Pratt v Hismelt Corporation Pty Limited(S)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   PRATT -v- HISMELT CORPORATION PTY LIMITED(S) [2008] WADC 164

CORAM:   MAZZA DCJ

HEARD:   ON THE PAPERS

DELIVERED          :   17 NOVEMBER 2008

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2884 of 2001

BETWEEN:   DAVID ANTHONY PRATT

Plaintiff

AND

HISMELT CORPORATION PTY LIMITED
Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Costs - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971O 66 r 1

Result:

Costs orders made

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr L Gandini

Defendant:     Ms F Davis

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Chapmans

Defendant:     DLA Phillips Fox

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4

Foster v Chief Executive Officer of the Department of Agriculture [2006] WASCA 95

Fountain Selected Meats (Sales) Pty Ltd v International Produce Merchants Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 397

Hewitt v Benale Pty Ltd (2002) 27 WAR 91

Hismelt Corporation Pty Ltd v Pratt [2007] WASCA 192

Lo Presti v Ford Motor Company of Australia Ltd (No 2) [2008] WASC 12(S)

Mannix v Loumbos Pty Ltd [2000] NSWCA 32

Pratt v Hismelt Corporation Pty Ltd & Anor [2008] WADC 133

MAZZA DCJ: 

Introduction

  1. On 10 September 2008 I delivered judgment in this matter (Pratt v Hismelt Corporation Pty Ltd & Anor [2008] WADC 133) and I dismissed the plaintiff's action against the defendant.

  2. In essence, I found that the defendant was the plaintiff's deemed employer pursuant to s 175(1) of the Workers' Compensation & Rehabilitation Act 1981 ("the Act") as a result, the defendant was entitled to the protection afforded it by Pt 4 Div 2 of the Act.  The effect of these provisions was to disentitle the plaintiff to an award of common law damages.

  3. I made an order dismissing the plaintiff's claim but I did not, at that time, make an order with respect to costs.  The parties wished to consider their positions so far as costs were concerned and so it was agreed that they would each provide me with submissions on the matter and they were content for me to deal with the point on the papers.  What follows are my reasons and orders on costs.

  4. As expressed in his outline of submissions, the plaintiff sought the following orders:

    1.The defendant pay the plaintiff's costs, to be taxed if not agreed, between the commencement of the action to 3 December 2007.

    2.The plaintiff pay the defendant's costs between 3 December 2007 and 10 September 2008 to be taxed if not agreed.

  5. In addition, the plaintiff says that there should be no costs order with respect to the costs issue.

  6. The defendant sought an order that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the action to be taxed on a party/party basis up to 2 April 2004 and thereafter on an indemnity basis as a result of a Calderbank offer made by the defendant on 11 March 2004.  The defendant asks that any cost order include the submissions it made on the issue of costs.

The plaintiff's submissions

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pratt v Hismelt Corporation Pty Limited(S) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WADC 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Pratt v Hismelt Corporation Pty Limited, the plaintiff sought damages against the defendant, claiming injury resulting from the defendant's alleged negligence. The dispute reached the court following a series of procedural and legal arguments, particularly regarding the applicability of the Workers' Compensation & Rehabilitation Act 1981. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate allocation of costs between the parties following the dismissal of the plaintiff's action. The central legal issue was whether the plaintiff should bear the costs of the defendant's unsuccessful appeal, given the timing and nature of the defendant's defence and the subsequent proceedings.

The court considered the procedural history and the implications of the defendant's failure to timely amend its defence to include a s 175 defence. The plaintiff argued that the defendant should have amended its defence upon the release of the Hewitt v Benale Pty Ltd decision, which would have clarified the legal position. The court noted that the defendant did not amend its defence until 24 March 2004 and failed to pursue more decisive procedural steps, such as applying for a stay or summary judgment. Instead, the defendant chose to appeal the decision of Judge Wager, which was ultimately unsuccessful. The court found that the defendant's delay in raising the s 175 defence contributed to the escalation of costs and complexity of the proceedings.

Based on these findings, the court ruled that the plaintiff should bear the costs of the defendant's unsuccessful appeal. The plaintiff's failure to promptly raise the s 175 defence led to unnecessary procedural steps and increased costs. The court's decision emphasised the importance of timely and appropriate legal strategies to manage the progression of litigation. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the appeal, as well as the costs of the proceedings up to a certain date, to be taxed on a party/party basis. This decision reflects the court's intention to hold parties accountable for their procedural choices and their impact on the overall litigation process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 10 September 2008 I delivered judgment in this matter (Pratt v Hismelt Corporation Pty Ltd & Anor [2008] WADC 133) and I dismissed the plaintiff's action against the defendant. In essence, I found that the defendant was the plaintiff's deemed employer pursuant to s 175(1) of the Workers' Compensation & Rehabilitation Act 1981 ("the Act") as a result, the defendant was entitled to the protection afforded it by Pt 4 Div 2 of the Act. The effect of these provisions was to disentitle the plaintiff to an award of common law damages. I made an order dismissing the plaintiff's claim but I did not, at that time, make an order with respect to costs. The parties wished to consider their positions so far as costs were concerned and so it was agreed that they would each provide me with submissions on the matter and they were content for me to deal with the point on the papers. What follows are my reasons and orders on costs. As expressed in his outline of submissions, the plaintiff sought the following orders:1.The defendant pay the plaintiff's costs, to be taxed if not agreed, between the commencement of the action to 3 December 2007.2.The plaintiff pay the defendant's costs between 3 December 2007 and 10 September 2008 to be taxed if not agreed. In addition, the plaintiff says that there should be no costs order with respect to the costs issue. The defendant sought an order that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the action to be taxed on a party/party basis up to 2 April 2004 and thereafter on an indemnity basis as a result of a Calderbank offer made by the defendant on 11 March 2004. The defendant asks that any cost order include the submissions it made on the issue of costs. The plaintiff provided a chronology of the proceedings. The plaintiff commenced the proceedings against the first and second defendant on 6 November 2001. A statement of claim was filed and served on 12 March 2002 and on 14 March 2002 the first defendant filed and served its defence. In that defence the defendant did not plead the s 175 defence. On 19 June 2002 the Court of Appeal delivered its decision in Hewitt v Benale Pty Ltd (2002) 27 WAR 91. That decision, the plaintiff submitted, should have prompted the defendant to amend its defence to plead that the defendant was the plaintiff's deemed employer under s 175 of the Act. The plaintiff submitted that the defendant did not amend its defence to introduce the s 175 plea until 24 March 2004. At or around that point, it is said, the defendant should have pursued the matter by applying to stay the proceedings or apply for summary judgment or seeking a trial of preliminary issue, but it did not. Rather, the defendant pursued along with the second defendant an application for summary judgment, on different grounds, which succeeded before Deputy Registrar Wallace but failed on appeal to Her Honour Judge Wager. Instead of leaving the matter there, the plaintiff argued, the defendant chose to appeal Judge Wager's decision, an appeal which proved ultimately unsuccessful.