Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Whittle

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

PORTLIN NO 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v WHITTLE & ANOR

[2009] SASC 229

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Vanstone

6 August 2009

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - SUBJECT MATTER OF LEASE

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - TERM OF LEASE OR TENANCY - DURATION

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - TERM OF LEASE OR TENANCY - COMMENCEMENT

Plaintiff company leased premises from defendants - lease in writing - term of lease ten years with right of renewal - dispute as to the area leased - whether term of lease subsequently reduced to three years - dispute as to commencement date - whether right of renewal unenforceable for uncertainty - determination of rent payable - defendants counterclaim for damages arising from plaintiff taking possession of area greater than that leased - further seek an account for profits made by business operated on demised land but not forming part of plaintiff's lease.

PORTLIN NO 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v WHITTLE & ANOR
[2009] SASC 229

Civil

  1. VANSTONE J:     Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd (Portlin) was the corporate vehicle acquired by Mr Maurice Hood and the first defendant, Mr Albert Whittle, to operate premises known as “Truck Stop” on Highway One at Port Augusta.  The registered proprietors of the property, Mr Whittle and his wife, the second defendant, leased it to Portlin.

  2. Portlin went into liquidation on 29 June 2006.  It still operates Truck Stop.  Its major asset is the lease, which it claims subsists.  It claims that it is entitled to perfect its leasehold interest and it seeks declarations to entitle it to do so.  The terms and conditions of the lease are the matters of dispute in this action.

    Background

  3. In 2000 the defendants were in negotiations with a third party, Parnell Mogas Pty Ltd, which they hoped would lead to that company taking a lease over the premises.  Ultimately, those negotiations failed and the site was vacant for a number of months.  During that period, and in February 2001, Mr Whittle and Mr Morris Hood became directors and equal shareholders in Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd, with a view to that company conducting business at the premises on a temporary basis.

  4. On 6 March 2001 Portlin and Mr Whittle executed a document headed “Offer to Rent” agreeing that Portlin would lease “the property known as Port Augusta Truck Stop situated at Lot 8, Highway One, Port Augusta, excluding the premises currently occupied by Specialised Tyres Pty Ltd”.  The term of the lease was expressed to be on a monthly basis, “until Portlin earns a net profit of 2½ per cent on total sale of fuel”.  This document is exhibit P18.  Mr Hood was by now styled “Managing Director” and his role was to undertake the day-to-day management of the Truck Stop.

  5. From early 2001, Portlin commenced to carry on business at the premises.  It is common ground that the business was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Whittle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Whittle was a case before the South Australian Supreme Court. The plaintiff, Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd, in liquidation, sought to determine the rights and obligations under a lease agreement with the defendants, Mr Whittle and his family trust. The primary disputes were over the area leased, the term of the lease, the commencement date, the enforceability of a renewal option, and the determination of rent payable. The defendants counterclaimed for damages due to the plaintiff occupying more land than leased, and sought an account of profits from a business operated on the leased land but not part of the lease.

The court needed to decide several legal issues. Firstly, it had to ascertain the area that was actually leased under the agreement. Secondly, it had to determine the term of the lease and whether there was a valid renewal option. Thirdly, the court had to establish the correct commencement date of the lease. Fourthly, the enforceability of the renewal option due to potential uncertainties was examined. Lastly, the court had to determine the rent payable under the lease and address the defendants' counterclaims.

The court found that the lease covered the original Lot 8, excluding the area occupied by Specialised Tyres. It held that the lease term was ten years with a right to renew for the same term, starting from 6 April 2001. The court ruled that the rent for the third year was correctly stated as $12,765 per month including GST, and subsequent rent would be adjusted based on the CPI or 4 per cent, whichever was less. The court dismissed the defendants' counterclaim for damages and an account of profits, finding no evidence to support these claims. The court proposed to hear the parties on the form of orders to give effect to these findings.

The court's final orders would likely address the clarified terms of the lease, the invalidity of the counterclaims, and the determination of the rent payable. The court's decision provided clarity on the lease's scope, duration, and financial obligations, while dismissing the counterclaims without merit.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Portlin went into liquidation on 29 June 2006. It still operates Truck Stop. Its major asset is the lease, which it claims subsists. It claims that it is entitled to perfect its leasehold interest and it seeks declarations to entitle it to do so. The terms and conditions of the lease are the matters of dispute in this action.Background In 2000 the defendants were in negotiations with a third party, Parnell Mogas Pty Ltd, which they hoped would lead to that company taking a lease over the premises. Ultimately, those negotiations failed and the site was vacant for a number of months. During that period, and in February 2001, Mr Whittle and Mr Morris Hood became directors and equal shareholders in Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd, with a view to that company conducting business at the premises on a temporary basis. On 6 March 2001 Portlin and Mr Whittle executed a document headed “Offer to Rent” agreeing that Portlin would lease “the property known as Port Augusta Truck Stop situated at Lot 8, Highway One, Port Augusta, excluding the premises currently occupied by Specialised Tyres Pty Ltd”. The term of the lease was expressed to be on a monthly basis, “until Portlin earns a net profit of 2½ per cent on total sale of fuel”. This document is exhibit P18. Mr Hood was by now styled “Managing Director” and his role was to undertake the day-to-day management of the Truck Stop. From early 2001, Portlin commenced to carry on business at the premises. It is common ground that the business was a 24 hours per day operation and included a fuel service area and café. In a document entitled “Minutes of Meeting of Directors of Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd (exhibit P20), dated 27 March 2001, Mr Whittle and Mr Hood appear to have agreed, as directors of Portlin, that the rent for the “Truck Stop would be fixed at $88,000 p.a. including GST or $7,333.33 per month for the first two months of operation”. Mr Hood said that this figure was not amended for the balance of calendar year 2001. Not long after June 2001, Mr Hood provided some financial data for Portlin’s operations to Messrs Gill Penfold Kelly, who were Mr Whittle’s accountants. A tax return for the year ending June 2001 was filed. Portlin declared an operating profit before income tax of approximately $8,000. During the balance of calendar year 2001 Mr Whittle participated very little in the affairs of Portlin, he having suffered a heart attack in April 2001. He did not play any active role until approximately December 2001. At about that time, Mr Hood informed Mr Whittle of the prospect of securing a contract to prepare and supply food to the nearby power station. This was referred to as “NRG Catering”. This enterprise constituted a promising adjunct to the business already carried out from the site. Ultimately it was agreed between Mr Hood and Mr Whittle that they would operate that business in partnership and that Portlin would sub-lease an area of the premises to the partnership. During March 2002 a new lease was executed by both Mr Whittle, for the defendants, and Mr Hood, for Portlin. The document, which is exhibit P39, was dated 2 March 2002. Its terms were as follows:Portlin No 2 Pty Ltd LeasePortlin No. 2 Pty Ltd agrees to lease from the AT Whittle Family Trust all the land and building space not occupied by Specialised Tyres for a period of 10 years with the right to renew.The land and building being that, situated on Lot 8 Highway, Port Augusta.The Directors recognise that the total cost to rebuild and make good the property for occupation, and to expand the business opportunities will be $1,500,000.00 in total.The rent plan for the first three years will be as follows:Year 1 $8,000.00 per month = $96,000.00 including GSTYear 2 $9,990.00 per month = $119,880.00 including GSTYear 3 $12,765.00 per month = $153,180.00 including GSTAll rent after, to be annually adjusted by CPI or 4% which ever is the lesser.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to the profits arising from the amenities business retained by Portlin, there is simply no evidence before me suggesting that Portlin is not entitled to such profits. Nothing was put to me by the defendants in final submissions as to this part of the claim. It is simply not made out. That part of the counterclaim fails.Conclusion I found that the land which was subject to the two leases, exhibit P18 and exhibit P39, was the original Lot 8, less the area occupied by Specialised Tyres. The Specialised Tyres land was the three easternmost bays of the large shed, together with the rectangular paved area extending 8 metres to the south of those three bays. In addition, I have found the plaintiff enjoyed a licence to use part of Lot 10 for the purpose of taking access at the point labelled “A”. I have found that the lease, exhibit P39, had a ten year term with a right to renew for the same term, and commenced on the original commencement date, being 6 April 2001. The rent for Year 3 was as stated on exhibit P39, being $12,765 per month including GST. The rent for the years thereafter was based on that figure, as increased by the CPI or 4 per cent, whichever was less. I have found that since October 2006, by order of this Court, the plaintiffs have been in possession of land beyond their entitlement under the lease, but there is no evidence as to any damages arising therefrom. I have found that the counterclaim for an account of profits made from the amenities business fails. I propose to hear the parties as to the form of orders to give effect to these findings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established