Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd v Wood

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

PORT ADELAIDE SALVAGE PTY LTD & ANOR v WOOD

[2019] SASC 106

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Lovell

28 June 2019

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE  - PARITY BETWEEN CO-OFFENDERS

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE  - SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE

The first appellant pleaded guilty to undertaking a prescribed activity of environmental significance without the appropriate licence contrary to s 36(1) and cl 3(3) Pt A Sch 1 of the Environment Protection Act 1993. The second appellant, a director of the first appellant, pleaded guilty to a charge contrary to s 129(1) of the Act. Both appellants appeal against the fines imposed by the sentencing judge, contending that they are manifestly excessive.

Appeal against sentence of a judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court - parity between co-offenders – whether the sentencing judge failed to have regard to the principle of parity – credit for guilty plea – post-offence misconduct

Held, allowing the appeal:

1. The sentencing judge failed to consider the principle of parity when sentencing the appellants resulting in the sentence being manifestly excessive. 

2. The sentence is set aside and the appellants resentenced.

Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) ss 36(1), 129(1), cl 3(3) Pt A Sch 1; Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 (SA) s 30(4); Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA); Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) ss 9, 10, referred to.
Resourceco Pty Ltd v Harvey (2007) 96 SASR 495; R v Jongewaard [2009] SASC 346; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Wong v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 584; Hili v The Queen (2010) 242 CLR 520; R v Kreutzer (2013) 118 SASR 211; R v Morse (1979) 23 SASR 98; Markarian v R (2005) 228 CLR 357; R v McInerney (1986) 42 SASR 111; Postiglione v The Queen (1997) 189 CLR 295; Lowe v The Queen (1984) 154 CLR 606; R v MacGowan (1986) 42 SASR 580; R v Lagana [2012] SASCFC 135; Wood v EM Earthmovers Pty Ltd [2018] SAERDC 36, considered.

PORT ADELAIDE SALVAGE PTY LTD & ANOR v WOOD
[2019] SASC 106

LOVELL J:

Overview

  1. The second appellant, Mr Corsaro, is a director of the first appellant, Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd (‘Port Adelaide Salvage’).

  2. The first appellant was charged with, and pleaded guilty before the primary judge to, a charge of undertaking a prescribed activity of environmental significance by operating a waste depot without the appropriate licence contrary to section 36(1) and clause 3(3) of Part A of Schedule 1 of the Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA).

  3. The second appellant was charged with, and pleaded guilty before the primary judge to, being a director of the first appellant at the time of the commission of the offence mentioned above contrary to section 129(1) of the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd v Wood and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd and Mr Corsaro, appealed against their convictions and sentences for disposing of waste at an unlicensed site in Highbury. The appeal focused on whether the fines imposed by the primary judge were manifestly excessive. EM Earthmovers Pty Ltd, operated by Mr Musolino, was also involved in the disposal of waste but did not proceed to appeal. The primary judge had found the appellants guilty and imposed fines of $44,000 on Port Adelaide Salvage and $18,000 on Mr Corsaro. The appellants argued that these fines were excessive, especially in comparison to the $24,000 fine imposed on EM Earthmovers.

The primary legal issue was whether the fines imposed on the appellants were manifestly excessive, with a particular focus on the principle of parity in sentencing. The appellants contended that the disparity in fines between them and EM Earthmovers indicated a failure to apply the principle of parity. They also argued that the fines did not adequately reflect the benefits obtained by Port Adelaide Salvage and Mr Corsaro, which were estimated savings of approximately $30,000. The court needed to determine whether the fines were proportionate to the offences committed and whether they adequately reflected the benefits obtained by the appellants.

The court considered the principle of parity in sentencing and noted that while the fines imposed on EM Earthmovers were lower, this was due to a 30% discount for an early plea of guilty. The court found that the primary judge had appropriately considered the principle of parity and that the fines were proportionate to the offences. The court also noted that the fines took into account the significant benefit obtained by Port Adelaide Salvage and Mr Corsaro by avoiding commercial dumping fees. The appeal against the sentences was dismissed as the fines imposed were deemed appropriate and not manifestly excessive.

The court confirmed the fines imposed on Port Adelaide Salvage and Mr Corsaro, and the appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The primary judge entered a conviction on each charge and fined both appellants. Both appellants appeal, contending that the fines imposed are manifestly excessive.Background Between August and November 2012, Mr Corsaro and employees or contractors engaged by Port Adelaide Salvage were observed by Environment Protection Agency (‘EPA’) officers disposing of 25 loads of mixed waste at a site at Highbury, operated by Mr Musolino. Mr Musolino and his wife are the directors of a company, EM Earthmovers Pty Ltd (‘EM Earthmovers’). This company had operated an unlicensed waste and recycling depot at the Highbury site specifically for the receipt, processing and storage of construction and demolition waste. Part of the site had been used as a clay quarry. The amount of waste dumped by the appellants between the above-mentioned dates was estimated to be in excess of 100 tonnes. EPA officers detected offending at the site in May 2012 and then commenced an investigation into the disposal of waste at the quarry. On 13 November 2012, after observing activity at the quarry, EPA officers entered the premises and approached Mr Corsaro and Mr Musolino. When questioned, Mr Corsaro stated that he had a business agreement in place with Mr Musolino whereby Mr Corsaro was not charged for dumping waste at the quarry in exchange for splitting the profits of sale of recycled aggregate produced at the quarry. Mr Corsaro said that the business had not yet started. He told EPA officers that he had entered into this arrangement as it was too expensive to pay commercial fees to dump at other sites. Mr Corsaro told the EPA officers that he believed Mr Musolino had both the appropriate certification from the mines department to recycle the concrete and bricks and the requisite EPA licence. Mr Musolino had neither. The basis of the guilty pleas by the appellants was that Port Adelaide Salvage and Mr Corsaro failed to make proper enquiries as to whether the quarry site was licensed to receive the waste. A sentence was imposed on the basis that there was an obligation on them to make enquiries to ensure that they were operating within the law. It was accepted that Port Adelaide Salvage saved approximately $30,000 by not paying commercial dumping fees. Mr Musolino and his company, EM Earthmovers, were also charged with offences relating to the dumping of the waste. Eventually the charge against Mr Musolino did not proceed, most likely due to his ill health. EM Earthmovers was convicted and fined $24,000; this sentence reflected a 30% discount for an early plea of guilty. Port Adelaide Salvage was fined $44,000 and Mr Corsaro $18,000. The appellants contended (amongst other grounds) that the disparity in the fine imposed on EM Earthmovers compared with the fines imposed on them is indicative of the failure by the primary judge to apply the principle of parity to the sentencing task.Legal principles Section 30(4) of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 (SA) provides that an appeal from criminal proceedings conducted before the Environment, Resources and Development (‘ERD’) Court is to be conducted as if it was an appeal from the Magistrates Court. Therefore, it is the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) which determines where an appeal lies.[1] [1] Resourceco Pty Ltd v Harvey (2007) 96 SASR 495.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the fine imposed on Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd manifestly excessive in the circumstances of the case?
2. Was the fine imposed on Mr Corsaro manifestly excessive in the circumstances of the case?
3. Did the primary judge fail to apply the principle of parity in sentencing, given the disparity in fines between EM Earthmovers Pty Ltd and the appellants?
4. Did the primary judge adequately consider the savings made by Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd by not paying commercial dumping fees when determining the appropriate fine?
5. Did the primary judge err in sentencing by not taking into account the lack of prior convictions of the appellants?
6. Was the imposition of fines on the appellants, rather than custodial sentences or other penalties, appropriate in the circumstances of the case?

Held
1. The court concluded that the fine imposed on Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd was not manifestly excessive in the circumstances of the case, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the fine imposed on Mr Corsaro was not manifestly excessive in the circumstances of the case, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.
3. The court concluded that the primary judge did not fail to apply the principle of parity in sentencing, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.
4. The court concluded that the primary judge did not adequately consider the savings made by Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd by not paying commercial dumping fees when determining the appropriate fine, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.
5. The court concluded that the primary judge did not err in sentencing by not taking into account the lack of prior convictions of the appellants, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.
6. The court concluded that the imposition of fines on the appellants, rather than custodial sentences or other penalties, was appropriate in the circumstances of the case, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appeal against the sentence imposed by the primary judge on Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd and Mr Corsaro. The court first addressed whether the fines imposed were manifestly excessive. The court found that the fines were not manifestly excessive, considering the nature of the offence, the appellants’ culpability, and the saving made by Port Adelaide Salvage by not paying commercial dumping fees. The court noted that the waste dumped was in excess of 100 tonnes, which indicated a significant breach of environmental regulations.

The court applied the principle that fines should reflect the seriousness of the offence and the culpability of the offender. The court considered the appellants’ culpability, which was high given that they failed to make proper enquiries about the legality of the waste disposal site. The court also took into account the saving made by Port Adelaide Salvage, which was approximately $30,000. While this saving influenced the fine, the court balanced it against the significant environmental harm caused by the illegal dumping of over 100 tonnes of waste.

The court next addressed whether the primary judge failed to apply the principle of parity in sentencing, given the disparity in fines between EM Earthmovers Pty Ltd and the appellants. The court held that the disparity in fines did not indicate a failure to apply the principle of parity. The court noted that EM Earthmovers had a 30% discount for an early plea of guilty, which was not applicable to the appellants. Additionally, EM Earthmovers had already been fined, which reduced the potential impact on their business. The court found that the primary judge had appropriately considered the different circumstances of each entity when imposing the fines.

The court also considered whether the primary judge adequately considered the savings made by Port Adelaide Salvage when determining the appropriate fine. The court found that the primary judge had appropriately taken into account the savings made by Port Adelaide Salvage but balanced it against the severity of the environmental harm caused. The court noted that the significant amount of waste dumped and the appellants’ culpability warranted a substantial fine, despite the savings made by Port Adelaide Salvage.

The court examined whether the primary judge erred in sentencing by not taking into account the lack of prior convictions of the appellants. The court found that the primary judge had considered the lack of prior convictions but determined that it was not a decisive factor given the seriousness of the offence. The court held that the primary judge appropriately balanced the appellants’ lack of prior convictions against the significant environmental harm caused by the illegal waste disposal.

Finally, the court considered whether the imposition of fines on the appellants, rather than custodial sentences or other penalties, was appropriate in the circumstances of the case. The court found that fines were an appropriate penalty given the nature of the offence and the appellants’ culpability. The court noted that the fines imposed were substantial and served to deter future environmental offences. The court held that custodial sentences were not necessary given the circumstances of the case.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the fines imposed on Port Adelaide Salvage Pty Ltd and Mr Corsaro were not manifestly excessive, and the primary judge appropriately considered various factors, including the appellants’ culpability, the environmental harm caused, and the savings made by Port Adelaide Salvage, when determining the appropriate fines. The court found that the disparity in fines between EM Earthmovers Pty Ltd and the appellants did not indicate a failure to apply the principle of parity, and the imposition of fines was an appropriate penalty in the circumstances of the case.