Pope & Pope v State Coroner No. Scgrg-98-60 Judgment No. S6526

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

POPE & POPE v STATE CORONER

Olsson J

This is an application for judicial review and injunctive relief against the Acting State Coroner.

In essence the plaintiffs seek to overturn her decision that a post-mortem examination be carried out on the body of their son Elliot Sydney Pope, whose tragic death occurred on 9 January 1998.  It is asserted on behalf of the plaintiffs that the direction given by the Acting State Coroner is, in the circumstances, beyond power or otherwise invalid.

I first turn to the relevant facts.

Elliot is the second child of the marriage of the plaintiffs.  He was born on 4 March 1997 and was thus approximately 10 months old at the time of his death.  He has an elder brother Oliver, who is 3½ years old.

The family resides at 84 Hawkers Road, Medindie.

At about 1.45 pm on 8 January 1998 both children were at home.  They were being looked after by their mother, the plaintiff Barbara Pope.  She was also baby-sitting a third child, who was a friend of Oliver.  All three children were, she said, playing outside.  They were “squealing and laughing”.

At one point Elliot sounded distressed.  His mother rushed out to find that he had fallen off his kickalong trike.  She comforted him and suggested that he come inside the house.  He did not wish to do so.  She, therefore, put him back on his trike and went back inside the house to make some telephone calls.

She made two such calls, after which she heard “the boys throwing things against the fence”.  She went outside to investigate.  Some ten minutes had elapsed since she had last gone outside.

When she exited the rear of the house she observed a red plastic bucket near a garden tap on the southern side of the property.  This was about 35 centimetres in height and 34 centimetres in diameter at the top.  It and the location of it near a child’s sand pit are depicted in the photographs comprising exhibit C1.

She at once saw what proved to be Elliot’s bottom and legs protruding from the top of the bucket, which contained a quantity of water.  He was all “floppy and cold”.  She carried him inside and telephoned the emergency number.  Under telephone instructions she administered CPR.

Ambulance officers arrived at about 2.02 pm and administered adrenalin.  A situation of cardiac arrest was noted on arrival.  After treatment some signs of life were noted and Elliot was conveyed to the Womens and Childrens Hospital.

Police officers were told by Elliot’s father that the bucket contained about 10 cms of water plus some sand in the bottom, when he first examined it after the incident.  Mrs Pope indicated that it was used for the dog’s water, but that, earlier in the day, the older boys had been washing their match box cars in it.  The top of the bucket would, she said, have come up to about Elliot’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pope & Pope v State Coroner No. Scgrg-98-60 Judgment No. S65... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6526
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Pope & Pope v State Coroner involves the plaintiffs, the parents of Elliot Sydney Pope, who seek to overturn the Acting State Coroner's decision to order a post-mortem examination of their son's body. Elliot, who was approximately ten months old, tragically drowned on January 9, 1998, after falling into a bucket filled with water. The plaintiffs, citing their religious beliefs, object to the autopsy and argue that it is unnecessary and contrary to their convictions. The court was required to determine whether the Acting State Coroner's decision to order the autopsy was proper and within the scope of her statutory powers.

The central legal issue in this case is whether the Acting State Coroner's decision to order an autopsy was based on reasonable grounds and in line with the provisions of the Coroners Act 1975. The plaintiffs argue that the cause and circumstances of Elliot's death were not unusual and that the Acting State Coroner's decision was not made in accordance with the Act. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties, including the medical reports and expert evidence provided by Drs. Keeley and Byard.

The court found that the Acting State Coroner's decision to order the autopsy was based on reasonable grounds and was in line with the provisions of the Coroners Act 1975. The court held that the death of Elliot occurred under unusual circumstances, which warranted the holding of an inquest. The court also determined that the Acting State Coroner's direction to conduct a post-mortem examination was intended to enable her to make an informed decision as to whether an inquest should be held. The court found that the Acting State Coroner's direction was necessary to determine the cause of death and provide essential forensic information.

The court dismissed the plaintiffs' application for judicial review and injunctive relief. However, it noted that the original direction signed by the Acting State Coroner did not satisfy the requirement of naming a specific medical practitioner. The court directed the Acting State Coroner to complete the formal direction in the appropriate manner by naming a specific medical practitioner. The court emphasized the importance of adhering to the statutory requirements of the Act and expressed sympathy for the plaintiffs' distress in this difficult situation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established