Poulton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Poulton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2017] AATA 566 (24 April 2017)

Division:VETERANS’ APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:2015/3319           

Re:Daphne Poulton  

APPLICANT

Repatriation CommissionAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr L Bygrave, Member  

Date:24 April 2017

Place:Sydney

The decision under review, being the decision by the Repatriation Commission on 4 June 2015 to refuse Mrs Daphne Poulton’s claim for the war widow’s pension, is affirmed.

.............................[sgd]................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member


CATCHWORDS

Veterans’ affairs – entitlements – war widow’s pension – hypertension causing death – where hypertension caused by consumption of alcohol – whether there is a causal connection between consumption of alcohol and operational service – decision affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth)

CASES

Collins and Repatriation Commission [2009] FCAFC 90

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Statement of Principles concerning Hypertension (No. 64 of 2013)

Statement of Principles concerning Ischaemic Heart Disease (No. 2 of 2016)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr L Bygrave, Member

24 April 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mrs Daphne Poulton, applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a review of the decision by the Repatriation Commission made on 4 June 2015 that refused her claim for a war widow’s pension in accordance with the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The matter was heard in Sydney on 20 March 2017. Mrs Poulton was unable to attend the hearing either in person or by telephone due to her poor health. Mrs Poulton had legal representation and her daughter, Mrs Sandra Eke, gave evidence at the hearing.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The late veteran, Mr Clifford Poulton, was born in 1919. He enlisted in the Australian Army on 1 October 1941 and was medically discharged on 1 August 1944. This period of time constitutes ‘eligible service’ as defined in the Act.

  4. Mr Poulton married Mrs Poulton in January 1944 and their daughter, Mrs Eke, was born in 1950.

  5. Mr Poulton’s death certificate stated that he died on 19 June 2013 at the age of 93 years due to:

    (I) (a) Multiorgan failure (2 days)

    (b) bowel ischaemia (2 days)

    (II) (a) ischemia heart disease

    (b) type II diabetes.[1]

    [1] Exhibit T, p 18.

    ISSUES

  6. The issues for determination by the Tribunal are:

    (a)the kind of death suffered by Mr Poulton, within the meaning of sections 120A and 120B of the Act; and

    (b)whether the death of Mr Poulton was connected with his eligible war service.

    RELEVANT LEGISLATION

  7. In accordance with sections 120A and 120B of the Act, the relevant Statement of Principles (SOP) in this matter are:

    (a)Hypertension (No. 64 of 2013);

    (b)Ischaemic Heart Disease (No. 2 of 2016).

  8. Pursuant to subsection 196B(14)(d) of the Act, a factor causing or contributing to death is related to service if ‘it was contributed to in a material degree by, or aggravated by, that service’.

  9. The standard of proof in this matter is that of reasonable satisfaction, or the balance of probabilities.

    EVIDENCE

  10. The Tribunal considered evidence from Associate Professor Richard Haber (Consultant Physician, Cardiologist), Dr Robert Smith (Consultant Cardiologist), Mrs Poulton and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Poulton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 566
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mrs Poulton against the Repatriation Commission's decision to refuse her claim for a war widow's pension. The dispute centred on whether the death of her late husband, Mr Clifford Poulton, from multi-organ failure and bowel ischaemia was causally linked to his eligible war service, specifically through hypertension and ischaemic heart disease allegedly caused by his alcohol consumption during service. The case was heard by Dr L Bygrave, Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine the kind of death suffered by Mr Poulton within the meaning of sections 120A and 120B of the relevant Act, and whether his death was connected with his eligible war service. This involved assessing whether hypertension and ischaemic heart disease, as defined by specific Statements of Principles, were present and whether these conditions were contributed to in a material degree by his war service, with the standard of proof being the balance of probabilities.

The Tribunal considered evidence from consultant cardiologists and the applicant's daughter. Crucially, the Tribunal found significant discrepancies and inconsistencies in the evidence provided by Mrs Poulton regarding her husband's alcohol consumption. As the opinion of Associate Professor Haber, a key expert witness, relied heavily on this unreliable evidence, the Tribunal could not place weight on his opinion. Furthermore, the Tribunal noted that the death certificate listed multi-organ failure and bowel ischaemia as the causes of death. Applying the principle from *Collins and Repatriation Commission*, which requires a medical cause of death to be the ultimate cause, the Tribunal was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that Mr Poulton's death resulted from ischaemic heart disease and hypertension caused by alcohol consumption connected to his war service. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Repatriation Commission's decision to refuse the war widow's pension.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter was heard in Sydney on 20 March 2017. Mrs Poulton was unable to attend the hearing either in person or by telephone due to her poor health. Mrs Poulton had legal representation and her daughter, Mrs Sandra Eke, gave evidence at the hearing.BACKGROUND The late veteran, Mr Clifford Poulton, was born in 1919. He enlisted in the Australian Army on 1 October 1941 and was medically discharged on 1 August 1944. This period of time constitutes ‘eligible service’ as defined in the Act. Mr Poulton married Mrs Poulton in January 1944 and their daughter, Mrs Eke, was born in 1950. Mr Poulton’s death certificate stated that he died on 19 June 2013 at the age of 93 years due to:(I) (a) Multiorgan failure (2 days)(b) bowel ischaemia (2 days)(II) (a) ischemia heart disease(b) type II diabetes.[1][1] Exhibit T, p 18.ISSUES The issues for determination by the Tribunal are:(a)the kind of death suffered by Mr Poulton, within the meaning of sections 120A and 120B of the Act; and(b)whether the death of Mr Poulton was connected with his eligible war service.RELEVANT LEGISLATION In accordance with sections 120A and 120B of the Act, the relevant Statement of Principles (SOP) in this matter are:(a)Hypertension (No. 64 of 2013); (b)Ischaemic Heart Disease (No. 2 of 2016). Pursuant to subsection 196B(14)(d) of the Act, a factor causing or contributing to death is related to service if ‘it was contributed to in a material degree by, or aggravated by, that service’. The standard of proof in this matter is that of reasonable satisfaction, or the balance of probabilities.EVIDENCE The Tribunal considered evidence from Associate Professor Richard Haber (Consultant Physician, Cardiologist), Dr Robert Smith (Consultant Cardiologist), Mrs Poulton and Mrs Eke. This evidence is set out below.Associate Professor Richard Haber (Consultant Physician, Cardiologist) Associate Professor Haber provided a report dated 10 February 2016 and gave oral evidence at the Tribunal hearing. In his report, Associate Professor Haber stated:[Mr Poulton] presented to St George Hospital at the age of 93 on 17 June 2013 with rectal bleeding… As part of treatment his aspirin were stopped… He died during that admission. He had coronary artery bypass graft, due to ischaemic heart disease for treatment of which he took aspirin. His general condition and age precluded investigations.[2][2] Exhibit A2, p 2. Associate Professor Haber contended that, while Mr Poulton died of multi-organ failure and bowel ischemia, ischaemic heart disease contributed to his death. Based on Mrs Poulton’s statement that her husband drank ‘more than six beers a day’ and ‘three scotches on Saturday and Sunday’, which equated to 480 grams of alcohol per week,[3] Associate Professor Haber opined that Mr Poulton satisfied factor 6(b) of SOP No. 64 of 2013 which connected his alcohol consumption with the clinical onset of hypertension. Associate Professor Haber concluded:[Mr Poulton’s] drinking habit almost certainly contributed to his hypertension and therefore to his ischaemic heart disease.He was treated with aspirin for his ischaemic heart disease which contributed to his rectal bleeding which was a terminal event.[4][3] Exhibit A2, p 3.[4] Exhibit A2, p 4.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The standard of proof in this matter is that of reasonable satisfaction, or the balance of probabilities.EVIDENCE The Tribunal considered evidence from Associate Professor Richard Haber (Consultant Physician, Cardiologist), Dr Robert Smith (Consultant Cardiologist), Mrs Poulton and Mrs Eke. This evidence is set out below.Associate Professor Richard Haber (Consultant Physician, Cardiologist) Associate Professor Haber provided a report dated 10 February 2016 and gave oral evidence at the Tribunal hearing. In his report, Associate Professor Haber stated:[Mr Poulton] presented to St George Hospital at the age of 93 on 17 June 2013 with rectal bleeding… As part of treatment his aspirin were stopped… He died during that admission. He had coronary artery bypass graft, due to ischaemic heart disease for treatment of which he took aspirin. His general condition and age precluded investigations.[2][2] Exhibit A2, p 2. Associate Professor Haber contended that, while Mr Poulton died of multi-organ failure and bowel ischemia, ischaemic heart disease contributed to his death. Based on Mrs Poulton’s statement that her husband drank ‘more than six beers a day’ and ‘three scotches on Saturday and Sunday’, which equated to 480 grams of alcohol per week,[3] Associate Professor Haber opined that Mr Poulton satisfied factor 6(b) of SOP No. 64 of 2013 which connected his alcohol consumption with the clinical onset of hypertension. Associate Professor Haber concluded:[Mr Poulton’s] drinking habit almost certainly contributed to his hypertension and therefore to his ischaemic heart disease.He was treated with aspirin for his ischaemic heart disease which contributed to his rectal bleeding which was a terminal event.[4][3] Exhibit A2, p 3.[4] Exhibit A2, p 4. At the Tribunal hearing, Associate Professor Haber acknowledged his opinion relied on the accuracy of Mrs Poulton’s statement about her husband’s alcohol consumption. He also accepted his understanding of the medical evidence was that Mr Poulton was treated for hypertension in 1990 and 2012, and developed ischaemic heart disease on or about 2000.[5][5] Exhibit A2, p 3.Dr Robert Smith (Consultant Cardiologist) Dr Smith was Mr Poulton’s Cardiologist from 1997, when he presented with advanced ischaemic heart disease requiring multivessel bypass surgery. The Tribunal was provided with Dr Smith’s clinical notes and medical letters dated 10 February 1997, 18 March 1997, 4 June 1997, 2 November 2000, 14 May 2009, 4 November 2009, 15 April 2014, 2 September 2014 and 17 March 2015. In a report dated 18 March 1997, Dr Smith noted Mr Poulton ‘has had hypertension for 40 years and has been on medication all the time’.[6] This would place the onset of Mr Poulton’s hypertension from the late 1950s.[6] Exhibit A6. In reply to questions from an RSL Advocate, Dr Smith reported on 17 March 2015:Mr Poulton had advanced severe diffuse coronary artery disease which was certainly potentiated by his underlying risk factors of being a long-standing sufferer of hypertension and later in life a diabetic. He also had underlying hyperlipidaemia. His heavy drinking habit certainly could have been a potential factor in predisposing him to hypertension and perhaps the development of diabetes. There is no doubt that all of these factors interacted with each other to contribute to the development of advanced vascular disease which culminated in his death.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on Mr Poulton’s death certificate, I am satisfied that he died of multiorgan failure and bowel ischemia. I am not satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that his death resulted from ischaemic heart disease and hypertension caused by his consumption of alcohol that was connected with his eligible war service.DECISION The decision under review, being the decision by the Repatriation Commission on 4 June 2015 to refuse Mrs Poulton’s claim for the war widow’s pension, is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mrs Eke told the Tribunal that her father always followed a routine: on weeknights after work her father would have a beer and then a couple of scotches at home; on a Saturday, he would stop for a beer at the pub on the way home from work.CONSIDERATION Mrs Poulton’s legal representative submitted that Mr Poulton’s service related alcohol consumption caused his hypertension, which in turn caused his ischaemic heart disease that was the cause of his death; and consequently, Mrs Poulton is entitled to the war widow’s pension. Based on Mrs Poulton’s evidence, she contended that:·Mr Poulton consumed an average of at least 500 grams of alcohol per week for at least six months before the clinical onset of hypertension as set out in factor 6(b) of SOP No. 64 of 2013; and·Mr Poulton had hypertension before the clinical onset of ischaemic heart disease as required by factor 9(1) of SOP No. 2 of 2016. There is a paucity of information before the Tribunal to support this contention, in part due to Mrs Poulton being unable to attend the Tribunal hearing and clarify the information in her statements. The written statements of Mrs Poulton in relation to the amount of alcohol consumed by her husband are neither internally consistent nor consistent with the evidence of Mrs Eke. I note that Mrs Poulton’s statement dated 31 May 2016 and Mrs Eke’s evidence indicate that Mr Poulton did not consume at least 500 grams of alcohol per week. Due to these discrepancies, I find that I am unable to place any significant weight on Mrs Poulton’s evidence. As Associate Professor Haber’s opinion relies on Mrs Poulton’s evidence about her husband’s alcohol consumption, I also find that I am unable to place any weight on Associate Professor Haber’s opinion. I have regard to the decision by the Full Federal Court in Collins and Repatriation Commission,[11] in which their Honours decided that a medical cause of death must be the medical condition/s that were the ultimate cause of death and it is not sufficient for a medical condition to hasten the death.[11] [2009] FCAFC 90, at [82]. Based on Mr Poulton’s death certificate, I am satisfied that he died of multiorgan failure and bowel ischemia. I am not satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that his death resulted from ischaemic heart disease and hypertension caused by his consumption of alcohol that was connected with his eligible war service.DECISION The decision under review, being the decision by the Repatriation Commission on 4 June 2015 to refuse Mrs Poulton’s claim for the war widow’s pension, is affirmed.