Police v Mott; Police v Rhodes

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

POLICE v MOTT; POLICE v RHODES

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice White and The Honourable Justice Layton)

14 December 2005

TRAFFIC LAW - OFFENCES - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - ALCOHOL AND DRUG RELATED OFFENCES - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - EVIDENCE

Appeals by the South Australia Police against decisions removing the statutory presumption as to the reliability of breath analysis evidence (Road Traffic Act 1961 s 47G(1)) - in each case the issues on appeal relate to whether mistakes made by the Police in completing the "request form" required under s 47G(2a) constitute departures from the "requirements and procedures" of the legislation for the purposes of s 47G(1) - appeals allowed.

Road Traffic Act 1961 s 47A(1), s 47B, s 47G, s 47E, s 47EB, s 47F; Road Traffic (Miscellaneous) Regulations 1999 reg 8A, reg 10, reg 11, Sch 2, Sch 3, referred to.
Taylor v Daire (1982) 30 SASR 453; Lloyd v Police (2004) 89 SASR 383; Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355; Semmens v Police [1999] SASC 176; Police v Jervis (1998) 70 SASR 429; Police v Henwood (2005) 92 SASR 15; Police v Fountaine (1999) 74 SASR 26; Parker v Police (2002) 83 SASR 67, discussed.

POLICE v MOTT; POLICE v RHODES
[2005] SASC 474

Full Court:      Doyle CJ, White and Layton JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:          The Court heard two appeals, each of which involves a challenge to a Magistrate’s decision to dismiss a charge of driving a motor vehicle while there was present in the defendant’s blood the prescribed concentration of alcohol, contrary to s 47B of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) (“the RTA”).

  2. Each appeal raises yet again the issue of whether failure by a member of the police force to comply with a particular aspect of the legislation and regulations, relating to the analysis of the breath of the driver of a motor vehicle, has the consequence that the statutory presumption raised by s 47G(1) of the RTA, relating to the result of the breath analysis, is not available as an aid to proof. The point in issue is the same in each case.

  3. In each case the Magistrate held that a member of the police force had made a mistake in completing the details in a “request form”. The form is used to record a request made by a defendant for an approved blood test kit. Such a request can be made pursuant to s 47G(2a) of the RTA.

  4. In each case the Magistrate held that the mistake in the “request form” had the consequence that the prosecution had not established for the purposes of s 47G(1) of the RTA that “the requirements and procedures in relation to breath analysing instruments and breath analysis under [the RTA], including sub-sections (2) and (2a)” had been complied with.

  5. It followed, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v Mott; Police v Rhodes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 474
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The South Australia Police appealed against decisions made by the Magistrates Court to dismiss charges against two individuals, Mott and Rhodes, who were accused of driving with a prescribed concentration of alcohol in their blood. The dismissals were based on the argument that the statutory presumption of the reliability of breath analysis evidence under the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) was not applicable due to errors made by the police in completing the "request form" required under s 47G(2a) of the Act. The central legal issues were whether these errors constituted departures from the "requirements and procedures" of the legislation, thus affecting the availability of the statutory presumption.

The court examined whether the completion of the "request form" was a condition for the statutory presumption under s 47G(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA). The court concluded that the form was not integral to the statutory procedures beyond the initial request for a blood test kit. It held that the form's completion was not essential for the admissibility of evidence under s 47G(1a). Therefore, the errors made by the police in filling out the form did not preclude the presumption from applying. The appeals were allowed, and the cases were remitted to the Magistrates Court for further hearings.

The court's decision emphasised that the form's completion was not a critical condition for the statutory presumption, and minor errors did not invalidate the presumption. The form's role was limited to the initial request process and did not impact the admissibility of breath analysis evidence. The appeals were allowed, and the cases were remitted for further hearings. The court also indicated it would hear the parties on the question of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The prosecution in each case relied on the statutory presumption in proof of each charge. Accordingly, in each case the charge was dismissed. The charge could not be proved on the evidence before the Magistrate, without the aid of the statutory presumption.Facts and legislation In each case the defendant was required to submit to a breath analysis. The requirement to do so was made in exercise of the power conferred by s 47E of the RTA. In the case of Mr Mott the breath analysing instrument produced a reading, that by s 47EB of the RTA is to be taken to be a reading of 0.100 grams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood. In Mr Rhodes’ case the reading was 0.08 grams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood. The prescribed concentration of alcohol is defined by s 47A(1) of the RTA as a concentration of 0.05 grams or more of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood. Therefore, in each case the breath analysing instrument indicated that the prescribed concentration of alcohol was present in the blood of the defendant. It is not disputed that in each case the person operating the breath analysing instrument then gave the defendant the prescribed oral notice and the prescribed written notice, as required by s 47G(2a) which provides as follows:47G(2a)Where a person has submitted to an analysis of breath by means of a breath analysing instrument and the concentration of alcohol indicated as being present in the blood of that person by the breath analysing instrument is the prescribed concentration of alcohol, the person operating the instrument must forthwith –(a)give the person the prescribed oral advice and deliver to the person the prescribed written notice as to the operation of this Act in relation to the results of the breath analysis and as to the procedures for the taking and analysis of a sample of the person’s blood; and(b)at the request of the person made in accordance with the regulations, deliver an approved blood test kit to the person. In each case the defendant then requested a blood test kit, and was given “an approved blood test kit”: s 47G(2a)(b). Regulation 10 of the Road Traffic (Miscellaneous) Regulations 1999 (“the Regulations”) is made in exercise of the power conferred by s 47G(2a)(b). It provides:10 Request for approved blood test kit(1)For the purpose of section 47G(2a) of the Act, a request for an approved blood test kit must be made in accordance with the following provisions:(a)the request may, in the first instance, be made orally to the person operating the breath analysing instrument (the operator);(b)on such a request having been made by the person, the operator or any other member of the police force present at the scene must complete a written request form in the form set out in Schedule 2 by inserting the particulars required by form;(c)the person making the request must then sign the request form in the presence of the operator or other member of the police force and the person’s signature must be attested to by the signature of the operator or other member;(d)the original of the signed request form may be retained by the person making the request;(e)a copy of the signed request form must be delivered to the operator or other member of the police force.(2)The copy of the request form delivered to the operator or other member of the police force must be delivered to the Minister or retained on the Minister’s behalf for 12 months from the day on which the request form was signed by the person making the request.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For those reasons I consider that the issue that arises on these appeals is not resolved by considering whether there has been substantial compliance with the requirements of reg 10, or by considering whether there has been compliance with reg 10, on the basis that a trifling departure from the requirements can be ignored, as was done by this Court in Lloyd. To my mind the issue is resolved, as I have attempted to do, by considering whether or not the relevant aspect of reg 10 is made a condition of the availability of the statutory presumption. Were I to approach the matter in the terms in which it was approached in Lloyd, , I would have come to the same conclusion. But my reasons, which would then reflect more closely the submissions by the Solicitor-General, would reflect the fact that the mistakes made in completing the “request form” in this case, are of no significance in the statutory scheme, and accordingly can be disregarded.Conclusion For those reasons I would allow each appeal. In the case of Mr Mott I would set aside the order dismissing the complaint, and order that the matter be remitted to the Magistrate who heard the matter for further hearing in accordance with these reasons. In the case of Mr Rhodes I would allow the appeal. I would set aside the order of the Judge dismissing the appeal to this Court. I would order that there be substituted an order allowing the appeal to this Court, and for the order dismissing the complaint I would substitute an order that the proceedings be remitted to the Magistrate who heard them for further hearing in accordance with these reasons. I would hear the parties on the question of costs. WHITE J: The circumstances of these two appeals, and the statutory and regulatory provisions relating to them, are set out in the judgment of the Chief Justice. Each raises the question of whether an error by a police officer in entering the particulars on the prescribed form of written request for an approved blood test kit has the effect of precluding the prosecution from relying on the presumption contained in s 47G(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) (“RTA”). The starting point for the consideration of that question is the language in s 47G(1) establishing the presumption: … where the requirements and procedures in relation to breath analysing instruments and breath analysis under this Act, including sub-ss (2) and (2a), have been complied with it must be presumed, in the absence of proof to the contrary, that the concentration of alcohol [indicated by the instrument] was present in the blood of the defendant at the time of the analysis. It is compliance with “the requirements and procedures” of the specified type which conditions the availability of the presumption. That being so, the resolution of these appeals requires consideration of two issues: is completion by the operator of the form set out in Sch 2 to the Road Traffic (Miscellaneous) Regulations 1999 (“the Regulations”) with the particulars required by that form a requirement or procedure under the RTA to which s 47G(1) refers and, if so, has there been compliance in each case with that requirement?The Requirements and Procedures Under This Act

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In support of his overall submissions, Mr Edwardson relies on the well known cases dealing with the presumption created by s 47G(1), and the effect of it requiring compliance with the requirements and procedures referred to, as a condition of the availability of the presumption. The main cases are referred to by White J in Lloyd at [72]-[75]. In Police v Henwood [2005] SASC 209; (2005) 92 SASR 15 at [31]-[37] I briefly summarised the operation of the statutory presumption. Consideration of submissions I accept Mr Kourakis’s submission that the “request form” does not call for the member of the police force to insert the time of taking the breath sample which is, by operation of reg 8A(3), taken to be the reading produced by the breath analysis instrument (because it is the lower of the two readings obtained). The form refers to the time at which the person “submitted to a breath analysis”. That is not a precise expression. It might refer to the time when the person first exhales after the first direction given to exhale into a breath analysing instrument: s 47E(2d). It might be taken as referring to the period of time during which the person provides two samples of breath for analysis as required by reg 8A(1). Commonsense would suggest that the reference is to the former, being the first process which would fit within the description, but the latter would also comply with the requirements of the form. The time recorded on the “request form” need not be the time of the analysis of the sample relied on by operation of reg 8A(3), as submitted by Mr Edwardson. It follows that in Mr Rhodes’ case the time inserted by the police officer was a sufficient compliance within the requirement of the form (subject to the mistake as to the year). I consider that the completion of the “request form” is the means by which a person makes a request “in accordance with the Regulations”: s 47G(2a)(b). Regulation 10 permits (and indirectly requires) an oral request (the making of which is not recorded on the form) followed by the signing of the “request form”. A person who does not make a request at all, or who refuses to sign the form and deliver a copy of the signed form to a member of the police force, is probably not entitled to the delivery of a breath test kit. But the “request form” need play no further part in the statutory procedures relating to breath analysis or analysis of a blood sample or in proceedings alleging an offence contrary to s 47B of the RTA. The person who requests the blood test kit is not required to retain the form or to produce the form as a condition of presenting evidence in reliance on s 47G(1a). If the person’s entitlement to give such evidence is challenged, the person can give oral evidence of the oral request, and of the fact of completion of the form and of delivery of an approved blood test kit. The person could call for production of the original form of request if it is still held by the Minister: see reg 10(2). The form need be kept by the Minister only for 12 months. Production by the person of that person’s copy of the “request form” would, of course, be permissible and helpful. My point is that it is not essential before evidence can be led under s 47G(1a).