Prothonotary v Hirata

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
CITATION: Prothonotary v Hirata [2000] NSWSC 684
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 12414/90
HEARING DATE(S): 12/04/2000
JUDGMENT DATE: 12 April 2000

PARTIES :


Prothonotary v Kay Keiko Hirata
JUDGMENT OF: James J at 1
COUNSEL : M Sexton SC/K Nomchong - Plaintiff
R F Greenwood QC - Defendant
SOLICITORS: IV Knight - Plaintiff
Jenny Bull & Company - Defendant
DECISION: Penalty imposed

      THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      JAMES J

      WEDNESDAY 12 APRIL 2000

      12414/99- PROTHONOTARY v KAY KEIKO HIRATA

      JUDGMENT

1   HIS HONOUR: On 10 March 2000 I found the defendant, Kay Keiko Hirata, guilty of having committed a contempt of court. Yesterday and to-day I have conducted a hearing on what penalty, if any, should be imposed. On 10 March I delivered a judgment on liability and that judgment on liability is to be read with the present judgment.

2   The defendant is a solicitor, who acted as the solicitor instructing defence counsel in the courtroom in a criminal trial held in the District Court in April and May 1999 before her Honour Judge Latham and a jury in courtroom 1.1 in the Downing Centre, Sydney. During the trial the defendant formed the belief that a member of the jury, who I referred to in my judgment of 10 March as Mr S, might be a person named Carl Gibson who she had known many years previously.

3   On Friday 28 May 1999 the jury retired to consider their verdict in the criminal trial. In the afternoon of 28 May the jury, not having reached a verdict, were permitted by her Honour Judge Latham to separate for the weekend. In the late afternoon of 28 May a number of members of the jury and the defendant went separately to the same hotel near the court building.

4   In my judgment of 10 March I found that at the hotel the defendant found herself in close proximity to Mr S; that she immediately recognised Mr S as being the juror at the trial who she thought might be Carl Gibson; that she still believed that he might be Carl Gibson; that she spoke to Mr S; that she claimed, in what she said to Mr S, to know him and obtained confirmation from him that he was a member of the jury; and that, knowing that the person that she was speaking to was a member of the jury, she said that she had something for him, produced an envelope and held the envelope out towards the juror. On the outside of the envelope were written the words, "for Carl Gibson (Juror) courtroom 1.1". There was nothing inside the envelope. The juror did not take hold of the envelope and did not read what was written on the outside of the envelope. At this stage the foreman of the jury, who was also at the hotel, intervened.

5   On 10 March I found that the conduct of the defendant constituted a contempt of court, as having, as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prothonotary v Hirata and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 684
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Prothonotary v Hirata, the defendant, Kay Keiko Hirata, was found guilty of contempt of court by James J on 10 March 2000. The hearing on penalty took place on 12 April 2000. Hirata, a solicitor, had been found guilty of attempting to communicate with a juror during a criminal trial, thereby breaching the sanctity of the jury system. The court had to decide on the appropriate penalty for Hirata's actions, balancing the objective seriousness of the offence with mitigating circumstances such as Hirata's lack of intent to interfere with the administration of justice and her already suffering extra-curial punishment.

The legal issues revolved around the appropriate punishment for contempt of court, taking into account the nature of the offence, the defendant's subjective circumstances, and the potential impact on the defendant's financial situation. The court considered the defendant's lack of experience, her impaired judgment due to alcohol and medication, her good character, and the potential for further disciplinary action by the Legal Services Commission. The court also deliberated on whether to impose costs on the defendant, considering the substantial costs incurred by the plaintiff, represented by the Solicitor-General.

James J concluded that while Hirata's conduct was objectively serious, there were mitigating factors, such as her lack of intent to interfere with the justice process and her already suffering extra-curial penalties. The court imposed a fine of $2,000, suspended for two years, contingent on Hirata's good behaviour, and ordered her to pay the plaintiff's costs, which were assessed at approximately $35,000. The court acknowledged the potential hardship this order might cause but deemed it necessary to uphold the integrity of the judicial process. The court also left open the possibility of revisiting the form of the recognisance or the quantum of the costs in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established