Procter & Gamble Australia Pty Ltd v Energizer Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Procter & Gamble Australia Pty Limited v Energizer Pty Limited
[2011] FCA 1347

Citation: Procter & Gamble Australia Pty Limited v Energizer Pty Limited [2011] FCA 1347
Parties: PROCTER & GAMBLE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED ACN 008 396 245 v ENERGIZER AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED ACN 003 539 026
File number: NSD 121 of 2011
Judge: BENNETT J
Date of judgment: 29 November 2011
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – respondent admits making representation in promotional materials that respondent’s products have a hydrating effect on the skin of the user during shaving process – whether representation contravenes ss 18(1) and 29(1)(g) of Australian Consumer Law – whether hydrating effect is greater than de minimis

TRADE PRACTICES – whether respondent made representation in promotional materials that respondent’s products have a hydrating effect on the skin of the user after shaving process – relevance of nature of product – relevance of absence of evidence of consumer complaint or consumer misunderstanding

TRADE PRACTICES – whether respondent made representation in promotional materials that respondent’s products provide best shave for user in comparison to other products – whether respondent’s claims are mere puffery

Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 4, 18(1), 29(1)(g)
Cases cited:

ACCC v Dukemaster Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 682 cited

ACCC v Henry Kaye and National Investment Institute Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1363 cited
Annand & Thompson Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission [1979] 25 ALR 91 cited
Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations Inc v Tobacco Institute of Australia Limited (1991) 27 FCR 149 cited
Cadbury Schweppes v Darrell Lea (No 4) (2006) 229 ALR 136 cited
Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 45 applied
Jainran Pty Ltd v Boyana [2008] NSWSC 468 applied
Kulikovsky v Police [2010] SASC 58 cited
Lymquartz v 2 Elizabeth Bay Road [2007] NSWSC 457 cited
Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 191 followed
Taco Co of Australia Inc v Taco Bell Pty Ltd (1982) 42 ALR 177 cited
Tillmanns Butcheries Pty Ltd v Australasian Meat Industry Employees' Union (1979) 27 ALR 367 cited

Date of hearing: 5-9, 14-16 and 23 September 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 317
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Robb QC with Mr T Breakspear
Solicitor for the Applicant: Colin Biggers & Paisley
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Hennessy
Solicitor for the Respondent: Gilbert + Tobin

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 121 of 2011

BETWEEN:

PROCTER & GAMBLE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
(ACN 008 396 245)
Applicant

AND:

ENERGIZER AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
(ACN 003 539 026)
Respondent

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 November 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties are to submit proposed agreed orders by 6 December 2011.

2.If the parties are unable to agree proposed orders, each party should submit proposed orders, including orders as to costs, by 9…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Procter & Gamble Australia Pty Ltd v Energizer Australia Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1347
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Procter & Gamble Australia Pty Ltd (P&G) brought an action against Energizer Australia Pty Ltd (Energizer) for false and misleading representations in relation to the hydrating effects of certain wet shaving products. The court was required to determine whether Energizer's promotional materials breached sections 18(1) and 29(1)(g) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by claiming that its Hydro Products have a hydrating effect on the skin of users during the shaving process and whether the hydrating effect was greater than de minimis. Additionally, the court needed to assess if Energizer had represented that its products provide the best shave in comparison to other products and whether such claims constituted mere puffery.

The court found that Energizer did make representations in its promotional materials that its Hydro Products have a hydrating effect on the user’s skin during the shaving process. The court relied on expert evidence to establish that there is indeed an increase in skin hydration that lasts from the application of the Hydro Polyox until the face is dried after rinsing. The court also determined that the reasonable consumer, who is a male of shaving age with a high level of familiarity with exaggerated claims in wet shaving products, would interpret these representations as conveying a significant hydrating effect rather than a mere transitory one. The court concluded that these representations were misleading and deceptive, as the hydrating effect, while present, was transitory and of a de minimis nature. Furthermore, the court found that claims regarding the Hydro Products providing the best shave were not mere puffery but were substantiated by the evidence presented.

The court ordered that the parties submit proposed agreed orders by a specified date, with an alternative requirement for each party to submit their proposed orders if agreement could not be reached. The court also allowed for short written submissions if the parties chose to accompany their proposed orders with them.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to submit proposed agreed orders by 6 December 2011.

2. If the parties are unable to agree proposed orders, each party should submit proposed orders, including orders as to costs, by 9 December 2011. If desired, the proposed orders may be accompanied by short written submissions of no more than 2 pages, in normal font and spacing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

The majority of the parties’ evidence was directed to establishing whether the Hydro Products provide a moisturising/hydrating effect on the user’s face during the shaving process.Background Skin hydration, moisturisation and skin lubrication Professor Lavker describes “skin hydration” as the amount of moisture in the outer layer of the skin, a definition that he says is, in his experience, accepted by dermatologists, cutaneous biologists and individuals in the cosmeceutical industry. It can be achieved by short-term means, such as when water is applied to the skin surface, or longer term, as in the case of occlusion, which “seals” the skin to prevent evaporation. In contrast, skin moisturisation is the process of delivering agents that restore the lipid bilayer of the stratum corneum (SC), add moisturising ingredients and promote the removal of the outermost cells of the SC (desquamation). The term “moisturisation” is, as described by Professor Lavker, product and context-dependent. Professor Humbert draws a distinction between moisturisation, which he describes as a dynamic state leading to hydration of the skin, and hydration, which he describes as a static state of hydrated skin. He explains that the act of moisturisation leads to the hydrated state of the skin. The hydration effect is a state at a given time “t”, whereas moisturisation has a particular temporal aspect. It denotes a period of time during which the skin will benefit from the emollient effect. Skin lubrication occurs when a substance is applied to the skin that influences friction. Lubrication of the skin can be effectively achieved by water, aqueous surfactants and oil-based products. This aspect of skin care is also product and/or formula dependent. There is no dispute between the experts that hydration means the addition and retention of water in the skin. Water is required to maintain a properly functioning SC. Thus, skin hydration is beneficial. As Dr Rawlings explains it, simply adding water to the skin will not “hydrate” the skin in any meaningful way because the water will evaporate from the skin’s surface. Water does not hydrate the skin for a sufficiently long time truly to moisturise the skin. Long-lasting hydration, rather than the masking of skin dryness by emolliency, is provided either by the application of ingredients that bind water, which then reside on the skin’s surface or penetrate into the surface layers of the skin, or by the application of ingredients that reduce the loss of water from the surface layers of the skin. As explained by Dr Janet Coope-Epstein, a Development Chemist working for Energizer Inc who was part of the team that developed the Hydro Products, the latter occurs by retarding the evaporation of water on the skin surface. Humectants are classified in the former category. They hold on to water and help retain water in the skin. Occlusive agents are in the latter category. Both are commonly found in moisturisers that provide long-lasting hydration of the skin.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is not in dispute that the wet shaving process includes the use of pre-shave products, water, shaving creams and gels and post-shave products.EVIDENCE ON THE TRANSIENT HYDRATION REPRESENTATION The majority of the parties’ evidence was directed to establishing whether the Hydro Products provide a moisturising/hydrating effect on the user’s face during the shaving process.Background Skin hydration, moisturisation and skin lubrication Professor Lavker describes “skin hydration” as the amount of moisture in the outer layer of the skin, a definition that he says is, in his experience, accepted by dermatologists, cutaneous biologists and individuals in the cosmeceutical industry. It can be achieved by short-term means, such as when water is applied to the skin surface, or longer term, as in the case of occlusion, which “seals” the skin to prevent evaporation. In contrast, skin moisturisation is the process of delivering agents that restore the lipid bilayer of the stratum corneum (SC), add moisturising ingredients and promote the removal of the outermost cells of the SC (desquamation). The term “moisturisation” is, as described by Professor Lavker, product and context-dependent. Professor Humbert draws a distinction between moisturisation, which he describes as a dynamic state leading to hydration of the skin, and hydration, which he describes as a static state of hydrated skin. He explains that the act of moisturisation leads to the hydrated state of the skin. The hydration effect is a state at a given time “t”, whereas moisturisation has a particular temporal aspect. It denotes a period of time during which the skin will benefit from the emollient effect. Skin lubrication occurs when a substance is applied to the skin that influences friction. Lubrication of the skin can be effectively achieved by water, aqueous surfactants and oil-based products. This aspect of skin care is also product and/or formula dependent. There is no dispute between the experts that hydration means the addition and retention of water in the skin. Water is required to maintain a properly functioning SC. Thus, skin hydration is beneficial. As Dr Rawlings explains it, simply adding water to the skin will not “hydrate” the skin in any meaningful way because the water will evaporate from the skin’s surface. Water does not hydrate the skin for a sufficiently long time truly to moisturise the skin. Long-lasting hydration, rather than the masking of skin dryness by emolliency, is provided either by the application of ingredients that bind water, which then reside on the skin’s surface or penetrate into the surface layers of the skin, or by the application of ingredients that reduce the loss of water from the surface layers of the skin. As explained by Dr Janet Coope-Epstein, a Development Chemist working for Energizer Inc who was part of the team that developed the Hydro Products, the latter occurs by retarding the evaporation of water on the skin surface.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Professor Humbert was only cross-examined on the relevance of the EEMCO guidelines.Conclusion I accept that the evidence establishes that, by reason of the Hydro Polyox in the Hydro Products, there is an increase in hydration of the skin that lasts from the time of application of the Hydro Polyox until the face is dried after rinsing. That is, the hydration effect exists for the duration of the shaving process.THE REASONABLE CONSUMER As is evident from Campomar, the Court is required to identify the characteristics of the class of consumers to whom a representation is alleged to have been made in order to assess whether the representation has been conveyed. It does not appear to be in dispute that the class of persons to whom the Hydro Materials is addressed is large, comprising males of shaving age. However, the characteristics of the reasonable consumer are in dispute. Energizer contends that the nature of the hypothetical consumer is crucial to understanding the relevant background and context in which the hypothetical consumer would understand the Hydro Materials. Energizer points to the unchallenged evidence of Mr De Beer, Energizer’s Marketing Manager for Personal Care products, together with the evidence of Dr Coope-Epstein, Mr Andrews, a solicitor representing Energizer, and Ms Zupkovsky, the Research and Development Blade & Razor Claims Innovation Leader at P&G, in contending that the hypothetical reasonable consumer displays the following characteristics and awareness:·He knows that the wet shaving process involves multiple steps including preparation, lathering up, shaving and moisturising and is aware that there are different products for each step.·He is familiar with the distinction between pre-shave and post-shave moisturising products, as well as traditional “leave-on” cosmetic moisturisers.·He is familiar with the use of the term “hydration” in connection with products which hydrate the body or skin, such as sports and soft drinks, and knows that the term does not refer only to moisturisers. He knows that the image of water is synonymous with hydration rather than moisturising.·He is aware that razors commonly incorporate features traditionally described as “comfort strips” to lubricate the skin in order to make shaving a more comfortable experience.·He regards a new razor blade cartridge as expensive and is reluctant to change brands due to the “investment” made in the handle of his existing razor. However, he is prepared to switch brands in response to technological innovations.·Novel and interesting product names and eye-catching and appealing promotional campaigns incorporating elements of surprise may alert him to unexpected product innovations.·He has a high familiarity with exaggerated claims being made in relation to wet shaving and other personal care products.·He is familiar with the common use of exaggerated water techniques in advertisements, such as for soft drinks and sports drinks. ·He has a high level of awareness of the Gillette brand, which he regards as synonymous with the razor product category. Accordingly, he has a high level of familiarity with the branding, slogans, advertising and other promotion devices used in relation to Gillette, including the widespread use of “best”; for example “Best A Man Can Get”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Energizer contends that it is only necessary for it prove that there is a moisturising/hydrating effect and that the extent of such an effect is not part of the case brought by P&G. Energizer relies on P&G’s Second Further Amended Statement of Claim, which relevantly states:13.[Through the Hydro Material Energizer has] represented to the public, including to consumers and potential consumers of the [Hydro] Products… that:(a)the use of the [Hydro] Products will have a moisturising effect on the user’s skin;(b)the benefits of the increased moisturisation or hydration will continue after shaving;(c)the hydration effect claimed by [Energizer] will not be a transitory effect during shaving;(d)the hydration effect claimed by [Energizer] will not be limited to the lubrication of the shaving process;or some of those representations. (The representations set out in sub-paragraphs (a) to (d) are collectively called the Hydration Representations).…17.The Hydration Representations, and each of them, are and were false and misleading and deceptive in that:(a)the use of the [Hydro] Products will not generally, or at all, have a moisturising effect on the user’s skin;(b)[deleted](c)the user of the [Hydro] Products will not experience a moisturising effect that will be of a degree sufficient to have a significant beneficial effect on the user’s skin;(d)any moisturising effect on the cells of the user’s skin which does occur will be insignificant and transitory and will not continue for any significant period after the conclusion of the shaving process;(e)the Hydrating Gel Reservoir and the Lubricating Gel Reservoir components of the [Hydro] Products have substantially identical ingredients, which principally provide lubrication during the shaving process;(f)there is no, or no reasonable and adequate, scientific foundation for making the Hydration Representations;(g)the ingredients incorporated by [Energizer] into the Hydrating Gel Reservoir and the Lubricating Gel Reservoir are not physically and chemically capable of moisturising or hydrating the face of the user in the manner claimed by [Energizer] in the Hydration Representations to any significant or measurable degree. Energizer says that P&G’s case has been pleaded on the basis that the only representations which arise in respect of the hydrating properties of the Hydro Products are those pleaded in [13] of P&G’s Second Further Amended Statement of Claim. Energizer says that there is a fundamental disconformity between the representations pleaded in [13] and the pleaded facts alleged to give rise to the falsity of those representations in [17] of P&G’s Second Further Amended Statement of Claim. Energizer submits that the pleaded facts in [17] cannot establish the falsity of the representation in [13(a)] because each of the pleaded facts in [17] allows for the Hydro Products to have “a” moisturising effect (with the exception of [17(f)], which has no bearing at all). Energizer points out that P&G has not alleged that Energizer has made a representation with respect to the Hydro Products having a “significant beneficial effect”.