POLICE v BRIDGES
Magistrates’ Appeal
Bleby J
The respondent was charged on complaint with an offence contrary to s28(1)(b) of the Summary Offences Act 1953. The particulars of the offence alleged against her were that on 24 July 1997 at Wayville she received money paid in a brothel situated at an address in Wayville, in respect of prostitution. The maximum penalty for this offence in the case of a first offender is a fine of $1,000 or imprisonment for three months. For a second or subsequent offence the maximum penalty is imprisonment for six months or a fine of $2,000.
On 12 January 1998 the respondent pleaded guilty to the offence in the Adelaide Magistrate’s Court. She was then represented by Mr McGee, a legal practitioner, who also appeared for her before me. The circumstances of what happened at the hearing are described in an affidavit of Andrew Paech, the prosecutor, and I read para 3 of that affidavit. He referred to the fact that the respondent pleaded guilty and he then said:
“Her Honour then, without giving me the opportunity to present the facts of the matter or to allege any prior convictions, asked Mr McGee if a penalty of no conviction, no fine, and no costs, would be acceptable. Mr McGee replied that it was and her Honour simply ordered the defendant to pay the victims of crime levy without conviction or further penalty. I recall that her Honour then stated words to the effect that this would be her penalty while the men were not charged with any offence for their part in crimes of this type.”
The complainant now appeals against the order made by the magistrate. The grounds of appeal allege that the learned magistrate erred in failing to record a conviction and to impose a penalty.
The first question to be considered is whether this is an appropriate case in which to entertain an appeal by the Crown against the failure to enter a conviction and to impose a penalty. That question was recently considered by this court in Police v Cadd & Ors (1997) 69 SASR 150, where the court by majority decided that Crown appeals under s42 of the Magistrate’s Court Act 1991 should be in accordance with the principles established by the High Court in Everett v R (1994) 181 CLR 295, namely that Crown appeals against sentence should only be entertained in a “rare and exceptional case”. They will be confined, so the court said, to cases where it is necessary to establish some matter of principle for the governance and guidance of lower courts. The High Court held that that notion encompassed the correction of manifest inadequacy in sentencing standards, constituting an error in point of principle.
The majority in Cadd’s case expressly stated that what the High Court had said in Everett’s case was not inconsistent with what King CJ had said in R v Osenkowski (1982) 30 SASR 212 at pp212-213. That passage reads as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v Bridges No. Scgrg-98-31 Judgment No. S6582 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6582
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court emphasised that it was not the role of the magistrate to tailor penalties to fit social theories or policy defects perceived by her. The only relevant social policy was that reflected by Parliament in the Acts it passed. The court also noted that the magistrate had no right to entertain the question as to whether males in other circumstances should or should not have been prosecuted for offences relating to prostitution, or to entertain the question as to the perceived inadequacy of the law to deal with males who make use of prostitutes. The court found that the proceedings had miscarried in these material respects, and the appeal must inevitably be allowed. In the interests of justice, the court determined an appropriate penalty after taking into account all the relevant circumstances. The circumstances of the offence were that the respondent had received money for sexual services from a police officer acting as an agent. The respondent's record of previous convictions included minor traffic offences, one minor offence of larceny, and breaches of the Summary Offences Act and the Liquor Licensing Act. The court imposed a fine of $100, taking into account the circumstances of the offence and the antecedents of the respondent. The magistrate previously ordered the payment of $28 by way of levy, which would remain in addition to the fine and other costs. The total amount due was $217, and the respondent was given six months to pay the fine, costs, and levy imposed. The court made no order as to the costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi