Potter v City of Holdfast Bay

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

POTTER v CITY OF HOLDFAST BAY

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Debelle, The Honourable Justice Besanko and The Honourable Justice White)

16 September 2005

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - BUILDING CONTROL - COUNCIL CONSENT AND APPROVAL

Application to council for development consent to use land as a car park – car park to service adjoining premises used for sale of new and used cars – whether proposed use was a non-complying development – council had not adopted procedure for assessing an application for a non-complying development – relevant principles – held, proposed use was a non-complying development with consequence that council had not adopted the correct procedure – further held, no reason to interfere with alternative basis of decision of Environment, Resources and Development Court, namely, that the proposal did not warrant consent by reference to the planning merits - appeal dismissed.

Development Act 1993 s 4, s 33, s 35; Development Regulations 1993 reg 16, reg 17; Planning Act 1982 s 47, s 56, referred to.
City of Mitcham v Feckmann (1999) 74 SASR 56, applied.
Cutajar v Thebarton Town Corporation (1991) 55 SASR 70, not followed.
Adelaide City Mission v South Australian Planning Commission (1993) 60 SASR 178, discussed.
City of West Torrens v McDonald's Properties (Australia) Pty Ltd (1985) 38 SASR 467; Papadopoulos v Corporation of the City of Woodville (1985) 39 SASR 569; Wilson v City of Mitcham & Mercedes College Springfield Inc (1986) 130 LSJS 31; Church of England Collegiate School of St Peter v Corporation of the Town of St Peters (1990) 70 LGRA 34; Church of England Collegiate School of St Peter v Corporation of the Town of St Peters (No 2) (1990) 71 LGRA 309; Ampol Road Pantry Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Brighton (1993) 62 SASR 165; Kipa Freeholds Pty Ltd v Development Assessment Commission (1999) 101 LGERA 414; District Council of Mt Barker v Palma (2002) 120 LGERA 182, considered.

POTTER v CITY OF HOLDFAST BAY
[2005] SASC 354

Full Court:  Debelle, Besanko and White JJ

  1. DEBELLE J:        The appellant operates a business selling new and used cars on land on the northern side of the junction of Bath Street and Brighton Road, Glenelg.  The appellant seeks to develop adjoining land at 39 Bath Street by demolishing a house on that land and establishing in its place a car park for customers, employees and visitors associated with the appellant’s new and used car business on Brighton Road.  The land is within the area of the respondent City of Holdfast Bay (“the Council”).

  2. The appellant applied to the Council for provisional development plan consent to undertake the proposed development.  The Council refused the application.  The appellant appealed to the Environment, Resources and Development Court (“the Environment Court”) against the decision.  The Environment Court dismissed the appeal.  The appellant now appeals to this Court.

    The Land and its Locality

  3. The following description of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Potter v City of Holdfast Bay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 354
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant in this case seeks to obtain development consent to use the subject land as a car park to service the adjoining premises used for the sale of new and used cars. The City of Holdfast Bay denied the application. The appellant appealed the decision to the Environment, Resources and Development Court, which dismissed the appeal. The appellant then appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central issue in this case is whether the proposed development is a non-complying development and whether the council adopted the correct procedure in assessing the application. The court held that the proposed development is a non-complying development and that the council had not adopted the correct procedure. The court further held that there was no reason to interfere with the alternative basis of decision of the Environment Court, namely, that the proposal did not warrant consent by reference to the planning merits. The appeal was dismissed.

The court considered the definition of "service trade premises" and "motor repair station" under the Development Regulations 1993. The court found that the appellant's business consists of both service trade premises and a motor repair station, which are both non-complying developments in the Historic Conservation Zone. The court held that the proposed development represented an extension of the appellant's business onto the subject land and, therefore, represented a change of use to a non-complying development. The court held that, because the council had not implemented the procedures prescribed in s 35(3) of the Development Act for assessing whether to grant development consent to a non-complying development, it had no jurisdiction to hear the appeal. Additionally, the court was prevented by s 35(4) of the Development Act from hearing an appeal in relation to a refusal of consent to a non-complying development. The court also considered the planning merits of the application and held that the proposal was clearly at odds with the objectives of the Historic Conservation Zone. The court concluded that the proposal was so fundamentally in conflict with the intent, purpose and desired character of the Historic Conservation Zone that the decision of the council refusing development consent was correct. The appellant's contentions were not successful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant proposes to demolish the existing buildings on the subject land and develop the land as a car park providing spaces for 26 cars. The purpose of the development is said to be to relieve congestion in the car storage area of the existing car yard and to reduce the need for visitors and staff to park in Bath Street. The appellant proposes that four of those spaces will be available for visitors, eight for staff and the remaining 14 for vehicles of customers which are being serviced at the adjoining car yard. A ramp will provide access from the land to the land occupied by the appellant’s existing business. It is proposed to establish landscaping on the southern and western boundaries of the land. A brush fence 1.8 metres high will be erected on the Bath Street boundary. Colourbond fencing will be erected on the western and northern boundaries.The Decision of the Environment Court The Environment Court dismissed the appeal from the Council’s decision on two grounds. The first was that the proposal represented an extension of the service trade premises and motor repair station operated by the appellant. The expression “service trade premises” is defined by the Development Regulations 1993 to mean premises used primarily for the sale, rental or display of … boats, caravans, domestic garages, sheds, outbuildings, motor vehicles, tents, trailers … or similar bulky articles or merchandise.The Development Regulations define “motor repair station” to meanany land or building used for carrying out repairs (other than panel beating or spray painting) to motor vehicles.The appellant’s business consists of both service trade premises and a motor repair station. Both forms of development are non‑complying developments in the Historic Conservation Zone. The Environment Court held that, as the proposed development represented an extension of the appellant’s business on to the subject land, it represented a change of use to a non‑complying development. The Environment Court held that, because the Council had not implemented the procedures prescribed in s 35(3) of the Development Act for assessing whether to grant development consent to a non‑complying development, it had no jurisdiction to hear the appeal. In addition, the Court was prevented by s 35(4) of the Development Act from hearing an appeal in relation to a refusal of consent to a non‑complying development. In case it had erred in reaching that conclusion, the Environment Court also considered the planning merits of the application. Its planning assessment constituted the second ground for refusing the appeal. The Court held that the proposal was clearly at odds with the objectives of the Historic Conservation Zone. The Court concluded that the proposal is so fundamentally in conflict with the intent, purpose and desired character of the Historic Conservation Zone that the decision of the Council refusing development consent was correct.The Appellant’s Contentions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established