Plant Genetic Systems N.V. v Paladin Hybrids Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application:  No. 621113 in the name of Plant Genetic Systems N.V.

Title:  Plants with modified stamen cells

Action: Opposition under S.59 of the Patents Act 1952 by Paladin Hybrids Inc. Application by the applicant under Section 223 for extension of time to pay a continuation fee, opposition to that application, hearing.

Decision:  Issued  .

Abstract:Extension of time allowed.

Attorney's employee failed to update the firm's database to show that the firm had full responsibility for the payment of maintenance fees.

All the circumstances taken into account, Ferocem Pty Ltd v Commissioner [1994] AIPC 91-057, followed.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re: Application No. 621113 in the name of Plant Genetic Systems N.V, opposition under S.59 of the Patents Act 1952 by Paladin Hybrids Inc. Application by the applicant under Section 223 for an extension of time to pay a continuation fee.

BACKGROUND

Patent application 621113 was lodged on 27 April 1989 as a PCT application. It was advertised accepted on 5 March 1992 and a notice of opposition was filed on 5 June 1992. In a decision dated 7 June 1993, a delegate of the Commissioner allowed amendment of the Statement of Grounds and Particulars. The evidence-in-support was completed by 26 May 1995 and the opposition is now in the evidence-in-answer stage. The applicant made several requests to propose amendments to the specification under S.104, one set of amendments had been opposed by the opponent, and the evidence-in-answer in the substantive opposition was deferred, pending settlement of the S.104 issue. The opposition to the amendments ceased though when those amendments were withdrawn, and the evidence-in-answer then became due on 27 August 1998.  Since then the applicant has applied for three extensions of time under R.5.10(2) to serve its evidence-in-answer, the first extension being for 3 months to 27 November 1998, the second extension being for three months to 27 February 1999 and the third for three months to 27 May 1999.

An examiner's report on the latest set of proposed amendments was issued on 18 August 1998 and comments from the opponent were filed on 28 September 1998 (the opponent alleges that the amendments are not allowable under S.102) but these comments have not been considered by the examiner to date.

By letter dated 4 December 1998 the Patent Office informed the parties that the application had lapsed, and an application for extension of time under S.223(2) to restore the application was filed by the applicant on the same day. The opponent objected to the extension and the matter was heard in Melbourne on 23 February 1999. The applicant was represented by Mr John Slattery, patent attorney, and the opponent was represented by Ms Pamela Tate, of Counsel, Dr Vivien Santer, patent attorney, and Ms Carmela Monger.

The opponent's representatives presented two declarations at the hearing, both dated 22 February 1999, by Dr Santer and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plant Genetic Systems N.V. v Paladin Hybrids Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] APO 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision of the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents in the matter of Plant Genetic Systems N.V. v. Paladin Hybrids Inc. involved an application by Plant Genetic Systems N.V. for an extension of time to pay a continuation fee, which was opposed by Paladin Hybrids Inc. The dispute centred around whether the applicant, Plant Genetic Systems N.V., had demonstrated a relevant error or omission under Section 223 of the Patents Act 1990 that justified the extension of time for fee payment, which had lapsed, causing the patent application to be in danger of being revoked.

The primary legal issue was whether the applicant had sufficiently identified the error or omission that led to the non-payment of the continuation fee and demonstrated that this was not a deliberate act. The opponent argued that the applicant had failed to identify the error properly, identify who committed the error, and give full and frank disclosure of the circumstances surrounding the error. The applicant contended that the error was due to an employee's failure to update the firm's database, which led to the oversight of the fee payment.

The court considered the evidence provided by the applicant, including a declaration by an employee who outlined the administrative error. The delegate found that the error was identifiable and attributable to the employee's oversight. The court noted that while the opponent raised concerns about the timing of the error and the lack of further declarations, the evidence was sufficient to support the conclusion that there had been a relevant error or omission. The delegate also considered the broader circumstances, including the applicant's proactive steps to address the lapse and the absence of any evidence of deliberate intent to allow the application to lapse.

Ultimately, the delegate allowed the extension of time under Section 223(2)(a), emphasizing the importance of the applicant's interest in maintaining its patent rights and the lack of any undue delay in applying for the extension. The delegate awarded costs against the opponent, Paladin Hybrids Inc., as the application for the extension was successful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established