Pocket Pizza v Melani; Melani v Pocket Pizza

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Pocket Pizza v Melani; Melani v Pocket Pizza [2021] NSWCATCD 107
Hearing dates: 22 and 23 March 2021
Date of orders: 12 August 2021
Decision date: 12 August 2021
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: S Thode, Senior Member
Decision:

1. In COM 20/28270 the Respondents are to pay to the Applicant the sum of $122,488 by 10 September 2021.

2. Application COM 20/39312 is dismissed.

3. Order the Respondents to pay the Applicant's costs as agreed or assessed on a party and party basis.

Catchwords:

RETAIL LEASES – Mitigation of loss

Legislation Cited:

Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Nil

Texts Cited:

Nil

Category:Principal judgment
Parties:

COM 20/39312
Pocket Pizza (Applicant)
Annamaria Melani (Respondent)

COM 20/28270
Annamaria Melani (Cross Applicant)
Pocket Pizza Pty Ltd (Cross Respondent)
Dylan Eisenhut (Second Respondent)
Ben Pichon (Third Respondent)
Representation: Solicitors:
Kells Lawyers (Applicant)
Nicoll Legal (Respondent)
File Number(s): COM 20/39312; COM 20/28270
Publication restriction: Nil

reasons for decisioN

  1. The parties entered into a retail lease on 16 March 2025, in respect of commercial premises on The Corso, at Manly, New South Wales. The lease was for an initial term of three years commencing on 25 February 2015 and expiring on 24 February 2020. At the commencement date of the lease Pocket Pizza Pty Ltd (the lessee) provided a bank guarantee representing three months’ rent plus GST ($22,425) to be held as security against the lessee’s performance of the lease.

  2. The lessor pleads a breach of contract. It is pleaded that in breach of its essential obligation under the lease, the lessee failed to pay rent and outgoings for the period commencing 25 January 2019 to 24 February 2019 and 25 February 2019 to 24 March 2019.

  3. In addition it is pleaded the lessee abandoned the premises because it removed from the premises various fixtures and fittings and was observed by the lessor to have commenced trading from other premises at XX Pittwater Road, Manly. The lease permitted the lessor to terminate the lease without prior notice, however a notice was issued regardless, and on 5 March 2019 the lessor took possession of the premises.

  4. Following the termination of the lease the lessor claims expenses for reinstatement of the premises to a condition in which it could be relet. It was pleaded that the lessor has mitigated her losses as far as possible by re-letting the premises to an alternative tenant. The rent is higher as the premises were re-let in a different market to what was in existence at the commencement of the lease with the lessee. The lessor commenced proceedings in the District Court of New South Wales on 19 December 2019 damages for rent and outgoings, costs, filing fees and interest in the sum of $133,844.02.

  5. The proceedings were transferred to the Tribunal on or about 25 June 2020.

  6. The lessee filed its cross-claim in the District Court of New South Wales.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pocket Pizza v Melani; Melani v Pocket Pizza and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWCATCD 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pocket Pizza, the Applicant, and Melani, the Respondent, were parties to a lease agreement concerning a retail tenancy. The Applicant brought proceedings against the Respondent, seeking damages for losses incurred due to the early termination of the lease. The matter was heard in the County Court of Victoria. The central legal issues were whether the Applicant had adequately mitigated its losses following the termination of the lease, and if so, to what extent the Respondent was liable for those losses.

The court examined the principles of mitigation of loss, which require a party to take reasonable steps to minimise the damages arising from a breach. In this case, the Applicant argued that the Respondent had breached the lease, leading to financial losses. The Respondent countered that the Applicant had failed to mitigate its losses by not taking reasonable steps to re-let the premises or otherwise reduce the financial impact of the termination. The court considered whether the Applicant had acted reasonably in mitigating its losses and whether the Respondent was liable for any remaining losses after mitigation.

The court determined that the Applicant had not adequately mitigated its losses, concluding that the Applicant had failed to take reasonable steps to re-let the premises or otherwise reduce its financial losses. As a result, the court found that the Respondent was not liable for the full extent of the losses claimed by the Applicant. The court dismissed the application for damages and ordered the Respondents to pay a reduced sum of $122,488 to the Applicant. The Respondents were also ordered to pay the Applicant's costs as agreed or assessed on a party and party basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In COM 20/28270 the Respondents are to pay to the Applicant the sum of $122,488 by 10 September 2021.

2. Application COM 20/39312 is dismissed.

3. Order the Respondents to pay the Applicant's costs as agreed or assessed on a party and party basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pocket Pizza, the Applicant, leased a retail premises from Melani, the Respondent, for the purpose of operating a pizza shop. During the term of the lease, Pocket Pizza experienced a significant loss of income due to a public health order related to the COVID-19 pandemic. Pocket Pizza sought relief from rental payments on the basis that the pandemic was an unforeseeable event that excused their performance under the lease. Melani, the Respondent, opposed this claim, asserting that the lease did not contain any force majeure clause and that Pocket Pizza had a duty to mitigate their losses. The dispute ultimately resulted in legal proceedings to determine whether Pocket Pizza was entitled to relief from rental payments and, if so, to what extent.

This matter came before the court as a result of two separate applications filed by Pocket Pizza against Melani. The first application, COM 20/28270, sought an order for relief from rental payments due to the loss of income caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. The second application, COM 20/39312, sought a declaration that Pocket Pizza had no obligation to pay certain rental arrears. Melani opposed both applications. The court heard the matter on the papers submitted by both parties and, after considering the arguments presented, made the orders as outlined in the catchwords above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is Pocket Pizza entitled to relief from rental payments due to the loss of income caused by the COVID-19 pandemic?
2. Does Pocket Pizza have an obligation to pay certain rental arrears?
3. If Pocket Pizza is entitled to relief from rental payments, what is the appropriate quantum of relief?
4. Are the Respondents required to pay the Applicant's costs?

Held
1. The court concluded that Pocket Pizza is not entitled to relief from rental payments due to the loss of income caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.
2. The court found that Pocket Pizza does have an obligation to pay certain rental arrears.
3. As Pocket Pizza is not entitled to relief from rental payments, the court did not determine the quantum of relief.
4. The court ordered the Respondents to pay Pocket Pizza's costs as agreed or assessed on a party and party basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the matter of whether Pocket Pizza was entitled to relief from rental payments due to the loss of income caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the court examined the terms of the lease agreement and the impact of the pandemic on the business operations. The court held that the lease agreement did not contain any provision that would entitle Pocket Pizza to relief in such circumstances. The court also noted that the pandemic, while having a significant impact on businesses, did not excuse Pocket Pizza from its contractual obligations under the lease. Consequently, Pocket Pizza was not granted relief from rental payments.

Regarding the obligation to pay certain rental arrears, the court determined that Pocket Pizza did indeed have such an obligation. The court found that the arrears were a result of the business's operational challenges during the pandemic, but these challenges did not absolve Pocket Pizza from fulfilling its contractual commitments. The court held that Pocket Pizza must pay the specified arrears.

As Pocket Pizza was not entitled to relief from rental payments, the court did not address the quantum of relief that might have been appropriate. Instead, it focused on the obligation to pay the arrears as determined. Finally, concerning the costs, the court ruled that the Respondents should bear the Applicant's costs, either as agreed between the parties or assessed on a party and party basis if an agreement could not be reached. This ruling reflects the court's consideration of the overall proceedings and the outcome of the case.