Police v Davidson No. Scgrg-97-1314 Judgment No. S6411

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

R  v  DAVIDSON

Magistrates Appeal

Nyland J

This is a prosecution appeal against sentence. The respondent appeared before a stipendiary magistrate in the Elizabeth Magistrates Court on 15 August 1997. He pleaded not guilty to a charge of driving a motor vehicle whilst there was present in his blood the prescribed concentration of alcohol, that concentration being .158 grams in one hundred millilitres of blood. He had been detected following a test conducted at a random breath testing station at about 7.46 pm on Saturday, 25 May 1997 at Gilbert Street, Hamley Bridge. The learned magistrate found the charge proved but thereafter invited the respondent through his counsel to make an application for the offence to be considered as "trifling", pursuant to the provisions of s47B(3)(b) of the Road Traffic Act 1961.

The magistrate, after hearing the evidence of the respondent, found that the offence was trifling.  He imposed a fine of $750 and ordered that the respondent be disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for a period of six weeks, to commence from 12.01 am on 1 October 1997. 

The appellant has appealed on the ground that the magistrate erred in finding that the offence was "trifling". The question whether an offence is trifling is one of fact.  It is an issue which has been frequently considered by the courts.

In Mancini v Vallelonga , Mitchell J stated the principles which have been consistently applied.  Debelle J referred to that matter in South Australian Police v Hodge and South Australian Police v Hughes , and summarised some of the relevant authorities.  The considerations which are to be taken into account may be summarised as follows:

  1. Whether or not the facts of the case at bar are atypical or not.  If the answer to this question is in the negative then the offence in general terms will not be considered to be trifling.

  1. If an offence is found to have been deliberately committed, then it is generally unlikely that the court would find the offence to be trifling.

  1. If it is a mere technical, casual or inadvertent breach and there is no deliberate intention to breach the relevant Statute it may be found to be trifling.

  1. An offence might be considered trifling if the facts reveal compelling reasons of a humanitarian nature or compelling reasons for safety for doing what was in fact done.

  1. In situations where there has been some form of emergency involved in events the offence may be found to be trifling.

As Debelle J said in South Australian Police v Hodge and South Australian Police v Hughes:

"... it is the circumstances of the offence which must be considered when determining whether an offence is trifling.  Any hardship which might follow to a defendant in consequence of the ordering of penalties are not relevant factors when determining whether the offence is trifling."

In Verran v Roberts , Napier J observed of the discretion to regard an offence as trifling that:

"It is impossible for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v Davidson No. Scgrg-97-1314 Judgment No. S6411 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] SASC 6411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Police v Davidson involved a conviction for driving with a blood alcohol concentration above the legal limit. The respondent, who was detected at a random breath testing station, pleaded not guilty but was found guilty by the magistrate. The magistrate then considered whether the offence was trifling under the Road Traffic Act 1961 and concluded that it was, imposing a fine and a six-week disqualification from holding a driver's licence. The prosecution appealed this decision, arguing that the magistrate had erred in finding the offence trifling.

The court examined the legal principles governing the determination of whether an offence is trifling, referencing precedents that outlined factors such as whether the offence was atypical, deliberate, or due to a technical breach. It also noted that the circumstances of the offence, not the potential hardship to the defendant, should guide such a determination. The court summarised these principles, emphasising that while courts must have discretion to mitigate harsh laws, they must not abuse this power to undermine legislative intent.

Upon reviewing the facts of the case, the court observed that the respondent was an operator of heavy machinery, concerned about his wife’s health, and had not intended to drive with excess alcohol. However, the court found that these circumstances did not make the offence trifling. The respondent's error in judgment, the lack of an emergency situation, and his consumption of a quantity of alcohol that was not close to the legal limit were factors that did not support a finding of a trifling offence. The court concluded that the magistrate had given undue weight to the respondent's hardship and potential job loss, which are factors relevant to penalty but not to the characterisation of the offence as trifling.

The appeal was allowed, and the court imposed a fine of $700, court fees of $73, a levy of $28, and a disqualification from holding a driver's licence for 12 months. The court found these penalties to be appropriate given the circumstances but emphasised that the offence was not trifling.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established