PARTIES: ERICA ANN SIMMS
v
KATE ADAMS
TITLE OF COURT: Court of Summary Jurisdiction
JURISDICTION: Criminal
FILE NO(s): 20826515
DELIVERED ON: 10th March 2010
DELIVERED AT: Darwin
HEARING DATE(s): 8th October 2009 and 29th January 2010
Submissions 23rd February 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Ms Fong Lim SM
CATCHWORDS:
Crime – aggravated assault – Transit Officers – power to arrest - discretion to arrest –unlawful arrest –improper arrest - Public Transport (Passenger Safety) Act sections 3, 11, & 27
Bunning v Cross [1978] 141 CLR 54 - applied
Fleet v District Court and Ors [1999] NSWCA 363 -considered
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Complainant: Ms Horvatt
Defendant: Ms Bennett
Solicitors:
Complainant: Director of Public Prosecutions
Defendant: Northern Territory Legal Aid Commission
Judgment category classification: C
Judgment ID number: [2010] NTMC 015
Number of paragraphs: 54
IN THE COURT OF SUMMARY JURISDICTION
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA
No. 20826515
[2010] NTMC 015
BETWEEN:
ERICA ANN SIMMS
Complainant
AND:
KATE ADAMS
Defendant
REASONS FOR DECISION
(Delivered 10th March 2010)
Ms FONG LIM RSM:
1. Kate Adams faces four charges, one count of disorderly conduct in a public place and three counts of assault on Transit Officers. Two of those assaults are alleged to have resulted in the Transit Officers suffering harm.
2. On the first occasion this matter came before me, Adams pleaded not guilty to the charge of disorderly conduct, however after leave was granted to amend the charge on the second hearing day on 28 January 2010, she then pleaded guilty to that charge. The assault charges remain in contest.
3. On 26 September 2008 Transit Officers McCorkell, Newport and Mussak were called to attend a bus stop at Coles in Palmerston to attend to an intoxicated male. They arrived and attended to the drunken man when McCorkell noticed Adams approaching the bus stop with a full shopping trolley. Adams had a current Trespass Notice to stay away from bus stops and the public buses.
4. McCorkell and Adams had a discussion about her intention or otherwise to get onto a bus, that discussion became heated with Adams verbally abusing the Transit Officers in general and McCorkell in particular. Who started the conversation and what was said before the argument became heated is disputed.
5. Adams is then alleged to have assaulted McCorkell at which point Adams was arrested and restrained by the Transit Officers. The disorderly conduct charge is particularised as Adams’ bad language in her abuse of the Officers. The assaults particularised as the flicking of a cigarette at and the punching of McCorkell and the biting, scratching and kicking of Newport and biting of Mussak.
6. Prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt all of the elements of each offence and negative any positive defence put forward by Adams beyond a reasonable doubt.
7. To find Adams guilty of the assault charges, I must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that she applied direct or indirect force upon McCorkell, Newport and Mussak,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v Adams and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NTMC 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether Adams committed an offence that justified the Transit Officers' power to arrest her, and if the arrest was lawful. Additionally, if the arrest was unlawful, the court had to decide whether to exclude evidence of events following the arrest, in line with the principles in Bunning v Cross. The court had to consider the powers of Transit Officers under the Public Transport (Passenger Safety) Act and whether Adams' actions constituted an assault warranting arrest. The court also had to examine the location of the alleged assault in relation to the bus stop to determine if the arrest was lawful.
The court concluded that the arrest of Adams was unlawful because it was not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the assault occurred "at a bus stop." Therefore, the Transit Officers did not have the power to arrest Adams at that moment. The court also decided that evidence of the events following the unlawful arrest should be excluded on public policy grounds, as the unlawful arrest led to Adams' escalating behaviour. Consequently, Adams was found not guilty of the charges relating to assaults on Newport and Mussak. However, she was found guilty of the assault on McCorkell, including the aggravating circumstance that McCorkell was a member of the public service executing his duty.
The final orders of the court were that Adams was found not guilty of the charges relating to assaults on Newport and Mussak, but guilty of the assault on McCorkell.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi