PMB Australia Ltd v MMI General Insurance Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: PMB Australia Ltd v MMI General Insurance Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2001] QSC 339
PARTIES: PMB AUSTRALIA LIMITED ACN 057 251 091
(plaintiff)
v
MMI GENERAL INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 000 122 850
(first defendant)
and
SUN ALLIANCE & ROYAL INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED ACN 005 297 807
(second defendant)
and
CIC INSURANCE LIMITED ACN 004 078 880
(in provisional liquidation)
(third defendant)
and
ZURICH AUSTRALIAN INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 000 296 640
(fourth defendant)
and
SUNCORP GENERAL INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 075 695 966
(fifth defendant)
and
GIO GENERAL LIMITED ACN 002 861 583
(sixth defendant)
and
QBE INSURANCE LIMITED ACN 000 157 899
(seventh defendant)
and
FAI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
ACN 000 327 855 (in provisional liquidation)
(eighth defendant)
FILE NO: 5235 of 1998
DIVISION: Trial Division
DELIVERED ON: 18 September 2001
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: Written submissions
JUDGE: Mullins J
ORDERS:

1.   Leave be given to the plaintiff to file the application dated 24 August 2001 seeking leave to amend the statement of claim and the affidavit of Mark Damien Darwin sworn on 24 August 2001.

2.   The application seeking leave to amend the statement of claim be dismissed.

3.   The plaintiff pay the first, second, fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh defendants’ costs of that application to be assessed.

4.   The plaintiff have judgment as follows:

(a)   as against the first defendant for the sum of $321,277.50;

(b)     as against the second defendant for the sum of $89,243.75;

(c)   as against the fourth defendant for the sum of $71,395.00;

(d)     as against the fifth defendant for the sum of $49,976.50;

(e)   as against the sixth defendant for the sum of $42,837.00;

(f)   as against the seventh defendant for the sum of $35,697.50.

5. The daily interest that accrues under s 57(2) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) on each judgment sum until payment is respectively:

First defendant  $58.11
Second defendant  $16.14
Fourth defendant  $12.91
Fifth defendant  $9.04
Sixth defendant  $7.75
Seventh defendant  $6.46
6.  The first, second, fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh defendants pay 80% of the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding including reserved costs to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

INSURANCE – GENERAL – assessment of interest carrying costs – assessment of interest payable under s 57 Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth)

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – leave sought to amend statement of claim after publication of reasons for judgment but before final judgment – prospects of success of proposed claims considered – relevance of timing of application

COSTS – appropriate costs order where plaintiff is successful in its claim but unsuccessful in respect of significant issues of quantum – departure from usual order that costs follow the event

Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth)
Insurance Contracts Regulations 1985 (Cth)

UCPR r 375(1), r 689 (1), r 690(5)

Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Ex 341; 156 ER 145
Re Mining Technologies Australia Pty Ltd [1999] 1QdR 60
Moss v Sun Alliance Australia Ltd (1990) 55 SASR 145
Motor Accident…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PMB Australia Ltd v MMI General Insurance Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 339
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

PMB Australia Ltd sought damages from several defendants, including MMI General Insurance Ltd, for losses related to insurance contracts. The dispute centred on the assessment of interest carrying costs and the calculation of interest under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The court had to decide whether the plaintiff was entitled to amend its statement of claim after the publication of reasons for judgment but before the final judgment, and if so, whether the proposed claims had prospects of success. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate interest rates and the appropriate costs order given the plaintiff's partial success in its claims.

The court considered the timing of the application to amend the statement of claim, noting that the application was made after the reasons for judgment had been published but before the final judgment was delivered. The court found that the application was made too late and dismissed the request to amend the statement of claim. The court further examined the merits of the plaintiff's claims against the individual defendants, awarding damages to PMB Australia Ltd against six of the defendants. Regarding the interest payable, the court determined the daily interest rates under section 57(2) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). The court also ordered that the defendants pay 80% of the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs, which were to be assessed on the standard basis.

In summary, the court denied leave to amend the statement of claim but proceeded to assess the merits of the claims. The plaintiff was successful in obtaining damages against several defendants and was awarded interest on the judgment sums. The court also ordered that the defendants pay a significant portion of the plaintiff's costs, departing from the usual order that costs follow the event.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be given to the plaintiff to file the application dated 24 August 2001 seeking leave to amend the statement of claim and the affidavit of Mark Damien Darwin sworn on 24 August 2001.

2. The application seeking leave to amend the statement of claim be dismissed.

3. The plaintiff pay the first, second, fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh defendants’ costs of that application to be assessed.

4. The plaintiff have judgment as follows:

(a) as against the first defendant for the sum of $321,277.50;

(b) as against the second defendant for the sum of $89,243.75;

(c) as against the fourth defendant for the sum of $71,395.00;

(d) as against the fifth defendant for the sum of $49,976.50;

(e) as against the sixth defendant for the sum of $42,837.00;

(f) as against the seventh defendant for the sum of $35,697.50.

5. The daily interest that accrues under s 57(2) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) on each judgment sum until payment is respectively:

First defendant $58.11

Second defendant $16.14

Fourth defendant $12.91

Fifth defendant $9.04

Sixth defendant $7.75

Seventh defendant $6.46

6. The first, second, fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh defendants pay 80% of the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding including reserved costs to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns the assessment of interest carrying costs and interest payable under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) in relation to a claim by PMB Australia Ltd against several defendants, including MMI General Insurance Ltd. PMB Australia Ltd, the plaintiff, sought damages for breach of contract and other claims against the defendants, who were various insurance companies. The plaintiff's claims were related to the underwriting of certain policies and the subsequent handling of claims by the defendants. The matter resulted in the plaintiff being successful in its claim but facing difficulties in respect of the quantum of interest and costs.

The plaintiff initially filed a statement of claim and subsequently applied for leave to amend the statement of claim after the reasons for judgment had been published but before the final judgment was handed down. The plaintiff sought to add new claims based on the interpretation of section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) concerning the assessment of interest. The plaintiff argued that the proposed amendments had a real prospect of success and that the application was made in good time.

The case came before the court following the plaintiff's initial claim and the defendants' responses. The matter proceeded through the usual stages of pleadings, discovery, and evidence. After the reasons for judgment were published, the plaintiff applied for leave to amend the statement of claim. This application was made after the publication of reasons for judgment but before the final judgment was delivered. The defendants opposed the application on the grounds of timing and the prospects of success of the proposed amendments. The court considered the application and the arguments presented by both parties before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave should be granted to the plaintiff to amend the statement of claim after the reasons for judgment have been published but before the final judgment is delivered.
2. What are the prospects of success of the proposed amendments to the statement of claim?
3. Should the court depart from the usual order that costs follow the event given the plaintiff's partial success on its claims?

Held
1. The court held that leave should not be granted to the plaintiff to amend the statement of claim after the reasons for judgment have been published but before the final judgment is delivered.
2. The court determined that the prospects of success for the proposed amendments to the statement of claim were insufficient to warrant leave to amend.
3. The court decided that it should depart from the usual order that costs follow the event given the plaintiff's partial success on its claims, and ordered a costs assessment that reflected this.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application to amend the statement of claim in light of the timing of the application and the content of the proposed amendments. It noted that leave to amend pleadings is not a matter of strict right and should be granted only if there is a good reason to do so. The court found that the proposed amendments were not significant enough to warrant a departure from the usual order of proceedings and that there was no good reason to permit the amendment at that stage. Regarding the prospects of success, the court examined the evidence and arguments presented and concluded that the proposed amendments would not likely change the outcome of the case. The court also addressed the issue of costs, acknowledging the plaintiff's success on some claims but also its failure on significant issues of quantum. It determined that a partial costs order was appropriate to reflect the plaintiff's partial success, departing from the usual order that costs follow the event. The court based its decision on the principle that the costs order should reflect the nature and extent of the success achieved by each party.