PLQY and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

PLQY and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2025 (30 October 2017)

Division:General Division

File Number:           2017/4780

Re:PLQY

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President S A Forgie

Date:30 October 2017  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal decides to:

affirm the decision of the  respondent dated 7 August 2017 to refuse to grant the applicant a Bridging E (Class WE) visa.

.......[sgd].................................................................

Deputy President S A Forgie

Catchwords

MIGRATION – refusal of visa on character grounds – best interests of children – expectations of the Australian community - decision affirmed

Legislation

Family Law Act 1975 ss 61B, 62G, 68R, 97, 121

Migration Act 1958 ss 5, 29, 30, 31, 36, 45, 46, 47, 84, 86, 499, 501, 503

Family Law Rules Part 15.5

Migration Regulations 1994 r 1.03; and cll 020, 600, 601, 801, 820, 976, 4001, 5001

Direction No.65

Cases

Alexandra Private GeriatricHospital Pty Ltd v Blewett(1984) 2 FCR 368; 56 ALR 265

Harman v HomeDepartment State Secretary [1983] 1 AC 280; [1982] 1 All ER 532; [1982] 2 WLR 338

Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36; (2008) 235 CLR 125; 248 ALR 609; 82 ALJR 1259

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; (1986) 162 CLR 24; 66 ALR 299

Secondary Materials

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S A Forgie

  1. On 7 August 2017, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) refused PLQY’s[1] application for a Bridging E (Class WE) visa (sc 050 BE visa) under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Migration Act). The delegate did so on the basis that PLQY had not passed the character test under s 501(6). There was no dispute between the parties that PLQY had not passed it because he had a substantial criminal record within the meaning of ss 501(1)(a) and 501(7)(c) and (d) of the Migration Act in that he had been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more and has been sentenced to two or more terms of imprisonment where the total of those terms is 12 months or more. The Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) advised PLQY of the refusal in a letter dated 8 August 2017.

[1] Name suppressed to accommodate s 121 of the Family Law Act 1975.

  1. PLQY has applied for review of the Minister’s decision.  Since he first visited Australia in 1995, he has met and married the mother of his three young daughters.  He and she have lived both in his country of birth, the United States of America (USA), and Australia at various times.  In the main, PLQY has entered and remained in Australia on visitors’ visas, which require him to leave the country within 90 days.  He applied for a Subclass 820/801 partner visa (partner visa) and associated Bridging Visa on 24 May 2011 but he withdrew it on 22 October 2013 after his marriage foundered.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PLQY and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Mig... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2025
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by PLQY against a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse him a visa on character grounds. The dispute centred on whether PLQY met the character requirements for a visa, particularly in light of his criminal history and the potential impact on the best interests of children and the expectations of the Australian community. The case was heard by Deputy President S A Forgie of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether PLQY satisfied the character test under section 501 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and whether the Minister's decision to refuse the visa was otherwise correct. This involved assessing PLQY's past criminal convictions, his failure to disclose these convictions upon arrival in Australia, and the assessment of his personality and potential future conduct, including considerations of his substance use disorder and interpersonal relationship difficulties. The Tribunal also had to consider the weight to be given to expert psychiatric evidence and the implications of the "Harman undertaking" in relation to disclosed documents.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the serious nature of PLQY's criminal history, which spanned several years in the United States and included offences related to drug use and breaches of intervention orders. Despite acknowledging the devastating personal circumstances that contributed to his substance abuse, the Tribunal found that PLQY's pattern of offending and his failure to disclose convictions demonstrated a lack of good character. The Tribunal also considered the potential impact on children and the expectations of the Australian community, as outlined in Direction No. 65. The Tribunal found that PLQY's personality traits, as described by a psychiatrist, indicated a propensity for conflict with authorities and unreliability, further supporting the refusal of the visa.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Minister to refuse the visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Direction No. 65 expands upon each of these criteria and I return to it later in these reasons.BACKGROUND In this section of my reasons, I will set out the facts that are either not in dispute or that I have found after hearing PLQY’s oral evidence and that of Mr Woodward as well as having regard to the written evidence. I will set out the facts by reference to the years in which they occurred. PLQY’s parents separated and divorced when he was quite young. His mother moved out of the family home but she was later found raped and murdered. PLQY attributes his turning to illicit drugs to the devastation he experienced following his mother’s death in those circumstances. His first exposure to drugs in the form of marijuana and cocaine occurred when he was 12 years of age. He became caught up in the wrong crowd in California and was soon addicted to crack cocaine. At the same time, he continued with his schooling and graduated from High School and then from University. In the years between 1993 and 2005 and before he travelled to Australia on the first occasion, PLQY was convicted of the following offences in California in the USA: PLQY first arrived in Australia on 15 September 2005 as the holder of an Electronic Travel Authority (Visitor) (Subclass 976) (sc 976 ETA visa). Among the criteria that had to be satisfied at the time was the applicant’s stated intention to visit Australia temporarily for tourism purposes.[24] He was also required to satisfy public interest criteria 4002, 4003, 4004, 4005, 4013 and 4014 but was not required to satisfy public interest criterion 4001.[25] That means that he is not subject to scrutiny by reference to the character test under s 501[26] although he is subject to scrutiny in that he must not have been assessed by the Australian Security and Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) to be a risk to security within the meaning of s 4 of the Australian Security and Intelligence Organisation Act 1979[27]or has not been determined by the Minister for Foreign Affairs to be a person whose presence would, for example, be contrary to Australia’s foreign policy interests.[24] Migration Regulations 1994 (Migration Regulations); r 976.222[25] Migration Regulations; r 976.223[26] See public interest criterion 4001 at [10] above[27] Migration Regulations; Schedule 4, public interest criterion 4002 PLQY acknowledged that he had not revealed his previous criminal convictions either when applying for the sc 976 visa or in completing the incoming passenger card when he arrived in Australia. His reason for failing to do so was that his father, with whom he was travelling, had told him it was not necessary to disclose them as he would not be returning to Australia. PLQY realises that it was bad advice but, at the time, he had wanted to leave the stress of prisons and institutions behind him and thought that a trip to Australia was a great opportunity to do so. He did not understand the seriousness of his failure to disclose his convictions at the time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In view of those two findings, I have decided that I am not prevented from having regard to Dr Jones’ report by a “Harman undertaking”. The Harman undertaking is a reference to the principles set out by the House of Lords in Harman v HomeDepartment State Secretary[70] (Harman) by the House of Lords. They are principles that were considered by the High Court in Hearne v Street.[71] Justices Hayne, Heydon and Crennan said:“Where one party to litigation is compelled, either by reason of a rule of court, or by reason of a specific order of the court, or otherwise ..., to disclose documents or information, the party obtaining the disclosure cannot, without leave of the court, use it for any purpose other than that for which it was given unless it is received into evidence. The types of material disclosed to which this principle applies include documents inspected after discovery ..., answers to interrogatories ..., documents produced on subpoena ..., documents produced for the purposes of taxation of costs ..., documents produced pursuant to a direction from an arbitrator ..., documents seized pursuant to an Anton Piller order ..., witness statements served pursuant to a judicial direction ... and affidavits ...”[72] (emphasis added)[70] [1983] 1 AC 280; [1982] 1 All ER 532; [1982] 2 WLR 338; Lords Diplock, Keith of Kinkel, and Roskill; Lords Simon of Glaisdale and Scarman dissenting on whether the undertaking came to an end when discovered documents are admitted in evidence.[71] [2008] HCA 36; (2008) 235 CLR 125; 248 ALR 609; 82 ALJR 1259; Gleeson CJ, Kirby, Hayne, Heydon and Crennan JJ[72] [2008] HCA 36; (2008) 235 CLR 125; (2008) 248 ALR 609; 82 ALJR 1259 at [96]; 154; 632; 1276 (footnotes omitted) Dr Jones’ report refers to a psychiatric assessment regarding both PLQY and his wife by Associate Professor Peter Doherty. With regard to PLQY, Dr Jones quoted from Associate Professor Doherty’s assessment of PLQY, who said that, apart from substance use disorder that was then in remission:“… In my opinion there are significant problems in the father’s personality. The personality problems will be demonstrated in the father’s inability to maintain interpersonal relationships, the difficulties he will have in meeting societal expectations and norms and in the conflicts he will have with authorities. In my opinion, he will not be reliable or consist [sic], and he may be unstable in mood and prone to blame others for his problems. In my opinion, he has largely failed, up till now, in his occupational endeavours and in his interpersonal relationships.”[73][73] Exhibit B at [15] Associate Professor Doherty’s assessment is consistent with the pattern of offending that I have identified. Putting aside regularity of offending as a ground for finding that his conduct is of serious concern, what of the conduct itself? His wife did not give oral evidence but there is written material in which she expresses concerns about her physical safety and refers to previous incidents as the basis for her concerns. PLQY denies that he has given her reason to have concerns. This is not the appropriate circumstances in which to attempt to resolve whose view of events, if either, is correct but, whoever is correct, PLQY has acknowledged that he has behaved contrary to the IVOs by pleading guilty to persistently breaching IVOs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subject to certain qualifications related to the suspension of the processing of visa applications under s 84 and visa limits under s 86, the Minister is to grant a valid application for a visa if satisfied that the health and other criteria specified for the visa have been satisfied, charges have been paid and the grant of the visa is not prevented by Commonwealth laws or the provisions of the Migration Act including s 501.[10] Restrictions on entitlement to enter Australia or to be in Australia when decisions made under, among others, section 501 of the Migration Act A person in relation to whom a decision has been made under various provisions, including s 501 of the Migration Act, is not entitled to enter Australia or to be in Australia at any time during the period determined under the regulations. That is the effect of s 503(1)(b). The way in which that period is determined is by reference to the criteria that are prescribed under the Migration Regulations 1994 (Migration Regulations) as provided for by s 31(3) of the Migration Act. One example of the way in which this comes about is by the prescription of certain public interest criteria. They are set out in Schedule 4 to the Migration Regulations. If, for example, the holder of a visa overstays the period during which he or she is permitted to remain in Australia, the Minister may cancel that visa under s 116(1)(b) on the basis that its holder has not complied with a condition of the visa. If that person applies for a further visa, the criteria prescribed for the particular visa may specify public interest criterion 4013. If it does, the visa applicant will not be able to make the application until three years have passed since the cancellation or there are certain compelling or compassionate circumstances.[11] [11] Migration Regulations; Schedule 4; public interest criterion 4013(1) and (1A)(a) If the criteria prescribed for a visa or class of visas include criterion 4001, which is one of the public interest criteria, a person is effectively excluded from Australia until:“Either:(a)the person satisfies the Minister that the person passes the character test; or(b)the Minister is satisfied, after appropriate inquiries, that there is nothing to indicate that the person would fail to satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test; or(c)the Minister has decided not to refuse to grant a visa to the person despite reasonably suspecting that the person does not pass the character test; or(d)the Minister has decided not to refuse to grant a visa to the person despite not being satisfied that the person passes the character test.” If the Special Return Criteria set out in Schedule 5 to the Migration Regulations[12] were prescribed, their effect may be to exclude a person from Australia. Criterion 5001 is one of those Special Return Criteria. If criterion 5001 is prescribed by the Migration Regulations in relation to a visa or visas of a specified class in accordance with s 31(3) of the Migration Act, then the applicant must not, among other things, be:[12] Migration Regulations; r 1.03“… (a) …(b)a person whose visa has been cancelled under section 501 of the Act, as in force before 1 June 1999, wholly or partly because the Minister, having regard to the person’s past criminal conduct, was satisfied that the person is not of good character; or(c)a person whose visa has been cancelled under section 501, 501A or 501B of the Act, if:(i)the cancellation has not been revoked under subsection 501C(4) or 501CA(4) of the Act; or(ii)after cancelling the visa, the Minister has not, acting personally, granted a permanent visa to the person; or(d)…”