Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   PROCESS MINERALS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD -v- CONSOLIDATED MINERALS PTY LTD [2012] WASC 268

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   22 - 24 MAY 2012

DELIVERED          :   31 JULY 2012

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1067 of 2012

BETWEEN:   PROCESS MINERALS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

CONSOLIDATED MINERALS PTY LTD
First Defendant

PILBARA MANGANESE PTY LTD
Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Preliminary issue - Contractual construction - Tailings - Mining waste - Fines material - High iron unbeneficiated fines - Stemming and sheeting uses - Characterisation as waste - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Preliminary issue determined in favour of the defendants

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr M L Bennett & Mr M J M Nas

First Defendant             :     Mr S Penglis & Mr S M Standing

Second Defendant         :     Mr S Penglis & Mr S M Standing

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Bennett & Co

First Defendant             :     Freehills

Second Defendant         :     Freehills

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 266

Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 219

KENNETH MARTIN J: 

Introduction

  1. This trial of preliminary issue involves a question of contentious characterisation concerning whether a class of material satisfies the definition of 'Super Fines' which is found in an agreement between the parties dated 10 September 1996, known as the Super Fines Agreement (the SFA).  The SFA has been the subject of earlier consideration in prior litigation between the same parties.  In action CIV 2272 of 2009, after a lengthy trial concerning issues of construction and interpretation involving numerous agreements between the parties, including the SFA, I delivered reasons for decision on 30 September 2010:  see Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 266. That decision was then the subject of appeals and cross‑appeals to the Court of Appeal where reasons were delivered on 13 October 2011: see Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 219.

  2. In the earlier litigation it was accepted that certain manganese fines material of a dimension less than 1.2 mm, found dry stockpiled at the defendants' manganese ore tenements at Woodie Woodie, constituted 'Super Fines' under the SFA. Accordingly this material was the property of the plaintiff (PMI) to process at its secondary manganese processing plant at Woodie Woodie. Small particles of manganese ore suspended in the slurry pumped directly from the defendants' processing plant at Woodie Woodie to PMI's adjacent plant were also accepted as meeting the SFA's definition of 'Super Fines' in that litigation. The controversy in [2010] WASC 266 was over another category of the defendants' stockpiled waste material. This dry material was uniformly of a much larger dimension and was known as 'coarse rejects'.

  3. The relevant issue of construction in the earlier litigation was whether coarse rejects fit within par (b) of the SFA's definition of Super Fines.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minera... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd, the parties disputed the characterisation of certain mining waste, specifically high iron unbeneficiated fines (HIUBF), under the South Australian Mining and Petroleum Act 2014. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether these materials, which were stockpiled for uses such as stemming and sheeting, should be considered waste under the Act.

The central legal issue revolved around the interpretation of the term "tailings" and whether the defendants' decisions to use HIUBF in non-saleable activities, such as stemming and sheeting, indicated an intention to discard the material, thus rendering it waste. The court had to consider whether the defendants' decisions to stockpile HIUBF constituted a determination that it was waste at the time of separation or if this determination could be deferred. Additionally, the court needed to decide if a class of HIUBF could remain of indeterminate status for an extended period, potentially affecting commercial interests due to fluctuating market conditions.

The court found that the defendants' decisions to use HIUBF for non-commercial purposes did not necessarily indicate an intention to discard it as waste. The court held that the characterisation of the material as waste depended on the defendants' intent at the time the material was separated and not on later decisions regarding its use. The court also concluded that the material could not be considered waste until a clear decision was made by the defendants to discard it. This interpretation prevented the existence of batches of HIUBF with indeterminate status, which could have significant commercial implications.

The court ordered that the defendants' decisions to use HIUBF for non-commercial purposes did not alone render the material waste. The characterisation as waste hinged on the defendants' intent at the time of separation. The court's decision provided clarity on the timing and conditions under which HIUBF could be considered waste, thus impacting the commercial viability of the mining operations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Third, PMI's primary argument at par 20 of its pleading, by reference to pars 20.2, 20.3 and 20.4, explicitly grounds itself upon the defendants' so‑called decisions about HIUBF. Each of those three subparagraphs is conjoined to par 20.1, as regards a prior separation of HIUBF, after crushing and washing. As formulated, then, mere separation of HIUBF by the defendants after crushing and washing is not contended by PMI to be enough of itself to render the HIUBF tailings waste. More is needed. The something more, as pleaded in pars 20.2, 20.3 and 20.4, is the subjective intent of the defendants underlying their decisions concerning the HIUBF. Fourth, as now seen, PMI seems to advance its primary case on the basis that any decision of the defendants to use HIUBF in anything other than in saleable product delivers a conclusion that the HIUBF must be waste, thus tailings, and thus Super Fines. Fifth, decisions by the defendants to use HIUBF that is stockpiled for non‑sale activities such as stemming (for blasting) or sheeting (for a road base), carries a conclusion, on PMI's case, that the HIUBF's recoverability and value after being used in that fashion is destroyed. Hence, argues PMI, the HIUBF is being dealt with by the defendants in a manner that shows that in truth it is regarded by the defendants as their waste, thus tailings, and thus Super Fines. Sixth, a decision by the defendants to stockpile HIUBF, on PMI's case, can provide a platform to draw a conclusion that the defendants have discarded the material and therefore assessed it to be waste (but as mentioned, par 20.1 of the statement of claim and its words 'and then', suggest separation alone is not enough). Seventh, a temporal question presents over when the assessment is to be rendered as to whether any affirmative decision has been made by the defendants to treat HIUBF as waste or not. Must an affirmative decision of the defendants that a batch of HIUBF is waste be made at, or proximate to, the time that the HIUBF material, having been crushed and washed, leaves the defendants' wash plant? Or, could a decision by the defendants as to waste be deferred, to be made later, perhaps much later (ie many years), after the HIUBF has sat unused in stockpile at Woodie Woodie? Eighth, correlatively to seven, by reference to par 21 of the statement of claim (on PMI's alternative case), can there be a class of HIUBF of indeterminate character, which only acquires its characterisation (for the purposes of the SFA) as waste at a later point in time, once the defendants do finally reach a decision not to use a batch or batches of HIUBF as sale product? From that last situation a commerciality issue may immediately be seen to arise. Can it be countenanced (perhaps for years) that there are batches of stockpiled HIUBF at Woodie Woodie of indeterminate status? This is in circumstances where world manganese prices, as well as the demands of particular purchasers and customer tolerances for iron in manganese fines, can and do obviously fluctuate over time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established