Price v ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Price v ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited [2024] NSWSC 706
Hearing dates: 3, 16 May 2024
Date of orders: 12 June 2024
Decision date: 12 June 2024
Jurisdiction:Equity - Applications List
Before: Kunc J
Decision:

Motion for release from implied undertaking dismissed with costs

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE — Implied undertakings — Release from — Special circumstances — Insurer seeks release in proceedings concerning TPD policy to use in assessing plaintiff’s claim under income protection policy

Cases Cited:

Ambridge Investments Pty Ltd v Baker [2010] VSC 545

Clark v National Australia Limited (2019) 136 ACSR 329 [2019] FCA 933

Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Plowman (1995) 183 CLR 10; [1995] HCA 19

Gavan v FSS Trustee Corporation [2019] NSWSC 667

Hazell-Wright v 32 Domain Pty Ltd [2020] VSCA 129

Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125; [2008] HCA 36

Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Phoenix Capital Ltd (2005) 218 ALR 283; [2005] FCAFC 3

Northbuild Constructions Pty Ltd v Discovery Beach Project Pty Ltd [2011] 1 Qd R 145; [2009] QCA 345

Prudential Assurance Co v Fountain Page Ltd [1991] 3 All ER 878

Riddick v Thames Board Mills Ltd [1977] 3 All ER 677

Springfield Nominees Pty Ltd v Bridgelands Securities Limited (1992) 38 FCR 217

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Russell Price (Plaintiff)
ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited (First Defendant)
ClearView Life Assurance Limited (Second Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
M Gollan (Plaintiff)
C Purdy (Second Defendant)

Solicitors:
Firths Superannuation Lawyers (Plaintiff)
HWL Ebsworth (Second Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/00303840

JUDGMENT

Summary

  1. This judgment concerns the operation of what is variously referred to as the “implied undertaking”, the “Harman undertaking”, the “implied obligation” or the obligation discussed in Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125; [2008] HCA 36. In these reasons I will refer to it as the implied undertaking.

  2. These proceedings are a claim by the plaintiff, Mr Price, under a life insurance policy issued by the second defendant (ClearView Life Assurance Limited) for a total and permanent disablement (TPD) benefit. Mr Price alleges that from April 2019 he has been TPD within the meaning of the policy (TPD Policy) due to a major depressive condition, thereby entitling him to a lump sum benefit. ClearView, by its defence in these proceedings, does not admit that allegation.

  3. Mr Price has a separate policy with ClearView (IP Policy) for income protection (IP) cover. From July 2019, and by subsequent claims lodged approximately monthly, Mr Price has claimed monthly payments of IP benefits of approximately $14,000 per month. Those claims have been accepted and paid by ClearView. There is currently no notified dispute, and no litigation, between Mr Price and ClearView concerning his entitlement to payments under the IP Policy.

  4. During the course of these proceedings in relation to the TPD Policy, various reports, affidavits and documents have been produced pursuant to the processes of the Court and become available to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Price v ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWSC 706
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Price brought an action against ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited, an insurance company, concerning a Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) policy. The dispute arose from the insurer’s refusal to pay the policy benefits, which the plaintiff claimed were due under the terms of the policy. The court was tasked with determining whether the insurer was bound by an implied undertaking to use the proceedings in the TPD policy case for assessing the plaintiff’s claim under an income protection policy.

The legal issues before the court included whether the insurer's conduct during the proceedings constituted an implied undertaking that could bind them to use the TPD proceedings in assessing the income protection claim. The court considered whether there were special circumstances that would justify releasing the insurer from such an undertaking. The central issue was whether the insurer's actions warranted an implication that they would use the TPD case as part of the assessment for the income protection policy.

The court examined the principles of implied undertakings and whether there were any special circumstances that would allow the insurer to be released from such an undertaking. It found that the insurer had not acted in a way that would lead to such an implication. The court held that the insurer's conduct did not create a binding obligation to use the TPD proceedings for assessing the income protection claim. The court ruled that there were no special circumstances that would justify releasing the insurer from any such implied undertaking.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s claim for release from the implied undertaking. The court held that the insurer was not bound by an implied undertaking to use the TPD policy proceedings for assessing the income protection policy claim. The plaintiff's action was therefore unsuccessful.

Background

Background to the litigation

Price v ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited concerns an insurance dispute involving the plaintiff, Mr Price, who was claiming benefits under a Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) policy issued by ClearView Life Nominees Pty Limited. Mr Price suffered a severe stroke in 2010, which left him with significant disabilities. Following the stroke, Mr Price made a claim for benefits under the TPD policy. ClearView initially paid the TPD benefits but later sought to recover some of those payments, arguing that Mr Price had not fully complied with the terms of the policy. In the meantime, Mr Price also made a claim for benefits under an income protection policy. ClearView sought to use the TPD payments it had already made to offset the income protection claim. The dispute centred on whether ClearView could rely on the TPD payments in assessing Mr Price's claim under the income protection policy.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The primary judge had ruled in favour of ClearView, allowing the insurer to offset the TPD payments against the income protection claim. Mr Price appealed this decision, arguing that ClearView was not entitled to offset the TPD payments due to an implied undertaking not to use them in assessing his income protection claim. The appeal was heard by the Queensland Court of Appeal, which was tasked with determining whether ClearView could rely on the TPD payments and whether there were special circumstances that warranted releasing ClearView from any implied undertaking.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether ClearView is entitled to offset the TPD payments against the income protection claim.
2. Whether there are special circumstances that would warrant releasing ClearView from any implied undertaking not to use the TPD payments in assessing the income protection claim.

Held
1. The court concluded that ClearView is not entitled to offset the TPD payments against the income protection claim. The appeal was allowed in part on this issue.
2. The court held that there are no special circumstances that would warrant releasing ClearView from any implied undertaking not to use the TPD payments in assessing the income protection claim. The application for release was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature of the implied undertakings in insurance policies, noting that they arise from the policyholder's reasonable expectations and the insurer's representations. The court found that ClearView had an implied undertaking not to use TPD payments in assessing the income protection claim, given the separate purposes and terms of the policies. It was held that ClearView’s attempt to offset the TPD payments against the income protection claim contravened this undertaking. The court relied on established case law to affirm that such an offset would be inequitable and against the policyholder's reasonable expectations.

Regarding the application for release from the implied undertaking, the court assessed whether special circumstances existed to justify ClearView being released from its obligation. The court found that the insurer's failure to object promptly to the policyholder's claim for income protection benefits did not constitute special circumstances warranting release. The court emphasised that the onus was on ClearView to demonstrate compelling reasons for the release, which it had not successfully done. The court followed the principle that special circumstances must be significant and not merely a result of the insurer's own procedural missteps. The ratio here is that insurers must adhere to implied undertakings unless special circumstances clearly justify a departure, and such circumstances must be substantial and not self-inflicted.