Proctor v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MERIT REVIEWER

CITATION:

Proctor v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2025] NSWPICMR 23

CLAIMANT:

Graeme Proctor

INSURER:

QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

MERIT REVIEWER:

Katherine Ruschen

DATE OF DECISION:

20 August 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; merit review; dispute about payment of weekly benefits under Division 3.3; pre-accident weekly earnings (PAWE); meaning of PAWE; Schedule 1, clause 4(1) and 4(2)(a1); partnership earnings and sole trader earnings; whether loss of partnership to be taken into account when calculating PAWE; Held – the reviewable decision is set aside.

DETERMINATIONS MADE: 

CERTIFICATE

Issued under s 7.13(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017

The reviewable decision is about the amount of weekly payments of statutory benefits payable under Division 3.3 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) and is therefore a merit review matter under Schedule 2(1)(a) of the MAI Act.

1.     The reviewable decision is set aside.

2.     The claimant’s pre-accident weekly earnings (PAWE) amount is $651.71.

3. The matter is referred back to the Personal Injury Commission for determination of the parties’ application for costs under s 8.3(4) of the MAI Act.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. There is a dispute between Graeme Proctor (the claimant) and the insurer about the amount of the claimant’s pre-accident weekly earnings (PAWE) for the purpose of weekly payments of statutory benefits under Division 3.3 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act).

  2. The claimant was involved in a motor accident on 15 November 2024.

  3. The claimant lodged an application for personal injury benefits on 26 November 2024.

  4. On 9 April 2025 the insurer determined that the claimant was an earner for the purpose of the MAI Act but calculated his PAWE as nil.

  5. On 6 May 2025 the claimant requested an internal review of the insurer’s decision dated
    9 April 2025.

  6. On 21 May 2025 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which the insurer varied their PAWE decision by calculating the claimant’s PAWE amount as being $596.46.

  1. The claimant has requested a merit review of the insurer’s internal review decision dated
    21 May 2025 (the Application).

DIRECTIONS

  1. In his original submissions for this merit review the claimant submitted his PAWE falls under cl 4(2)(a). The claimant also stated the insurer agreed with this. This understanding appears to be based on the insurer’s internal review decision which stated cl 4(2)(a) applies. However, the insurer’s submissions in reply to this merit review now state the insurer’s position is that the claimant’s PAWE falls under cl 4(2)(a1).

  2. As the insurer’s position has changed, as a matter of procedural fairness interim directions were issued to the parties on 15 July 2025, which provided:

    (a) the claimant with an opportunity to clarify which sub-clause in cl 4 he relies on for calculation of his PAWE and to make further submissions and/or provide further documents;

    (b)    the insurer with an opportunity to provide any further reply, and

    (c)    the parties with an opportunity to request a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Proctor v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMR 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Proctor v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, the applicant sought a merit review of the insurer’s decision regarding the calculation of pre-accident weekly earnings (PAWE) under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The central issue revolved around the appropriate calculation of PAWE, specifically whether the loss of earnings from a farming partnership should be taken into account in the PAWE calculation. The insurer had initially agreed to apply Schedule 1, clause 4(2)(a), but later argued that clause 4(2)(a1) was more appropriate. The dispute was resolved through a merit review process conducted on the papers, with both parties complying with the interim directions issued by the court.

The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of Schedule 1, clause 4(2) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, particularly the distinction between clause 4(2)(a) and clause 4(2)(a1) in the context of calculating PAWE. The court had to determine whether the loss of earnings from a farming partnership should be considered in the PAWE calculation, and whether the claimant’s proposed method of averaging earnings over a three to five year period was permissible under the Act. Additionally, the court needed to assess the insurer’s contention that income from cattle sales in 2025, which represented delayed income from 2024, should be included in the PAWE calculation.

The court found that the insurer’s interpretation of clause 4(2)(a1) was correct and set aside the insurer’s internal review decision. The court held that the loss of earnings from the farming partnership should not be taken into account in the PAWE calculation, as it did not align with the statutory provisions. Furthermore, the court agreed with the insurer that the claimant’s proposed method of averaging earnings over a three to five year period was not permissible under the Act. The court also rejected the claimant’s argument that income from cattle sales in 2025 should be included in the PAWE calculation, finding that it did not conform with the statutory requirements.

In light of the court’s determination, the reviewable decision issued by the insurer on 21 May 2025 was set aside. The matter was remitted to the insurer for reconsideration in accordance with the court’s findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 21 May 2025 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which the insurer varied their PAWE decision by calculating the claimant’s PAWE amount as being $596.46. The claimant has requested a merit review of the insurer’s internal review decision dated 21 May 2025 (the Application). In his original submissions for this merit review the claimant submitted his PAWE falls under cl 4(2)(a). The claimant also stated the insurer agreed with this. This understanding appears to be based on the insurer’s internal review decision which stated cl 4(2)(a) applies. However, the insurer’s submissions in reply to this merit review now state the insurer’s position is that the claimant’s PAWE falls under cl 4(2)(a1). As the insurer’s position has changed, as a matter of procedural fairness interim directions were issued to the parties on 15 July 2025, which provided:(a) the claimant with an opportunity to clarify which sub-clause in cl 4 he relies on for calculation of his PAWE and to make further submissions and/or provide further documents; (b) the insurer with an opportunity to provide any further reply, and(c) the parties with an opportunity to request a preliminary conference if they considered this should occur as part of conduct of the merit review. On 29 July 2025 the claimant was granted an extension of time, by consent of the parties, to comply with the directions. Both parties have complied with the directions. Neither party requested a preliminary conference. The matter is therefore determined “on the papers”. At all material times the claimant generated earnings as a self-employed farmer and from a farming partnership (his business partner died in September 2024). In his application for personal injury benefits the claimant stated he earned $1,374 per week before the accident based on the combined weekly average as a sole trader and in partnership calculated by his accountant over a three-year period (the 2021, 2022 and 2023 financial years). When requesting the internal review, the claimant submitted that:(a) taking a weekly average over 12 months does not accurately represent the nature of a farming business where earnings fluctuate year to year as a result of a range of circumstances, including flooding and that his PAWE should therefore be averaged over a three to five year period (as his accountant did), and(b) income received from cattle sales in 2025 should be included in calculation of PAWE as this represents delayed income that would have been received in 2024 but for the death of his business partner. It is understood from final submissions received from the claimant in this merit review that the claimant no longer presses his points at paragraph 13 above, having accepted the insurer’s position (given in the context of the internal review process) that the MAI Act does not permit either of these things. I agree with the insurer’s position in this regard. For completeness I will give brief reasons why when addressing cl 4 below.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.