ALLAN JOHN POSSELT AND LYNETTE JANICE POSSELT v KENNETH JAMES WOLFENDEN, WAYNE PATRICK WARRICK, WILLIAM ARTHUR HEADLEY, THE PRUDENTIAL ASSURANCE CO LTD AND WILLIAM WORKMAN
THE PRUDENTIAL ASSURANCE CO LTD (First Cross-Claimant) v KENNETH JAMES WOLFENDEN, WAYNE PATRICK WARRICK AND WILLIAM ARTHUR HEADLEY (First Cross-Respondents)
No. WAG 135 of 1995
FED No. 468/98
Number of pages - 11
Procedure
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NICHOLSON J
Procedure - application for leave to file re-amended statement of claim - motion for stay - whether leave should be granted - whether action vexatious or embarrassing - whether just to grant leave given limitation issues.
Federal Court Rules, O 13 rr2, 2(2), 2(3), 2(7), 7
Bowstead & Reynolds on Agency (16th ed 1996)
Abela v Giew (1964) 81 WN (Pt 1) (NSW) 344, followed
Londish v Gulf Pacific Pty Ltd (1993) 45 FCR 128, followed
Liptons Cash Registers and Business Equipment Ltd v Hugin (GB) Ltd [1982] 1 All ER 595, followed
ANZ Banking Group Ltd v Larcos (1987) 13 NSWLR 286, followed
PERTH, 16 December 1997 and 23 April 1998 (hearing), 5 May 1998 (decision)
#DATE 5:5:1998
Appearances
Counsel for the Applicants: N D C Dillon
Solicitor for the Applicants: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the First Respondent: M Cornes
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Barker Gosling
Counsel for the Second Respondent: R J Ainslie
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Mallesons Stephen Jaques
Counsel for the Third Respondent: No appearance
Solicitor for the Third Respondent: None on record
Counsel for the Fourth Respondent: M J Stevenson
Solicitor for the Fourth Respondent: Jackson McDonald
Counsel for Fifth Respondent K Banks-Smith
Solicitor for Fifth Respondent Phillips Fox
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The fourth respondent's motion to stay the proceedings be refused.
2. Costs on the motion reserved for submission.
3. The applications for leave to file the Re-amended Statement of Claim and to file a minute of amendment to par 12D therein be granted provided that:
(a) the joinder of the second applicant shall be effective only from the date of this order; and
(b) the respondents have leave to reply by way of defence to any cause of action by the first or second applicants regarding the expiration of any relevant limitation period.
4. The costs of the application for leave to amend and the joinder application be reserved for submission.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
NICHOLSON J
The applicants seek leave to re-amend their Statement of Claim and to add another applicant ("Lavar"). The grant of leave and the addition of Lavar are opposed, particularly on behalf of the fourth respondent which brings a motion to stay the proceedings in the present or re-amended form as vexatious and as not disclosing any reasonable or probable cause of action against it. The fifth respondent relies on submissions made for the fourth respondent.
PREVIOUS APPLICATIONS
The fourth respondent previously brought two strike out applications in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Posselt, Allan John & Anor v Wolfenden, Kenneth James & Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] FCA 468
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the proposed amendments would prejudice the respondents and whether there was a reasonable prospect of success for the applicants' claims. The applicants argued that the amendment would not prejudice the respondents because it only added a new cause of action against the second respondent, who had not yet been served with the proceedings. The court acknowledged that while there may be some prejudice to the respondents, it was not sufficient to warrant refusing the amendment. The applicants also demonstrated a reasonable prospect of success for their claims, as the evidence presented indicated potential breaches of contract and tortious conduct by the respondents. Consequently, the court granted the applicants leave to amend their statement of claim under the relevant provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
The fourth respondent's motion to stay the proceedings be refused.
2. Costs on the motion reserved for submission.
3. The applications for leave to file the Re-amended Statement of Claim and to file a minute of amendment to par 12D therein be granted provided that:
(a) the joinder of the second applicant shall be effective only from the date of this order; and
(b) the respondents have leave to reply by way of defence to any cause of action by the first or second applicants regarding the expiration of any relevant limitation period.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants alleged that the respondents had mismanaged investments and breached fiduciary duties, resulting in significant financial losses. This included claims that the respondents had acted without proper authorisation in conducting certain financial transactions, which directly impacted the applicants' financial interests. The applicants sought to recover damages for these alleged breaches, including losses from unauthorised transactions and mismanagement. The factual events detailed in the case revolve around the interpretation of contractual terms, the actions taken by the respondents, and the subsequent disputes that led to this litigation.
This case came before the court as an application for various procedural orders. The applicants sought leave to file a Re-amended Statement of Claim and to make amendments to a specific paragraph within this document. The application was made in response to earlier proceedings where the applicants had sought to join a second applicant. The respondents opposed these applications, raising issues regarding the timing and appropriateness of the amendments. The matter was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments, with the court considering the necessity and fairness of allowing the proposed amendments.
Prior to this application, the applicants had already filed an original Statement of Claim, which was subsequently amended. The court had to determine whether further amendments were permissible under the rules of court and whether such amendments would prejudice the respondents. The applicants argued that the amendments were necessary to clarify their claims and to ensure that all relevant parties were properly before the court. The respondents contended that the proposed amendments were an attempt to introduce new causes of action outside the scope of the original claim and that they would be unfairly prejudiced by the delay in bringing these claims.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the fourth respondent's motion to stay the proceedings should be granted.
2. Whether the applicants are entitled to leave to file the Re-amended Statement of Claim.
3. Whether the applicants are entitled to leave to file a minute of amendment to paragraph 12D of the Re-amended Statement of Claim.
4. If leave is granted, whether the joinder of the second applicant should be effective only from the date of this order.
5. Whether the respondents should have leave to reply by way of defence to any cause of action by the first or second applicants regarding the expiration of any relevant limitation period.
Held
1. The fourth respondent's motion to stay the proceedings should not be granted.
2. The applicants are entitled to leave to file the Re-amended Statement of Claim.
3. The applicants are entitled to leave to file a minute of amendment to paragraph 12D of the Re-amended Statement of Claim.
4. If leave is granted, the joinder of the second applicant should be effective only from the date of this order.
5. The respondents should have leave to reply by way of defence to any cause of action by the first or second applicants regarding the expiration of any relevant limitation period.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering the fourth respondent's motion to stay the proceedings, the court found that the stay was not warranted based on the current state of the case and the applicants' need for a prompt resolution. The court emphasised the importance of the proceedings continuing to avoid any further delays, which would have prejudiced the applicants' rights. The court's refusal to grant the stay is based on the principle that unnecessary delays should be avoided to ensure justice is served without undue prejudice to any party.
Regarding the applicants' applications for leave to file the Re-amended Statement of Claim and a minute of amendment to paragraph 12D, the court granted these applications. The court recognised that the amendments were necessary to clarify and correct the applicants' claims, ensuring that all relevant facts and legal arguments were accurately presented. The court balanced the applicants' right to amend their pleadings against the potential prejudice to the respondents and found that the amendments were justified in this instance. The court's decision to grant leave to amend is consistent with the principle that parties should have the opportunity to correct and clarify their claims where necessary to achieve a fair and just resolution of the dispute.
Concerning the effective date of the second applicant's joinder, the court ruled that it should be effective only from the date of the order. This decision was based on the court's consideration of the timing of the joinder and its impact on the proceedings. The court determined that allowing the joinder to be effective from the date of the order would best serve the interests of justice and avoid any potential confusion or unfairness. This ruling aligns with the principle that amendments to pleadings should be made in a manner that ensures clarity and fairness in the proceedings.
Lastly, the court granted the respondents leave to reply by way of defence to any cause of action by the first or second applicants regarding the expiration of any relevant limitation period. The court acknowledged the respondents' need to address the potential issue of limitation periods in their defences. By allowing the respondents to reply by way of defence, the court ensured that all relevant legal issues would be fully addressed and that the proceedings would proceed in a manner that allows for a fair determination of the matter. This decision reflects the principle that all parties should have the opportunity to respond to all relevant claims and defences in the case.