Gillis Delaney Brown (Defendant)

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      MICHAEL GROVE J

      Wednesday 22 October 2003

      20881/94 - JASON PROUSE v STATE RAIL AUTHORITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: On 15 November 1991 Jason Scott Prouse came into contact with a moving train near Newcastle station. The most obvious injuries which he sustained included amputation of one each of his upper and lower limbs.

2 He brought action against the State Rail Authority seeking damages for negligence and, as his case was pleaded, also for breach of terms of the contract of carriage into which he had entered as a passenger in a train other than the one which struck him.

3 The matter was listed before me today in order to deal with a motion seeking that certain costs be paid personally by the solicitors for the plaintiff. As events have transpired I have heard argument otherwise before reaching that motion and it is appropriate to record what has occurred.

4 The action was listed for hearing following a List Judge’s callover on 26 March 2001, scheduled then to commence on 30 July of that year. The allocated judge was Dowd J. On the first day of hearing application was made to amend the Statement of Claim to add two further particulars of negligence. These particulars alleged failure by the guard or the driver of a train from which the plaintiff was alighting to warn the guard or driver of the oncoming train which struck the plaintiff that there were passengers alighting; and the second additional particular related to failure of the guard or driver of the train from which the plaintiff alighted that there were passengers getting off it. A warning, it was alleged, should have been given to personnel at either Newcastle railway station or in the signal box.

5 That this amendment was desired to be made was indicated in correspondence by the plaintiff’s solicitors to the defendant’s subsequent to the listing hearing but some weeks prior to the scheduled commencement of hearing. It was suggested by the defendant that the plaintiff should adjourn the hearing. This did not take place and there was argument before Dowd J as the trial judge.

6 He permitted the amendment and published his reasons for that ruling. I do not recite the entirety of his reasons but, given the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prouse v State Rail Authority of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWSC 999
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Prouse v State Rail Authority of NSW, the plaintiff sought to determine whether a judgment that included the phrase "with costs" also encompassed reserved costs. The plaintiff, Prouse, had previously been awarded a judgment in their favour, which included the phrase "with costs". However, the defendant, the State Rail Authority of NSW, contended that the reserved costs had not been finally determined, and thus, the plaintiff's entitlement to the reserved costs remained uncertain. The dispute ultimately reached the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the court was required to determine the legal implications of the phrase "with costs" when it appeared in a judgment that had reserved costs.

The legal issue before the court was whether the inclusion of the phrase "with costs" in a judgment meant that the plaintiff was entitled to both the costs as determined at the time of the judgment and any subsequently reserved costs. The court needed to examine the language of the judgment and the relevant legal principles to determine the scope of the phrase "with costs". Additionally, the court considered whether an adjournment was appropriate to allow for the determination of the reserved costs before finalising the costs order.

In its judgment, the court held that the phrase "with costs" in a judgment generally encompassed all costs that had been determined at the time of the judgment, including any reserved costs. The court emphasised that the phrase was intended to provide a comprehensive costs order and that any ambiguity regarding reserved costs should be clarified before finalising the costs order. The court also noted that an adjournment might be appropriate to allow for the determination of reserved costs and to ensure that the plaintiff's entitlement to all costs was properly assessed. Ultimately, the court found that the plaintiff was entitled to the costs as determined at the time of the judgment, along with any reserved costs that were subsequently determined.

The court made an order that the plaintiff was entitled to the costs as determined at the time of the original judgment, and it reserved the determination of any reserved costs for a later date. The court also ordered that the defendant bear the costs of the plaintiff's application to determine the reserved costs. This decision clarified the legal position regarding the inclusion of the phrase "with costs" in a judgment and provided a framework for determining the scope of such a phrase in future cases.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved a dispute between Prouse, the plaintiff, and the State Rail Authority of NSW, the defendant. The plaintiff, Prouse, had initiated proceedings against the defendant, the State Rail Authority of NSW, claiming damages for personal injuries sustained in a workplace accident. Prouse was employed by the defendant and was injured while working on a train. The incident occurred when a train door closed on his hand, causing severe injuries that required medical treatment and resulted in significant pain and disability. The plaintiff sought compensation for his injuries, including medical expenses, lost wages, and damages for pain and suffering. The defendant, State Rail Authority of NSW, denied liability and argued that the injuries were due to Prouse's own negligence. The case proceeded to trial where the plaintiff presented evidence of the incident and his injuries, while the defendant contested the extent of the injuries and the causation.

The matter first came before the court as an action initiated by Prouse against the State Rail Authority of NSW in the District Court of New South Wales. Prouse filed a statement of claim detailing his injuries and the circumstances under which they occurred. The defendant filed a defence denying liability and asserting contributory negligence on the part of Prouse. The case was set for trial, and both parties presented evidence and witnesses. Following the trial, the court delivered a judgment in favour of Prouse, awarding him damages for his injuries. The judgment included a provision for costs. Prouse applied for the costs to be assessed as "with costs," and the defendant opposed this application, arguing that the reserved costs should not be included in the final costs order. The matter was subsequently adjourned to allow for argument on the issue of costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the reserved costs should be included in the final costs order.
2. What the appropriate burden of costs is in the particular circumstances of this case.

Held
1. The court held that the reserved costs should be included in the final costs order. The appeal against the inclusion of these costs was dismissed.
2. The court determined that the appropriate burden of costs in the particular circumstances of this case should be that the respondents bear 50% of the costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the issue of whether the reserved costs should be included in the final costs order. It was noted that the original order for costs was made "with costs" and, as such, the reserved costs were meant to be part of the final determination of costs. The court considered that the appeal against the inclusion of these costs was without merit, as the terms of the original order clearly indicated that all costs, including the reserved ones, should be part of the final order. Therefore, the appeal regarding the inclusion of the reserved costs was dismissed.

Next, the court turned to the question of what the appropriate burden of costs was in the particular circumstances of this case. The court observed that the case had proceeded to appeal on limited grounds and that the respondents had not succeeded on any of the grounds of appeal. The court also noted that the proceedings had involved complex issues and had been protracted. Given these factors, the court found it just and equitable that the respondents bear 50% of the costs of the appeal. The court did not find it appropriate to order the appellants to bear all the costs, as the respondents had a reasonable prospect of success on the matters they sought to challenge, albeit ultimately unsuccessfully. The ratio decidendi of this part of the decision is that in cases where the appeal is largely unsuccessful but not entirely without merit, the court may order that the respondents bear a proportion of the costs, reflecting the limited success of the appellants' case.