In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952 - and - In the Matter of Application No. 522675 for a Patent by PPG INDUSTRIES INC. - and - In the Matter of Section 59 Opposition thereto by STAUFFER CHEMICAL COMPANY.
DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER:
Patent application No. 522675 entitled "Antidotal Compounds for Use with Herbicides" was lodged on 9 December, 1980 and is a convention application based on two U.S. applications both with a priority date of 26 December, 1979. Acceptance of the application was advertised in the Official Journal dated 17 June, 1982.
Stauffer Chemical Company lodged notice of opposition under section 59 on 21 September, 1982. The service of evidence was completed on 8 November, 1984 and the matter was heard in Canberra on 18 April, 1985. Dr. J.MCL. Emmerson of Counsel advised by Mr. A. Thomas, patent attorney of Collison & Co. , represented the applicant and Mrs. P. Moore of Counsel advised by Mr. J. O'Connor, patent attorney of Spruson & Ferguson, represented the opponent. Although the notice of opposition specified grounds (c) to (i) of sub-section 59(1) the only grounds argued at thy hearing were that the invention, so far as claimed in any claim lacks novelty, has been anticipated and prior claimed and that the complete specification does not comply with the requirements of section 40.
The Specification
The specification states that the invention relates to N-(2,2-dialkoxyethyl)-N-substituted-2,2-dichloroacetamides and to N-(optionally substituted 1,3-dioxolan- or dioxane-2-methyl)-N-substituted-2,2-dichloroacetamides, their use as antidotes, herbicidal compositions containing these compounds and methods of preparation of these compounds.
The dioxolan and dioxane dichloroacetamides are described in similar terms to those used in claim 1 and the dialkoxyethyl acetamides are described in similar terms to those used in claim 6. The preparation of the compounds is described in similar terms to those used in claims 5 and 10. Specific details are described for the preparation of four of the compounds.
The application of the compounds is described as follows:
"The compounds of this invention, as represented in Formulae I and II, have been found eminently well-suited for protecting growing crops, for example, corn from the phytotoxic effects of active herbicides particularly S-alkyl thiocarbamate herbicides and chloroacetanilide herbicides."
The antidotal compounds may be separately incorporated into the soil but are preferably formulated with the herbicidal composition. The preferred weight ratio of herbicide to the antidote lies in the range of 18:1 to 6:1. The formulation may contain more than one herbicide as well as other commonly used agricultural compounds, for example, fertilisers. The formulation may be applied to the soil in any manner well known in the art, for example, as a dust or as an emulsion.
The effects of S-ethyl dipropylthiocarbamate on hybrid field corn were compared in the absence and presence of the compound defined in claim 2 or claim 7. After 42 days the corn crop whose treatment included the claimed compounds was healthy and normal whereas the corn crop treated with the herbicide alone showed reduction in growth, hormonal…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read PPG Industries Inc. v Stauffer Chemical Company and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1985] APO 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the compounds defined in claim 6 of the patent application were novel and not anticipated by the Stauffer patent, as the Stauffer patent did not disclose that the antidotal activity of a compound could be predicted from its structural formula. The court concluded that the compounds claimed in the patent application did not fall in the class of those described in the Stauffer patent, and therefore, the Stauffer patent did not disclose the compounds claimed in the patent application. The court also found that the claims 8 and 9 were not prior claimed by the Stauffer patent. However, the court noted that the specification did not comply with section 40 in some instances, and the applicant was given 60 days to propose amendments to overcome these defects.
In conclusion, the court found that the patent application was novel, not anticipated, and fairly based on the description, with the exception of some minor issues regarding section 40 compliance. The costs of the opposition were awarded against the opponent.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi