Police v David (Lurnpa Tjambatjimba) Cole

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
CITATION:  Police v David (Lurnpa Tjambatjimba) Cole [2024] NTLC
10
PARTIES:  Police
v
David (Lurnpa Tjambatjimba) Cole
TITLE OF COURT:  LOCAL COURT
JURISDICTION:  CRIMINAL
FILE NO(s):  22204351
DELIVERED ON:  18 October 2024
DELIVERED AT:  Darwin
HEARING DATE(s):  27 August and 14 October 2024
DECISION OF:  Judge Greg Macdonald
CATCHWORDS: 

Assault – Evidence – Investigation – Disclosure – Decision to prosecute – s 31 Criminal Code –
Intent or foreseen as possible - s 188 Criminal Code – ‘touching’ without consent – s 200 Criminal

Code – Threaten detriment to hinder.

Criminal Code s 188 (1) and (2) a

Local Court (Procedure) Act, ss 60AB, 60AE, 60AF, 60AJ and 60AK

Petty and Maiden v The Queen [1991] HCA 34
Keeley v Brooking (1979) 143 CLR 162 at 169
The Queen v Dookheea [2017] HCA 36 at [36] and [41].
R v Murray (1987) 11 NSWLR 12.
Pregelj v Manison (1987) 51 NTR 1
Watson v Trenerry; Williams v Trenerry [1998] NTCA 22

Collins v Wilcock (1984) 3 All ER 374

Page | 1

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Police:  Mr B Morgan
Defendant:  Mr B Fernandez

Solicitors:

Police:  Office of the DPP
Defendant:  NT Legal Aid Commission
Decision category classification B

Decision ID number: [2024] NTLC 10

Number of paragraphs: 21

Page | 2

IN THE LOCAL COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN

TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 22204351

BETWEEN:

POLICE

Applicant

AND:

DAVID (LURNPA TJAMBATJIMBA) COLE

Defendant

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 18 October 2024)

JUDGE MACDONALD

Background

1.        On 9 December 2021 an incident occurred proximate to the front door of the Local Court at Darwin. That incident involved the Defendant (Lurnpa) and a person carrying out their duties as a photo-journalist, known as A.

2.        On that day A was sitting on one of the large spherical stone bollards affixed approximately 4 metres from the entrance to the Local Court, and saw Lurnpa walking down Harry Chan Avenue

towards that entrance. He was known to A and the evidence was that A’s role in employment

included to obtain photographs of persons attending court for matters on which the NT News was reporting. Regardless of the various perspectives discussed below, A was undoubtedly carrying out their duties as an employed photojournalist on 9 December 2021 when they sought to take photographs of Lurnpa as he approached the entrance to the Local Court. Upon seeing A ready their large camera for its purpose, Lurnpa first sought to obscure his face with a water bottle, and then produced a mobile phone and appears to seek to commence recording A from a distance of approximately 6 metres.

3.        Lurnpa then advanced on A, who remained seated on the stone ball. It is noted that A’s oral

evidence included him stating that the phone footage was being broadcast on social media, so

Page | 3

recorded to that extent.[1] The prosecution case did not include any downloads from any platform, however Lurnpa adduced the recording in evidence in his defence. The content is particularly telling, and it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v David (Lurnpa Tjambatjimba) Cole and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NTLC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter between the police and David (Lurnpa Tjambatjimba) Cole, also known as Lurnpa, was heard in a court where Lurnpa contested three charges. These charges related to incidents occurring around three years prior, and the case had been rescheduled multiple times, with this being the second occasion for a hearing. Among the key issues was whether Lurnpa's conduct towards an individual, referred to as A, constituted criminal offences under the relevant statutes. Lurnpa had pleaded not guilty to charges including assault, use of an offensive weapon, and threatening to cause injury or detriment.

The court was tasked with determining whether Lurnpa's actions and words towards A constituted criminal offences. Specifically, it needed to consider whether Lurnpa's confrontational behaviour and physical contact with A's identification card amounted to assault, whether his recording of the interaction with A constituted the use of an offensive weapon, and whether his words and actions towards A amounted to threatening to cause injury or detriment. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Lurnpa's recording and broadcasting of the interaction were within legal boundaries.

The court found that Lurnpa's conduct, while confrontational and potentially offensive, did not reach the criminal threshold for the charges laid. Notably, the court determined that Lurnpa's recording of the incident was not prohibited under the Surveillance Devices Act, nor was his broadcasting of the interaction on the internet. While some of Lurnpa's communication could be considered a diatribe and potentially harmful, it did not constitute a criminal threat. Consequently, the charges against Lurnpa were dismissed as not proven beyond reasonable doubt.

The court concluded that the prosecution had failed to establish the charges against Lurnpa to the required standard. The court's decision was based on the specific legal standards for each charge and the evidence presented. The charges were dismissed, and no further legal action would proceed against Lurnpa for these incidents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 27 August 2024 Lurnpa pled not guilty to the three charges and a contested hearing ensued. No witness list was provided to the court, although it appeared that the Defendant’s counsel was aware of what witnesses the prosecution proposed. Oral evidence was given to the court by A. An investigating police officer might also have been called, however no statement from that officer had been provided to the Defendant. It was noted that the charges were approaching three years of age, and that the hearing on 27 August 2024 was the second occasion on which the matter had been listed for hearing. Also, that the hearing had been listed for some considerable period of time. Some evidentiary issues arising in the investigation are referred to below. Evidence and findings Contrary to his counsel’s suggestion, it is not the case that Lurnpa was “annoyingly polite” in his interactions with A. He was annoyed and sought to fight fire with fire, including by being confrontational in his mobile recording and communication with A. Ultimately, he also made contact with A’s ID Card, being worn on their person. Similarly, count 3, ‘threatening to injure or cause detriment’, is not proven beyond reasonable doubt. It is noted that Lurnpa was not prohibited by the Surveillance Devices Act from recording the public situation, and the court was not referred to any legal proscription in relation to broadcasting public interactions on the internet. Most relevantly, despite that aspects of his communication may be characterised as diatribe and potentially detrimental to A, the Defendant is not proven to have contravened the criminal law to the necessary standard by acting and speaking in the way he did.[11] It is not the court’s function in the proceeding to consider potential civil legal issues.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established