Plantagenet Press Pty Ltd v Advance Press Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   PLANTAGENET PRESS PTY LTD -v- ADVANCE PRESS PTY LTD [2002] WADC 16

CORAM:   GROVES DCJ

HEARD:   23-24  JANUARY 2002

DELIVERED          :   1 FEBRUARY 2002

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2540 of 2000

BETWEEN:   PLANTAGENET PRESS PTY LTD (ACN 059 074 887)

Plaintiff

AND

ADVANCE PRESS PTY LTD
Defendant

Catchwords:

Negligence - Film negatives for publication of books delivered to printer - Duty of care to look after negatives - Failure by printer to return negatives - Negatives lost - Damages for cost of replacement - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Judgment for plaintiff

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr RW Richardson

Defendant:     Ms PE Cahill

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Mallesons Stephen Jaques

Defendant:     Basile Hawkins

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth & Anor v Bishop & Anor, unreported FCt SCt of WA; Library No 950470; delivered 7 September 1995

Case(s) also cited:

Ashby v Tolhurst [1937] 2 KB 242

Brambles Security Services Ltd v Bi-Lo Pty Ltd (1992) A Tort Rep 81-161

David v Pearce Parking Stations Pty Ltd (1954) 91 CLR 642

Fankhauser v Mark Dykes Pty Ltd [1960] VR 376

Joseph Travers & Sons Ltd v Cooper [1915] 1 KB 73

Levison v Patent Steam Carpet Cleaning Co Ltd [1978] QB 69

Liesbosch (Dredger) v SS Edison [1933] AC 449

Moorhouse v Angus & Roberson (1) Pty Ltd [1981] 1 NSWLR 700

Port Swettenham Authority v TW Wu & Co (M) Sdn Bhd [1979] AC 580

S Davis & Co Ltd, In re [1945] Ch 402

Sydney City Council v West (1965) 114 CLR 481

  1. GROVES DCJ:  At the close of the plaintiff's case the defendant conceded on the issue of liability.  That was not surprising as will become apparent from the facts.  The conduct of the defendant by its denial of liability on the pleadings and the manner in which the defence case was presented leaves much to be desired so far as the proper conduct of an action is concerned and the utilisation of the court processes and resources.  The defendant did not lead evidence.  The issues for determination are whether the plaintiff is entitled to damages and if so the quantum of those damages.  The following are the facts as I find them to be.

  2. Trish Ainslie and Roger Garwood are professional photographers.  At all material times they together with another were directors of the plaintiff.  In or about 1995 they conceived the idea for the publication of a series of books, to be known as the Nomad series.  The publications would be directed to the tourist market.  The books would contain photographs taken by Ainslie and Garwood, supplemented where necessary by the photographs of others, and approximately 1,500 words of text commissioned from two writers.  The first four books in the Nomad series were to be on the Kimberley, Broome, Cape Country (Margaret River region) and Perth and Fremantle.  Further books in the Nomad series were planned to follow.

  3. The photographs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plantagenet Press Pty Ltd v Advance Press Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] WADC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Plantagenet Press Pty Ltd v Advance Press Pty Ltd, the dispute involved the costs associated with the destruction of photographic negatives used in the publication of books. The case was heard in an Australian court where the plaintiff, Plantagenet Press Pty Ltd, sought compensation from the defendant, Advance Press Pty Ltd, for the loss of photographic materials used in the production of their books. The primary issue was the determination of the reasonable costs incurred by the plaintiff to replace the lost photographs, including the costs of re-shooting and the associated labour.

The court examined the evidence presented by the plaintiff regarding the costs of re-shooting the photographs, which included the cost of travel, accommodation, and the labour of professional photographers. The plaintiff argued that the cost of re-shooting the photographs was necessary and reasonable, given that it was the most economical way to replace the lost materials. The defendant contested the reasonableness of these costs, suggesting that the plaintiff could have recovered the photographs from other sources or used alternative photographic libraries. However, the plaintiff's expert evidence, which was neither contradicted nor challenged, supported the necessity and reasonableness of the proposed re-shooting programme. The court concluded that the costs claimed by the plaintiff were reasonable and necessary to mitigate the loss caused by the defendant's negligence.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff, awarding damages based on the reasonable costs of re-shooting the photographs and the labour costs of the professional photographers. The court rejected the defendant's contention that no labour costs should be incurred, emphasizing that the costs were necessary to undertake the photographic expeditions that would not have been required but for the defendant's negligence. The final orders of the court included compensation for the costs of re-shooting the photographs and the associated labour costs, totaling $112,550.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Separation costs(i) $3,325.00/book x 4 $13,300.00 $13,300.00 Design costs(i) $2,150.00/book x 4 $8,000.00 $8,000.00$112,550.00 In Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth & Anor v Bishop & Anor, unreported FCt SCt of WA; Library No 950470; delivered 7 September 1995 confirmed on appeal Anderson J said:"In the case of the damage, loss or destruction of chattels the measure of damages is usually the cost of repair or replacement by purchasing in the market. Where a lost chattel cannot be replaced by purchase in the market 'and it is reasonable to have a substitute made, the cost of the substitute may provide the measure of damages'; 12 Halsbury 3 Ed par 1163 citing J & E Hall Ltd v Barclay [1937] 3 All ER 620.In the case of destruction of a profit earning chattel, used in the course of business, the bailor is entitled to loss of profit during the period which is reasonably required to replace it: Liesbosch (Dredger) v SS Edison [1933] AC 449. It goes without saying that the bailor cannot have both value of the chattels lost and the cost of replacing them." As I have indicated earlier, I am satisfied that it is reasonable that substitute photographs be taken so as to enable complete film negatives to be made from which the books can be printed. Thus the measure of damages is the cost to be incurred in getting to that stage. The calculations so far as the requisite number of rolls of film and travelling and accommodation expenses were prepared by Ainslie in consultation with Garwood. It was their evidence that the estimates were conservative. An attempt was made at challenging the estimates and the associated costs but neither of the witnesses were moved from their evidence. No evidence was led on behalf of the defendant to challenge or contradict this evidence. Again as to the allowance of $50 per hour for Ainslie and Garwood's time, this again was said to be conservative. Hourly rates for professional photographers greatly exceeds this sum. Whilst they had not charged the plaintiff for the time which they had expended in taking the original transparencies they had at that time received wages from the company. Whether or not Ainslie and Garwood re‑shoot the photographs or the plaintiff engages another or other professional photographers to do so I am satisfied that the cost of doing so is a cost which will necessarily be incurred. I do not accept the defendant's contention that no labour cost at all will be incurred by the plaintiff. What is required is for a series of photographic expeditions to be undertaken which but for the negligence of the defendant would not have been required. It is no answer to say that because Ainslie and Garwood were not paid an hourly rate for their time when the original negatives were shot that they should be expected to give their time to the company to re‑shoot the photographs for nothing. That is totally unrealistic. Defence counsel criticised the reasonableness of those costs by suggesting that the plaintiff had not adequately addressed the issue as to the necessity to re‑shoot photographs against the opportunity to either recover photographs from photographic libraries or from other photographers or indeed to obtain replacement photographs from the photographic libraries to which they had sent transparencies. I accept the evidence of Ainslie which was neither controverted nor contradicted that the most economical way of replacing the now non available photographs with others of similar content and of the requisite standard was to undertake the re‑shooting programme as proposed. I am satisfied also that as Ainslie and Garwood will be re‑shooting in each of the areas covered by the books that it is more economical that they re‑shoot photographs which will replace those of other photographers to whom a payment would otherwise have to be made if their photos were to be re‑used again. Again that evidence although criticised by defence counsel was not contradicted.