PLQF and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

PLQF and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 2982 (18 September 2023)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2023/4536

Re:PLQF

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

Date:18 September 2023

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision is set aside and in substitution it is decided that there is another reason why the mandatory cancellation decision should be revoked.

.................................[sgd].......................................

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of visa under s 501CA(4) because applicant did not pass the character test – whether there is another reason why the cancellation decision should be revoked – Ministerial direction no.99 – protection of the Australian community – family violence – strength, nature, duration of ties to Australia – best interests of minor children in Australia – expectations of the Australian community – legal consequences of the decision – extent of impediments if removed – impact on victims – reviewable decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

CASES

FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185

Jacobs and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2020] AATA 1524

MNLR v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 35

Pearson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 203

Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594

WKMZ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 55

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction No. 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA’

World Affairs, Winter 2020 (October-December) Vol. 24 No. 4

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

18 September 2023

Introduction

  1. PLQF, the Applicant, was born in Bhutan in January 1984. On 3 July 2012, aged 28, he arrived in Australia from a refugee camp in Nepal holding a Refugee (Class XB) (Subclass 200) visa (the visa) which was mandatorily cancelled on 8 September 2022 because of the sentence of imprisonment imposed for his criminal offending committed on 4 December 2020 (the 2020 offences). He applied unsuccessfully to have the cancellation decision revoked. He seeks to have that non-revocation decision made on 26 June 2023 set aside by the Tribunal.

    The issue to decided

  2. Both parties accept that the Applicant does not pass the character test (defined in section 501(6) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act)) because he was sentenced to an aggregate term of imprisonment of three years and nine months. Therefore, the issue to be decided is whether there is another reason why the cancellation decision should be revoked under section 501CA(4) of the Act, having regard to the considerations prescribed by ‘Direction No. 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA’ (Direction 99).

    Direction 99

  3. Paragraph 5.2 of Direction 99 sets out six principles (

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PLQF and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicult... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2982
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an application for revocation of a mandatory visa cancellation made under section 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant, who had failed to pass the character test, sought to have the cancellation decision revoked. The decision-maker was required to consider whether there was "another reason" why the cancellation decision should be revoked, having regard to Ministerial Direction No. 99, which outlines the factors to be considered in such cases.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant had established "another reason" to revoke the mandatory visa cancellation, and if so, what weight should be given to various considerations including the protection of the Australian community, the best interests of the applicant's minor children in Australia, the strength, nature, and duration of the applicant's ties to Australia, the expectations of the Australian community, the legal consequences of the decision, the extent of impediments if removed, and the impact on victims. The Tribunal was required to balance these factors to determine if revocation was warranted.

The Tribunal's reasoning involved a detailed assessment of the applicant's background, including his traumatic experiences as a refugee, his struggles with mental health and alcohol use disorder, and his criminal offending, which included family violence. The Tribunal considered the applicant's significant ties to Australia through his marriage and children, and the adverse impact his removal would have on his Australian citizen children, who relied on him for emotional and practical support. The Tribunal also acknowledged the applicant's efforts at rehabilitation, including participation in counselling and mental health treatment. However, it also weighed the seriousness of his past conduct and the risk of reoffending against these mitigating factors.

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that while there were significant considerations weighing in favour of revocation, particularly concerning the best interests of the applicant's children and his ties to Australia, these were tempered by the applicant's offending in their presence and the risk of reoffending. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant had not established sufficient grounds for the mandatory cancellation decision to be revoked.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I will consider in turn each of the considerations that is relevant in this case after setting out a summary of the evidence that provides the context for his offending. The impact on business is not relevant in this case.Background The Applicant was forced to flee from Bhutan to Nepal with his parents and his older sister when he was six years old as part of a mass exodus of Lhotshampa, Bhutanese of Nepali origin. At that time, the Bhutanese government implemented a ‘one nation, one people’ policy by denying/preventing the people of Nepali descent from exercising their cultural and linguistic rights. The government used armed forces to expel the Lhotshampa from the country. Life within the refugee camp was traumatic and the Applicant was regularly exposed to violence, disease and malnourishment. He claims that he has been stateless since then. In 2006, the Applicant married his wife (AB) who was also a stateless refugee living in the refugee camp. She gave birth to their son in January 2009. The Applicant was a labourer in the camp. The Applicant claimed that he first consumed alcohol when he was 16, living in the refugee camp. He developed a pattern of drinking alcohol daily, which continued when he relocated to Australia when he was drinking one to two bottles of wine daily. He had been consuming alcohol on the day he committed the 2020 offences. After arriving in Australia, the Applicant and his family resided in a regional area. He found the adjustment difficult, having left his parents and four siblings in the refugee camp but found work. His family has moved to the United States except for his sister and her son who he sponsored to come to Australia in 2017. His daughter was born in 2014. From 2015 to 2016 he was cutting sheet metal at an engineering company (the company) which employed him again full-time while he was in the community in January and February 2023 and has offered to re-employ him if he returns to the community. From 2017 to 4 December 2020, he was working sporadically. The Applicant is the primary source of evidence about his mental health and treatment. He claims that he was first prescribed medication for his mental health symptoms in 2017. He has been treated at a city hospital and by two regional health services. There is one letter dated 19 June 2020 from a drug and alcohol counsellor in the material summonsed from the local court where the Applicant appeared on 30 June 2020. It states that the Applicant self-referred to the service and had voluntarily participated in alcohol and other drug counselling on six occasions from 8 May 2020 to 19 June 2020. The Applicant ceased taking his medication in or around June 2020 when he felt that his symptoms were subsiding. He described his paranoid episodes as ‘coming and going’, and re-emerging in the week before he committed the 2020 offences. The Applicant has been diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), schizophrenia and alcohol use disorder by Dr Richard Furst, forensic psychiatrist, who assessed the Applicant in 2021, 2022 and 2023, and wrote reports. Dr Furst also gave oral evidence at the hearing.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This consideration weighs in favour of revocation but the weight to be attributed is tempered by the Applicant’s low to moderate risk of reoffending which would impact adversely on AB and the children.Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision The Applicant’s son is 14 and his daughter is eight years old. They both wrote letters in support of their father and wore T-shirts at the hearing with the message: ‘I love my father’. AB has stopped the children’s sport because she is unable to drive them long distances because she does not have the time. Her daughter stopped going to dancing and swimming when the Applicant went to prison because it was during the week and AB did not have the time to take her. She wants to go swimming. AB’s parents used to pick up the children from school. They have been overseas for an extended period and will be moving further away but within the same city. Her parents and siblings do not help all the time. She is unable to assist the children with their homework as much as the Applicant did because he is more educated than she is. AB said that their son keeps saying that he is looking after his sister and he will have his time when the Applicant comes back. I understand this remark to refer to him having to mind her when AB is working. He is not open with his mother. AB is particularly worried about their daughter who sees the Applicant in her dreams and gets pains/cramps in her stomach. A letter from her school substantiates the difficulties the daughter has as a consequence of her father being absent. She misses him deeply and worries about him. She often visits sick bay because of the cramps which are attributed to her worry about her father. She often needs to go home because of the cramps. Her ability to maintain friendships and progress academically have been adversely impacted. This impact seems to have occurred following the Applicant’s time in the community and return to immigration detention. This consideration weighs in favour of revocation but the weight to be attributed to it is tempered by the Applicant’s offending in their presence and by the risk of his moderate to low risk of reoffending which if realised would adversely affect each of the children and by the fact that they were present during the 4 December 2020 offending. Expectations of the Australian community The Applicant did not dispute that he has engaged in serious conduct in breach of the Australian community’s expectation that non-citizens obey Australian laws while in Australia and that the Australian community, as a norm, expects the Government to not allow him to remain in Australia.[3] [3] Paragraph 8.5(1) of Direction 99. It is not for a decision-maker to make an assessment of the community’s expectations.[4] The decision-maker determines the appropriate weight to be given to this consideration.[5][4] FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185 at [66]-[67] (Charlesworth J) and at [104] (Stewart J) and Direction 99, paragraph 8.5(4).[5] Jacobs and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2020] AATA 1524 at [72].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant was in police custody or on remand from 4 December 2020 until he was sentenced to imprisonment on 16 August 2022. He was released from prison on 3 December 2022 and taken into immigration detention. This case is Pearson affected[2]. Therefore, he was released into the community on 27 December 2022 and returned to immigration detention on 3 March 2023, where he remains. Primary considerations[2] Pearson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 203.Protection of the Australian community There are two considerations in relation to the protection of the Australian community:(a)The nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date; and(b)The risk to the Australian community, should the non-citizen commit further offences.The nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date The Applicant’s criminal offending began on 29 January 2017. The Applicant objected to police records of incidents being taken into evidence that did not result in an offence being recorded. The information is relevant because it demonstrates the Applicant’s consumption of alcohol and the consequential arguments that arose between him and his wife. I am unable to make findings as to exactly what happened where there is conflicting evidence from the Applicant and AB. On 26 October 2012, three months after the Applicant, AB and their son arrived in Australia, the police recorded a ‘domestic violence episode’. The Applicant had been drinking alcohol. The police had difficulty finding out what had happened because of language difficulties and conveyed AB and the son to her sister’s residence to ensure arguments ceased. On 6 June 2015 police observed the Applicant to be intoxicated at a licensed premise and told him to leave. The Applicant argued, defied a number of police directions, was arrested, refused to supply details requested, and was held in custody until the following morning. On 14 March 2017 he was sentenced to community corrections order (CCO) for 12 months without conviction for three offences committed on 29 January 2017: unlawful assault, intentionally damage property and possess dangerous article in public place. The Applicant assaulted AB with a meat cleaver and was found to be in possession of a tomahawk. He also damaged her motor vehicle. That was an incident of family violence. The conditions on the CCO were community work, ‘Treatment & Rehab’ alcohol and mental health, supervision and offending behaviour programs. He engaged with a mental health service after this incident which he told the Tribunal he did not really remember. On 14 May 2018, the police recorded the following account provided by AB. The Applicant was an alcoholic and had mental health issues and apparently skips or does not take his medication. When he does not drink, he is fine, but when he does, he becomes argumentative and threatening. They had had numerous arguments about his drinking. During those arguments he had threatened to stab her. On Saturday night 12 May 2018, the Applicant went out drinking at 12pm and returned home about 7pm intoxicated. AB refused to let him into the house. He became angry, started to bang on the door, yelling abuse at the victim wanting her to let him in. He broke some pot plants. AB left to go to her parents next door and gave him the house key. He followed her and banged on the door there for some time. AB expressed fears that when he drinks, he will kill her. An Apprehended Violence Order (AVO) had been applied for and the Applicant would be arrested and served when it was approved.