Plastec Australia Pty Ltd –v- Rubber Auto Supplies Pty Ltd & Maureen Irwin (third party)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Plastec Australia Pty Ltd –v- Rubber Auto Supplies Pty Ltd & Maureen Irwin (third party) [2016] QMC 3

PARTIES:

PLASTEC AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(Plaintiff)

v

RUBBER AUTO SUPPLIES PTY LTD
(Defendant)
&
MAUREEN IRWIN
(Third Party)

FILE NO/S:

BM12611/2012

DIVISION:

Civil Applications

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

2 March 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19 February 2016

A/MAGISTRATE:

R Carmody

ORDER:

1

(a)    The defendant is required to provide written notice to the plaintiff within 7 days of these Orders as to whether it intends to engage an; appropriate certified laboratory to undertake testing on the samples of the defective product (as that term is defined in the Statement of Claim) (“defective product”).

(b)   In the event that the defendant provides written notice pursuant to Order 1 (a) above, the plaintiff is to deliver the samples of the defective product to the appropriately certified laboratory nominated by the defendant in its notice for further testing, within 14 days of the defendant providing the following to the plaintiff:

(i)         The name of the proposed testing facility, including a summary of the facility’s specific testing expertise in relation to such products as the defective products;

(ii)        The proposed tests to be undertaken by the facility on the defective products;

(iii)       The name(s) and qualification(s) of the persons at the facility who will conduct the tests;      

(iv)       The proposed timeframe for the testing of the defective products and for reporting as to the results of the testing;

(v)        An undertaking that that the defendant’s instruction to nominated appropriate certified laboratory will contain a direction to provide its report to both the plaintiff and the defendant simultaneously;

(vi)       Written undertaking(s) from the testing facility and the persons who will conduct the tests that no other party will be provided with access to the samples, other than the persons at the facility who will conduct the tests.

(c)    That the costs of the testing be borne by the defendant;

(d)   That the defendant provide a copy of its letter of instructions to the certified laboratory and all correspondence relating to the preparation of the report pursuant to 1(v) above contemporaneous with the sending of the original correspondence to the tester.

(e)   That the defendant will instruct the laboratory that, within 6 weeks of the date of delivery of the products to the NATA certified laboratory identified in the defendant’s notice, the NATA certified laboratory must provide both a hard copy and soft copy of its report to the plaintiff and defendant.

2

(a)    Further and/or in the alternative to Order 1 above, subject to 2(b) below, the plaintiff is required to make the defective, product available to the defendant for the purposes of an inspection by a representative of the defendant, only on terms that the inspection occurs:

(i)         During ordinary business hours; and

(ii)        At the offices of the plaintiff’s solicitors; and

(iii)       Under the supervision of the plaintiff’s solicitors.

(b)   Notice of such an inspection referred to in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plastec Australia Pty Ltd –v- Rubber Auto Supplies Pty Ltd &... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QMC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Plastec Australia Pty Ltd filed a claim against Rubber Auto Supplies Pty Ltd and Maureen Irwin, a third party, in a dispute regarding the inspection and testing of samples of a defective product. The matter was before the court for an application for directions concerning the inspection and testing of the remaining sample of the defective product. The court had to decide on the proposed regime for the inspection and testing of the samples, taking into account the balance of convenience and the avoidance of prejudice.

The court deliberated on the appropriate procedure for the inspection and testing of the remaining sample, considering the balance of convenience and the potential for prejudice to either party. It was determined that the defendant should provide written notice to the plaintiff within seven days, stating whether it intended to engage an appropriate certified laboratory to undertake testing on the samples. If the defendant intended to proceed with testing, the plaintiff was to deliver the samples to the laboratory nominated by the defendant. The court also outlined specific requirements for the defendant's notice, including the name of the proposed testing facility, the proposed tests, the qualifications of the persons conducting the tests, and the proposed timeframe for testing and reporting. Additionally, the court required the defendant to bear the costs of testing and to provide a copy of its letter of instructions to the laboratory and all related correspondence to the plaintiff. The court further specified that the laboratory must provide both a hard copy and soft copy of its report to the plaintiff and defendant within six weeks of receiving the samples.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the need to balance the rights and interests of both parties while ensuring that the inspection and testing of the samples proceeded in a manner that avoided potential prejudice. The court considered the practicalities of the inspection and testing process, the need for supervision to maintain the integrity of the samples, and the importance of timely reporting of the test results. The court concluded that the proposed regime for the inspection and testing of the samples, as outlined in the orders, was the most appropriate way to proceed, taking into account the balance of convenience and the avoidance of prejudice.

In conclusion, the court issued orders that required the defendant to provide written notice to the plaintiff regarding its intention to engage a certified laboratory for testing. If the defendant intended to proceed with testing, the plaintiff was to deliver the samples to the laboratory nominated by the defendant, subject to specific requirements outlined in the orders. The court also specified that the defendant must bear the costs of testing, provide copies of its instructions to the laboratory and related correspondence to the plaintiff, and ensure that the laboratory provided a report to both parties within six weeks of receiving the samples. The parties were at liberty to apply to the court with three business days' notice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1

(a) The defendant is required to provide written notice to the plaintiff within 7 days of these Orders as to whether it intends to engage an; appropriate certified laboratory to undertake testing on the samples of the defective product (as that term is defined in the Statement of Claim) (“defective product”).

(b) In the event that the defendant provides written notice pursuant to Order 1 (a) above, the plaintiff is to deliver the samples of the defective product to the appropriately certified laboratory nominated by the defendant in its notice for further testing, within 14 days of the defendant providing the following to the plaintiff:

(i) The name of the proposed testing facility, including a summary of the facility’s specific testing expertise in relation to such products as the defective products;

(ii) The proposed tests to be undertaken by the facility on the defective products;

(iii) The name(s) and qualification(s) of the persons at the facility who will conduct the tests;

(iv) The proposed timeframe for the testing of the defective products and for reporting as to the results of the testing;

(v) An undertaking that that the defendant’s instruction to nominated appropriate certified laboratory will contain a direction to provide its report to both the plaintiff and the defendant simultaneously;

(vi) Written undertaking(s) from the testing facility and the persons who will conduct the tests that no other party will be provided with access to the samples, other than the persons at the facility who will conduct the tests.

(c) That the costs of the testing be borne by the defendant;

(d) That the defendant provide a copy of its letter of instructions to the certified laboratory and all correspondence relating to the preparation of the report pursuant to 1(v) above contemporaneous with the sending of the original correspondence to the tester.

(e) That the defendant will instruct the laboratory that, within 6 weeks of the date of delivery of the products to the NATA certified laboratory identified in the defendant’s notice, the NATA certified laboratory must provide both a hard copy and soft copy of its report to the plaintiff and defendant.

2

(a) Further and/or in the alternative to Order 1 above, subject to 2(b) below, the plaintiff is required to make the defective, product available to the defendant for the purposes of an inspection by a representative of the defendant, only on terms that the inspection occurs:

(i) During ordinary business hours; and

(ii) At the offices of the plaintiff’s solicitors; and

(iii) Under the supervision of the plaintiff’s solicitors.

(b) Notice of such an inspection referred to in Order 1(1) above, must be provided to the plaintiff within 7 days of the date of these Orders.

3

The parties be at liberty to apply to the Court with 3 business days’ notice.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established