Plummer and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

Plummer and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation) [2020] AATA 3759 (25 September 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/1960

Re:Michael Plummer

APPLICANT

National Australia Bank LimitedAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Date:25 September 2020

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision of the respondent dated 7 February 2019 is affirmed.

...........................[SGD]............................................

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS COMPENSATION – psychological injury – claim for anxiety disorder, panic attacks and agoraphobia  – whether the applicant suffers an ailment, or an aggravation of an ailment – whether the ailment, or aggravation of the ailment, was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the applicant’s employment – non-work related stressors affecting the employee’s health – predisposition of employee to ailment, or aggravation of the ailment – whether the respondent is liable to pay compensation – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 5B, 7(4), 14

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

25 September 2020

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant seeks a review of the reviewable decision of the respondent dated 7 February 2019. This reviewable decision determined that the respondent was not liable under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (‘SRC Act’) for the applicant’s claimed “anxiety disorder, panic attacks, agoraphobia” which he attributed to abusive telephone calls with customers he liaised with in his role within the Direct Consumer Servicing Unit whilst working for the respondent, National Australia Bank (‘NAB’).

  2. In this matter there were a large number of medical reports submitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) and oral evidence was given at the hearing by Dr Christopher Cocks and Mr Pete Potgieter.

  3. A comprehensive summary of the history of the matter and the relevant medical evidence was provided by the respondent, which I have considered and in summary include below. I note this summary is factual and in accordance with the evidence presented at the hearing, in particular the multiple medical reports, although there was dispute between the parties as to the conclusions to be drawn from the evidence. The below summary is broadly in line with what was submitted to the Tribunal by the respondent and was not in dispute at the hearing.

  4. The applicant is 28 years of age. He started working with NAB on 27 February 2017 as a Contact Centre Service Advisor within the Direct Consumer Servicing Unit.

  5. When the applicant resigned from his employment with NAB on 5 February 2020 he had not presented to work since around August 2018.

  6. The applicant submitted a workers compensation claim dated 9 October 2018 for “anxiety disorder, panic attacks, agoraphobia” which he said he first noticed on 5 June 2018. He sought medical treatment for this on the same day.

  7. The respondent’s determination decision of 7 December 2018 found that the applicant’s employment was not a significant contributing factor to either the onset or aggravation of the claimed mental illness. The applicant provided…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plummer and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 3759
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a claim for compensation by an applicant against National Australia Bank Limited. The applicant sought compensation for a psychological injury, specifically an anxiety disorder, panic attacks, and agoraphobia, which he alleged were significantly contributed to by his employment. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant suffered an ailment or an aggravation of an ailment, and if so, whether his employment with the respondent contributed to that ailment or aggravation to a significant degree.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on establishing the nature of the applicant's condition and the date it was sustained, as well as the causal link between his employment and the condition. While the applicant asserted his employment was the major contributor to his mental health issues, the Tribunal noted evidence of significant non-work related stressors, including a breakdown of his relationship and marijuana dependency, which were identified as perpetuating his condition. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered the applicant's pre-existing back pain, which had a history dating back to his teenage years and was exacerbated by his sedentary role at NAB, and the fact that his mental health issues were first diagnosed in the context of this back pain.

The Tribunal found that while the applicant's employment involved dealing with aggressive customer calls and technical issues, contributing to him feeling like a "punching bag," these factors were not the sole or significant cause of his psychological condition. The Tribunal acknowledged the applicant's pre-existing predisposition to psychological issues and the substantial impact of non-work related stressors. Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed a previous decision, indicating that the applicant's employment did not contribute to his ailment to a significant degree as required by the relevant legislation.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant commenced employment with the respondent, National Australia Bank Limited (NAB), on 27 February 2017 as a Contact Centre Service Advisor. His role involved dealing with customer complaints and enquiries, including issues related to refunds of money held in customer accounts for cruises. The applicant described his job as involving high levels of stress, particularly due to aggressive customer interactions and technical issues at NAB that led to lengthy delays in refunds. Despite these challenges, the applicant received positive feedback and a customer service award in June 2018. Throughout his employment, the applicant had an open relationship with his team leader, Ms Jessica Thorley, and regularly discussed his mental health concerns with her.

Prior to his employment at NAB, the applicant had suffered a back injury while working as a marine mechanic, although it did not affect his work at the time. However, when he transitioned to a more sedentary role at NAB, he experienced severe lumbar back pain, which he attributed to his obesity and the nature of his work. The applicant sought assistance for his back pain in September 2017 and began to experience mental health issues around the same time. The applicant claimed that his anxiety disorder, panic attacks, and agoraphobia first manifested on 5 June 2018 and were primarily due to the abusive telephone calls he received from customers in his role at NAB. However, the respondent and several medical professionals diagnosed the applicant with major depressive disorder (MDD) and depression instead.

The applicant’s mental health condition was further complicated by non-work-related stressors, including the breakdown of his relationship with his fiancée and the subsequent development of a marijuana dependency. These factors contributed to the exacerbation of his psychological condition. The applicant sought to have his employment at NAB recognised as a significant contributing factor to his mental health issues, thereby entitling him to compensation under the relevant workers' compensation legislation.

This case involves a claim for workers' compensation for psychological injury by Mr. Plummer against the National Australia Bank Limited. The matter came before the Workers Compensation Tribunal of Queensland, which reviewed a decision made by Dr. Cocks. The Tribunal's task was to determine whether Mr. Plummer suffered from an ailment, or an aggravation of an ailment, and whether this was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with the respondent, thus entitling him to compensation. The Tribunal's decision upheld the findings of Dr. Cocks, affirming that while Mr. Plummer's employment at NAB contributed to his psychological condition, there were significant non-work related factors that also played a role.

The procedural history of the matter includes initial claims and assessments made by Mr. Plummer, who began working for NAB in February 2017 and reported symptoms of anxiety disorder, panic attacks, and agoraphobia in June 2018. Dr. Cocks diagnosed the condition, and the Workers Compensation Tribunal of Queensland was tasked with reviewing the claim. Dr. Cocks' report and subsequent findings were pivotal, as they highlighted the interplay between work-related stressors and pre-existing non-work related factors in the development and exacerbation of Mr. Plummer’s condition. The Tribunal's review was comprehensive, considering the medical evidence, the timeline of events, and the nature of Mr. Plummer's employment at NAB. This led to the Tribunal affirming the decision that while Mr. Plummer's employment did contribute to his condition, the non-work related stressors were also significant contributors.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 7(4) of the SRC Act states that an employee shall be taken to have sustained an injury, being an ailment or aggravation of an ailment, on the day when the employee first sought medical treatment for the ailment or aggravation of the ailment, or on the day when the ailment or aggravation first resulted in incapacity for work or impairment of the employee, whichever happens first.THE EVIDENCEThe applicant’s evidence At the hearing, the applicant started by emphasising that prior to working for the respondent, NAB, he was “a functional person” and was obviously considered capable when he was offered employment. The applicant said that although he understood that there were other contributing factors to his mental health condition, the major contributor was his employment at NAB. Under cross-examination, the applicant confirmed that he had been employed by NAB as a Contact Centre Service Advisor from 27 February 2017 until he resigned voluntarily on 5 February 2020. During this time, he worked on a rotating roster dealing with customer complaints and enquiries. The applicant said he regularly dealt with calls in relation to money held in accounts for customers who had been on cruises, where the cruise would hold money from a customer’s account to pay for goods and services used on the cruise and where the balance would subsequently be released following authorisation. Sometimes there were lengthy delays in the refund of the money and the applicant expressed that clients could be extremely angry with NAB when they called. He said that other technical issues at NAB also meant that he received increasingly aggressive client calls and he felt like he was a “punching bag” for NAB’s customers. The applicant confirmed that he had undergone a twelve-week training period prior to commencing full-time work with NAB. He said he received positive feedback for his work at NAB and had received a customer service award in June 2018 for his achievements. Ms Jessica Thorley was the applicant’s team leader and direct report, and she was described as supportive and to have an open communication style. The applicant regularly and openly spoke to her about various issues arising in his daily life. The applicant said that he had never had any previous concerns about discussing his back injury with Ms Thorley, nor had there been any problems with him having time off work to deal with various health issues. He had also spoken to Ms Thorley about career progressions within NAB and in particular he had asked Ms Thorley about other roles which did not involve direct dealings with customers. The applicant confirmed that on 14 June 2018 Ms Thorley had nominated him for a floor walking role, but that he did not want this role as it involved “escalation” calls and he would find this triggering. He said that he did not tell Ms Thorley at the time that he did not want the role or the reasons for not wanting the role, but he had told her that he wanted a non-customer facing role.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Cocks said that the extensive non-work stressors would have resulted in the exacerbation of the applicant’s psychological condition that were present in 2017 and 2018. He said as follows:[The applicant’s] condition continues to be exacerbated by ongoing non-work related stressors. Specifically, the breakdown of his relationship with his fiancée and the subsequent development of marijuana dependency have perpetuated his condition. Therefore, in my opinion, there are significant pre-existing and non-work related factors that are contributing to the onset of his condition and its perpetuation.THE JUDGMENT The first issue to be determined by the Tribunal is whether the applicant suffered an ailment, or aggravation of an ailment, within the terms of section 5B of the SRC Act and, if so, the date at which the applicant sustained this. The second issue for determination is then whether this was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the applicant’s employment with the respondent so as to entitle the applicant to compensation under section 14 of the SRC Act. I have previously set out in detail a chronology of the applicant’s history, including his medical history, to provide context for understanding the development and progress of the applicant’s medical condition(s).What was the psychological condition and at what date was this sustained? The applicant claims that he developed “anxiety disorder, panic attacks, agoraphobia” which he said he first noticed on 5 June 2018 and attributed to abusive telephone calls with customers he liaised with in his role within the Direct Consumer Servicing Unit. The respondent accepted that the applicant has a psychological condition, however, believes this to be MDD, as diagnosed by Dr Ingram and Dr Cocks. Ms Abelson, former treating psychologist, also suggested that the applicant had depression. MDD was also among the diagnoses of Northside Cremorne Clinic. In this case the injury claimed is a mental illness, which was first diagnosed in or about November 2017. The diagnosis of depression and anxiety first came about in the context of the applicant suffering chronic back pain. I find the circumstances which led to his back pain at NAB together with his mental health issues are as follows. Prior to this period of employment with NAB, the applicant had worked for a marine engineering company. He had suffered a back injury whilst working as a marine mechanic but said that it did not affect his work at the time. He left his previous employer to work at NAB as he wanted to change his career direction. The applicant commenced work with NAB on 2 February 2017 as a Contact Centre Service Provider. In September 2017, the applicant sought assistance for severe lumbar back pain. At the time he was struggling with obesity and he had experienced a dramatic weight gain when he moved from his former job to a more sedentary occupation at NAB. The applicant had struggled with severe back pain for a long time since teenage years, which he told Dr Quittner was in part due to playing rugby union football.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal began by considering whether the applicant suffered an ailment, or an aggravation of an ailment, within the terms of section 5B of the SRC Act and, if so, the date at which the applicant sustained this. The applicant claimed he developed anxiety disorder, panic attacks, and agoraphobia, which he first noticed on 5 June 2018. The Tribunal found that the applicant's psychological condition was first diagnosed in or about November 2017, in the context of the applicant suffering chronic back pain. The Tribunal noted that prior to working for the respondent, the applicant had worked for a marine engineering company and suffered a back injury as a marine mechanic. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant sustained the psychological condition on the date when he first sought medical treatment for the condition or when the condition first resulted in incapacity for work or impairment of the employee, which in this case was November 2017.

The second issue for determination was whether the ailment, or aggravation of the ailment, was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the applicant’s employment with the respondent so as to entitle the applicant to compensation under section 14 of the SRC Act. The applicant claimed that the major contributor to his mental health condition was his employment at NAB. The Tribunal found that the circumstances which led to the applicant's back pain at NAB together with his mental health issues were relevant in determining whether the applicant's employment contributed to his psychological condition. The Tribunal noted that the applicant regularly dealt with calls in relation to money held in accounts for customers who had been on cruises, where the cruise would hold money from a customer’s account to pay for goods and services used on the cruise and where the balance would subsequently be released following authorisation. The applicant said that sometimes there were lengthy delays in the refund of the money and the applicant expressed that clients could be extremely angry with NAB when they called. The Tribunal found that the applicant's employment at NAB contributed to his psychological condition.

The third issue to be determined was to what extent, if at all, non-work related stressors and the applicant’s predisposition contributed to the development and exacerbation of the applicant’s psychological condition. Dr Cocks, a psychologist, gave evidence that the extensive non-work stressors would have resulted in the exacerbation of the applicant’s psychological condition that were present in 2017 and 2018. Specifically, the breakdown of his relationship with his fiancée and the subsequent development of marijuana dependency have perpetuated his condition. The Tribunal found that there were significant pre-existing and non-work related factors that were contributing to the onset of the applicant's condition and its perpetuation.

The fourth and final issue for determination was whether the psychological condition claimed by the applicant falls within the definition of a compensable injury under the SRC Act. The Tribunal noted that the applicant claimed to have developed anxiety disorder, panic attacks, and agoraphobia. However, the Tribunal found that the applicant's psychological condition was depression and anxiety, as diagnosed by Dr Ingram, Dr Cocks, and Northside Cremorne Clinic. The Tribunal found that the applicant's psychological condition did not fall within the definition of a compensable injury under the SRC Act as it was not an injury arising out of or in the course of employment.

In conclusion, the Tribunal found that the applicant suffered an ailment, or an aggravation of an ailment, within the terms of section 5B of the SRC Act and that this was sustained on 2 November 2017. The Tribunal also found that the applicant's employment at NAB contributed to his psychological condition. However, the Tribunal found that there were significant pre-existing and non-work related factors that were contributing to the onset of the applicant's condition and its perpetuation. Finally, the Tribunal found that the applicant's psychological condition did not fall within the definition of a compensable injury under the SRC Act as it was not an injury arising out of or in the course of employment. The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal must consider all factors, including non-work related stressors and the applicant’s predisposition, when determining whether an applicant’s psychological condition is compensable under the SRC Act.