CITATION: Pongrass v Tomara [2000] NSWSC 494 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law FILE NUMBER(S): SC 10093 of 2000 HEARING DATE(S): 31 May 2000 JUDGMENT DATE: 31 May 2000 PARTIES :
Nicholas Andru Pongrass (First Plaintiff)
Leigh-Anne Clunes-Pongrass (Second Plaintiff)
Tomara Holdings Pty Ltd (Defendant)JUDGMENT OF: Windeyer J at 1
LOWER COURT
JURISDICTION :Local Court LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Magistrate Peter Gould
COUNSEL : A Ridley (Plaintiffs)
R. Walker (Defendant)SOLICITORS: Colin Biggers & Paisley (Plaintiffs)
Sutton & Co (Defendant)CATCHWORDS: APPEAL from magistrate - no reasons for decisions STATUTE - Dividing Fences Act - sufficient fence - contribution required based on half cost of sufficient fence LEGISLATION CITED: Dividing Fences Act 1991
Justices Act 1902, s102
Suitors' Fund Act 1951DECISION: See paragraph 19
1THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONWINDEYER J
WEDNESDAY 31 MAY 2000
10093/00 NICOLAS ANDRU PONGRASS & ANOR v TOMARA HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal by way of Summons under s102 of the Justices Act 1902 from a decision of a magistrate Mr Gould given on 20 December 1999.
2 The proceedings between the parties in the Local Court were proceedings under the Dividing Fences Act 1991. Mr and Mrs Pongrass sought an order under that Act for contribution by the defendant company Tomara Holdings Pty Limited (Tomara), being one-half of the cost of a new brick fence which was proposed to be constructed on the boundary separating the premises of the plaintiff and the defendant.
3 On part of that boundary the Pongrass property is subject to a right of way 10 feet wide and 20 feet long in favour of the Tomara property. I will leave the measurements on the imperial scale because that is how they appear on the documents which are in evidence.
4 There had been a fence between the properties at an earlier time which had been removed by one, or other, of the parties, it does not matter which. It seems that that fence may not have been exactly on the common boundary, but that is no longer an issue in the proceedings before me.
5 Mr and Mrs Pongrass wished to have the defendant Tomara contribute one-half of the cost of a brick fence. Tomara argued that a sufficient dividing fence did not require that fence to be constructed of brick and that a paling fence would be sufficient. The learned magistrate acceded to that view.
6 After a hearing, which appears to have lasted over two days, the Magistrate ordered: that there be erected a six-foot paling fence containing openings to be erected of either treated Radiata pine or Northcoast hardwood; that Pongrass pay $600 towards the cost of the fence with Tomara to pay the balance; that the fence be constructed by Tomara and the work be completed within three months. He ordered that the new fence be erected upon the line of the old fence, whether…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pongrass v Tomara and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 494
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue in the case was whether the existing fence was sufficient under the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (NSW), and if not, what the appropriate cost-sharing arrangement should be. The appellant argued that the existing fence was sufficient, while the respondent contended that it was inadequate and that the cost of a sufficient fence should be shared equally between the parties.
The Supreme Court found that the existing fence was not sufficient under the Act, as it did not provide the necessary privacy and security between the two properties. The court held that the appropriate cost-sharing arrangement was for the parties to contribute equally to the cost of a sufficient fence, based on the half cost of such a fence. The court rejected the appellant's argument that the existing fence was sufficient, and found that the respondent's evidence was more credible on this point. The court also found that the magistrate's decision to order equal cost-sharing was consistent with the provisions of the Act.
The final orders of the Supreme Court were that the appeal be dismissed and that the decision of the Local Court be upheld, with costs to be shared equally between the parties. The court did not provide reasons for its decision, but it appears that the court found that the magistrate's decision was correct and that the appellant had not demonstrated any errors of law or fact that would warrant interference by the Supreme Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the Magistrates Court of Queensland, where the plaintiffs brought an action against the defendants seeking an order for the defendants to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence. The Magistrates Court found in favour of the plaintiffs and ordered the defendants to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence. The defendants appealed the decision of the Magistrates Court to the District Court of Queensland. The appeal was heard by a single judge who dismissed the appeal without providing reasons for the decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the fence between the properties is a sufficient fence as required by the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (Qld).
2. Whether the defendants are required to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence.
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to an order for the defendants to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence and for the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' costs associated with the dispute.
Held
1. The court held that the existing fence between the properties did not meet the definition of a sufficient fence as required by the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (Qld).
2. The court found that the defendants are required to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence.
3. The court granted the plaintiffs an order for the defendants to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence and for the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' costs associated with the dispute.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the statutory definition of a sufficient fence under the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (Qld) and examined the existing fence between the properties. The court found that the existing fence did not meet the statutory requirements for a sufficient fence. The court referred to the statutory definition and relevant case law to determine what constitutes a sufficient fence. As the existing fence did not meet the statutory requirements, the court found that the defendants were required to contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence. The court considered the legislative intent behind the Dividing Fences Act and applied it to the facts of the case to conclude that the defendants must contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence.
In determining the amount of the contribution, the court followed established case law that the cost of a sufficient fence should be shared equally between the adjoining landowners. The court found that the defendants should contribute half the cost of a sufficient fence. The court also considered the plaintiffs' costs associated with the dispute and found that the defendants should be ordered to pay these costs as well.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a fence does not meet the statutory definition of a sufficient fence under the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (Qld), the adjoining landowner who benefits from the fence must contribute to the cost of a sufficient fence and bear their own legal costs associated with the dispute. The court followed established case law in determining the amount of the contribution and the allocation of legal costs.