Playgro Pty Ltd v Playgo Art & Craft Manufactory Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Playgro Pty Ltd v Playgo Art & Craft Manufactory Limited [2016] FCA 280

File number: VID 234 of 2015
Judge: MOSHINSKY J
Date of judgment: 22 March 2016
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS – infringement – substantial identity and deceptive similarity – whether respondent’s device mark ‘PLAYGO’ substantially identical with or deceptively similar to applicant’s mark ‘PLAYGRO’

TRADE MARKS – infringement – where foreign company sold and delivered overseas toys bearing a device mark to Australian retailer, for sale to customers in Australia – where property in and risk in relation to goods passed overseas – whether foreign company used as a trade mark the device mark in Australia

TRADE MARKS – joint tortfeasorship – where foreign company sold and delivered overseas toys bearing a device mark to Australian retailer, for sale to customers in Australia – whether foreign company had common design with local retailer – whether foreign company is a joint tortfeasor in infringing sales by local retailer

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 21(1)(b)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 136

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), ss 6, 10, 17, 120(1)

Cases cited:

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Global Gaming Supplies Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 22

Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v FS Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641

Badische Anilin und Soda Fabrik v Basle Chemical Works, Bindschedler [1898] AC 200

Caterpillar Inc v John Deere Ltd (1999) 48 IPR 1

Champagne Heidsieck et Cie Monopole Societe Anonyme v Buxton [1930] 1 Ch 330

Coca-Cola Company v All-Fect Distributors Ltd (1999) 96 FCR 107

Cooper v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 156 FCR 380

E & J Gallo Winery v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 144

Estex Clothing Manufacturers Pty Limited v Ellis and Goldstein Limited (1967) 116 CLR 254

Fender Australia Pty Ltd v Bevk (1989) 25 FCR 161

Jumbunna Coal Mine NL v Victorian Coal Miners’ Association (1908) 6 CLR 309

Paul’s Retail Pty Ltd v Lonsdale Australia Ltd (2012) 294 ALR 72

Pioneer Kabushiki Kaisha v Registrar of Trade Marks (1977) 137 CLR 670

Queensland v Forst (2008) 168 FCR 532

Re the registered trade mark ‘Yanx’; ex parte Amalgamated Tobacco Corporation Limited (1951) 82 CLR 199

Registrar of Titles (WA) v Franzon (1975) 132 CLR 611

Registrar of Trade Marks v Woolworths Ltd (1999) 93 FCR 365

Shell Company of Australia Limited v Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Ltd (1961) 109 CLR 407

Southern Cross Refrigerating Company v Toowoomba Foundry Proprietary Limited (1953) 91 CLR 592

Thompson v Australian Capital Television Pty Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 574

Unilever plc v Chefaro Proprietaries Ltd [1994] FSR 135

Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Cooper (2005) 150 FCR 1

Ward Group Pty Ltd v Brodie & Stone plc (2005) 143 FCR 479

Williamson Pty Ltd v Barrowcliff [1915] VLR 450

Wingate Marketing Pty Ltd v Levi Strauss & Co (1994) 49 FCR 105

Date of hearing: 8 and 9 December 2015
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Playgro Pty Ltd v Playgo Art & Craft Manufactory Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 280
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Playgro Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, brought an action against Playgo Art & Craft Manufactory Ltd, Playgo Craft and Playgo Enterprises, the defendants, alleging infringement of trade marks registered in Australia. The central dispute was whether the respondents' use of the device mark 'PLAYGO' was substantially identical with or deceptively similar to the plaintiff's marks 'PLAYGRO', and whether the respondents had used the mark in Australia, thereby infringing the plaintiff's rights. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The court had to decide three main legal issues. First, whether the respondents' device mark 'PLAYGO' was substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, the plaintiff's trade marks. Second, whether the respondents 'used' as a trade mark the device mark in Australia. Third, whether Playgo Enterprises had a 'common design' with Myer to supply 'PLAYGO' branded toys for sale in Australia, such that Playgo Enterprises was a joint tortfeasor in any infringing sales by Myer.

The court concluded that the respondents' device mark 'PLAYGO' was not substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, the plaintiff's marks 'PLAYGRO'. The court found that the marks were not similar in appearance, sound, connotation or commercial impression, and that consumers would not be confused by the marks. The court also found that the respondents did not 'use' the device mark as a trade mark in Australia because property in and risk in relation to the goods passed overseas. However, the court found that Playgo Enterprises did not have a 'common design' with Myer to supply 'PLAYGO' branded toys for sale in Australia, and therefore Playgo Enterprises was not a joint tortfeasor in any infringing sales by Myer. The court concluded that the respondents infringed the plaintiff's trade marks contrary to section 120(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).

The court ordered that the parties bring in minutes of orders within 7 days to give effect to the reasons. The entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 7 days, the parties bring in minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents relied on the following affidavits:(a)affidavit of Ms Ya Ling Connie Lin (a director and shareholder of several companies in the Playgo group) dated 9 October 2015;(b)affidavit of Ms Miu Sim Frances Kwan (the sales manager of Playgo Enterprises) dated 9 October 2015;(c)affidavit of Ms Kwan dated 7 December 2015;(d)affidavit of Ms Anne Makrigiorgos (a patent and trade mark attorney) dated 12 October 2015.C. FACTS The following facts are drawn from the affidavits. As noted above, there was no cross-examination of the deponents.Playgro’s trade marks Playgro is the registered owner of the following trade marks in Australia:(a)Number 740357, which consists of the word mark ‘PLAYGRO’. The trade mark is registered in relation to, among other things, games and playthings (in class 28).(b)Number 954929, which consists of the device mark set out in paragraph [1] above. The trade mark is registered in relation to, among other things, games and playthings including toys, plush toys, dolls and accessories for such goods; bouncers (in class 28).(c)Number 970023, which consists of the device mark set out in paragraph [1] above. The trade mark is registered in relation to, among other things, games and playthings including educational games and toys for babies and children; soft and stuffed toys; toys that attach to prams, strollers, cots and other articles; plastic toys; jigsaw puzzles; activity centres; play mats and floor gyms; bouncers and rockers; gymnastic and sporting articles (in class 28).(d)Number 1149144, which consists of a device mark similar to or the same as that set out in paragraph [1] above. The trade mark is registered in relation to, among other things, teething toys, rattling toys, musical toys, sound and music activated toys, bath toys, entertaining, mechanical and educational toys, musical mobiles and activity gyms (in class 28).(e)Number 1330416, which consists of a device mark similar to or the same as that set out in paragraph [1] above. The trade mark is registered in relation to certain goods or services in class 35. These do not appear to include toys. The evidence did not deal with trade mark number 1330413.Playgo group The Playgo group is a Hong Kong based group of associated companies under the common ownership and control of Ms Lin and Mr Lau Yuk Fai (referred to as ‘Jacky Lau’). The group has been involved in the design, manufacture, distribution and wholesale of games, playthings and toys for children in Hong Kong since the early 1980s. The name ‘Playgo’ was devised by Mr Jacky Lau in or around 1994 and, since then, most of the companies in the group have included the word ‘Playgo’ as part of their name. He devised the name ‘Playgo’ as a name which would be easy for Westerners to read and remember. He came up with the name by combining the words ‘play’ and ‘go’. He decided to combine these two words in the name because the group’s products are toys for children to ‘PLAY’ with, and he wanted the name to evoke the phrase, ‘Let’s GO and play!’. Since around May 1994, the Playgo group has continuously designed, manufactured, distributed and wholesaled the group’s products under or by reference to the name ‘Playgo’.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 18 March 2015, Playgo Craft withdrew its application for a trade mark in Australia.Evidence relating to confusion or potential confusion Playgro relied on the page from the Big W catalogue, described in paragraph [78] above, as an instance of confusion between the trade marks. Playgro’s evidence included an extract from the website (accessed on 6 August 2015) offering for sale a second hand ‘Playgo play mat’ which is in fact a ‘PLAYGRO’ branded product (annexure “RLS-14” to Ms Sanders’ first affidavit). Playgo Craft and Playgo Enterprises have no relationship with the company that operates the website, or with the people seeking to sell items on the website, and do not list their products for sale on the website. Members of the public can seek to sell items on the website. The respondents’ evidence included the fact that, on 11 September 2015, two principals at the firm of patent and trade mark attorneys acting for the respondents attended a Myer store. They located the toy department within the store and spent 10 to 15 minutes walking around the department. The toy department was divided into sections catering for children of different ages. Toys for babies and toddlers were in one area, toys for young children were in another area, and toys for older children were in another area. Items sold under a common brand tended to be displayed together. Playgro’s branded toys were in the baby and toddler section and the respondents’ toys were in the area for young children. Accordingly, the shelves on which Playgro’s toys were displayed were physically separate from shelves displaying the respondents’ toys. They were separated by about 10 to 15 metres. All of the respondents’ toys were located in two ‘bookcases’. The bookcases did not bear the ‘PLAYGO’ brand. Other bookcases displaying branded toys bore the brand in the panel at the top. The respondents’ toys displayed in this section were:(a)My Tea Party;(b)Table Set For Four;(c)Deluxe Kettle;(d)My Mixer;(e)My Cleaning Trolley;(f)Gourmet Kitchen Appliances;(g)Chef's Collection Metal Cookware;(h)High Tea Cake Set for Two. Of these, the only items bearing the Playgo Device Mark were ‘My Tea Party’, ‘Deluxe Kettle’ and ‘My Mixer’. The respondents’ evidence also included a search of the Australian Trade Marks Office database, ATMOSS using the word ‘PLAY’ as a part word in class 28. The search disclosed 275 registered trade marks in Australia using the word ‘PLAY’ as a part word in class 28 as at October 2015. These included: PLAYSKOOL, PLAYBOY, PLAYMOBIL, PLAY-DOH, PLAYMATES, PLAYSTATION, PLAYLIFE, PLAYTIME, and PLAY ARTS.D. SUBSTANTIAL IDENTITY AND DECEPTIVE SIMILARITY As noted in paragraph [7] above, there are three main questions to be determined:(a)Is the Playgo Device Mark substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, Playgro’s trade marks?(b)Did the respondents ‘use’ as a trade mark the Playgo Device Mark in Australia?(c)Did Playgo Enterprises have a ‘common design’ with Myer to supply ‘PLAYGO’ branded toys for sale in Australia, such that Playgo Enterprises is a joint tortfeasor in infringing sales of those goods by Myer?

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, I conclude that Playgo Enterprises did not have a ‘common design’ with Myer to supply ‘PLAYGO’ branded toys for sale in Australia, and therefore Playgo Enterprises was not a joint tortfeasor in infringing sales by Myer.G. CONCLUSION For the reasons set out in Sections D and E, I conclude that the respondents infringed the Playgro trade marks described in sub-paragraphs (a) to (c) of paragraph [27] above contrary to s 120(1) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established