Praniess v Police; Police v Praniess

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

PRANIESS v POLICE; POLICE v PRANIESS

[2010] SASC 275

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Duggan

10 September 2010

TRAFFIC LAW - OFFENCES - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - ALCOHOL AND DRUG RELATED OFFENCES - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - EVIDENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - JUDICIAL DISCRETION TO ADMIT OR EXCLUDE EVIDENCE - EVIDENCE UNFAIR TO ADMIT OR IMPROPERLY OBTAINED - PARTICULAR CASES

TRAFFIC LAW - OFFENCES - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - ALCOHOL AND DRUG RELATED OFFENCES - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - DRIVING UNDER INFLUENCE OF INTOXICATING LIQUOR OR A DRUG - SENTENCE AND PENALTY

Appeals heard jointly - defendant subjected to breath test pursuant to Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) and subsequently supplied with blood analysis kit - blood sample obtained in compliance with prescribed procedures but unable to be analysed through no fault of defendant or police - Magistrate found defendant guilty of driving under the influence and driving with prescribed concentration of alcohol in his blood - prosecution withdrew driving with prescribed concentration of alcohol charge - defendant convicted and sentenced for driving under the influence - defendant previously convicted of driving under the influence when riding a bicycle - defendant appeals conviction and finding of guilt - police appeal against penalty - whether Court able to exclude evidence of breath analysis in exercise of unfairness discretion - whether sufficient evidence for finding of guilt on driving under the influence charge - whether Magistrate incorrectly allowed evidence of breath analysis in light of contention that defendant belched prior to test - whether conviction of driving under the influcence while riding a bicycle ought to have been regarded as previous offence for the purpose of s 47(4) leading to heavier penalty.

Held: appeal against conviction dismissed - appeal against sentence allowed - s 47K(8) overrides Court's discretionary power to exclude evidence on the ground of unfairness - Court permitted to act on the evidence of the breath analysis - even if Court had discretion to exclude the evidence it would be inappropriate for discretion to be exercised in present case - ample evidence to establish that offence of driving under the influence had been committed - Magistrate entitled to find that defendant did not belch - even if belch did occur exclusion of evidence not warranted - offence of driving under the influence on occasion of riding the bicycle constitutes a previous offence for the purposes of s 47(4) - present offence comprised a subsequent offence - sentence imposed by Magistrate set aside - fine of $1,500 and disqualification of 3 years imposed.

Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) s 5, s6, s 47, s 47(1)(a), s 47(2), s 47(3)(a), s 47(4), s 47B(1), s 47EB, s 47G(1), s 47K, s 47K(1), s 47K(1a), s 47K(1ab), s 47K(8) Sch 1 cl 3; Summary Procedure Act 1921 (SA) s 76A, referred to.
Police v Parker (2002) 81 SASR 240; R v Lobban (2000) 77 SASR 24; Police v Hall (2006) 95 SASR 482; Police v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Praniess v Police; Police v Praniess and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Praniess v Police; Police v Praniess, the defendant was found guilty of driving under the influence of intoxicating liquor and subsequently appealed the conviction and sentence. The police also appealed against the penalty imposed by the Magistrate. The central issue in the appeal was whether the Court could exclude the evidence of the breath analysis due to unfairness or improper procurement, and if there was sufficient evidence to sustain the conviction of driving under the influence. Additionally, the appeal questioned whether the Magistrate erred in considering the breath analysis evidence given the defendant's claim that he had belched before the test. The case also considered whether the defendant's prior conviction for driving under the influence while riding a bicycle should be considered a previous offence for the purpose of attracting a heavier penalty.

The Court determined that the discretionary power to exclude evidence on the grounds of unfairness was overridden by section 47K(8) of the Road Traffic Act. This section allows for the admission of breath analysis evidence, creating a presumption about the concentration of alcohol in the defendant's blood at the time of the analysis. The Court found that even if it had the discretion to exclude the evidence, it would be inappropriate to do so in this case. The Court was satisfied that there was ample evidence to establish the commission of the offence of driving under the influence. The Court also held that the Magistrate was entitled to find that the defendant did not belch before the test, and even if he had, the exclusion of evidence would not have been warranted. Furthermore, the Court ruled that the offence of driving under the influence while riding a bicycle constituted a previous offence for the purpose of section 47(4), leading to the present offence being classified as a subsequent offence. Consequently, the sentence imposed by the Magistrate was set aside, and a fine of $1,500 along with a disqualification of three years was imposed.

In light of the above, the Court dismissed the appeal against the conviction but allowed the appeal against the sentence. The Court's decision underscored the importance of statutory provisions in determining the admissibility and weight of evidence in traffic law cases. The Court's ruling affirmed the principle that the statutory presumptions created by the Road Traffic Act are strong and can only be rebutted by specific types of evidence. The case highlights the complexities of judicial discretion in balancing the fairness of the proceedings with the statutory framework governing traffic offences.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is necessary to set out the relevant provisions of the Road Traffic Act as it stood at the time of the alleged offence. Section 47K(1) provides for the admission into evidence of the reading obtained by the breath analysis instrument. The subsection also creates a presumption as to the concentration of alcohol in the blood of the defendant at the time of the analysis. It states:47K—Evidence etc(1)Without affecting the admissibility of evidence that might be given otherwise than in pursuance of this section, evidence may be given, in any proceedings for an offence, of the concentration of alcohol indicated as being present in the blood of the defendant by a breath analysing instrument operated by a person authorised to operate the instrument by the Commissioner of Police and, where the requirements and procedures in relation to breath analysing instruments and breath analysis under this Act, including subsections (2) and (2a), have been complied with, it must be presumed, in the absence of proof to the contrary, that the concentration of alcohol so indicated was present in the blood of the defendant at the time of the analysis. Section 47K(1a) restricts the scope of the rebuttal evidence:(1a)No evidence can be adduced in rebuttal of the presumption created by subsection (1) except—(a) evidence of the concentration of alcohol in the blood of the defendant as indicated by analysis of a sample of blood taken and dealt with in accordance with section 47I and Schedule 1 or in accordance with the procedures prescribed by regulation; and(b) evidence as to whether the results of analysis of the sample of blood demonstrate that the breath analysing instrument gave an exaggerated reading of the concentration of alcohol present in the blood of the defendant. Section 47K(1ab) creates a conclusive presumption that the concentration of alcohol as recorded by the breath analysing instrument was the concentration of alcohol as at the time of driving. Section 47K(2a)(b) directs that a defendant is to be provided with an approved blood test kit upon request. Section 47K(8) provides as follows:(8)A prosecution for an offence will not fail because of a deficiency of a kit delivered to the defendant in purported compliance with subsection (2a)(b) and the presumption under subsection (1) will apply despite such a deficiency unless it is proved—(a) that the defendant delivered the kit unopened to a medical practitioner for use in taking a sample of the defendant's blood; and(b) by evidence of the medical practitioner, that the medical practitioner was, because of a deficiency of the kit, unable to comply with the prescribed procedures governing the manner in which a sample of a person's blood must be taken and dealt with for the purposes of subsection (1a). If the defendant arranges for a blood sample to be taken by a medical practitioner or, in some cases, a registered nurse approximately equal proportions of the sample are to be placed in two containers. In the present case one of these containers was forwarded to the Forensic Science Centre by the registered nurse who took the sample. Mr Praniess arranged for the other container to be sent to Gribbles Pathology for analysis. As stated previously the samples in the containers could not be tested.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established