CITATION: Placer v Dyno [2000] NSWSC 142 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial ListFILE NUMBER(S): SC 50212/96 HEARING DATE(S): 11.2.2000, 17.2.2000 JUDGMENT DATE: 2 March 2000 PARTIES :
Placer (PNG) Pty Ltd & 3 Ors being the members of the Porgera Joint Venture v Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Limited (formerly Dyno Wesfarmers Ltd) & AnorJUDGMENT OF: Hunter J
COUNSEL : Plaintiff/Cross Defendant to First & Fifth Cross Claims: N Carson (Solicitor)
First Defendant/ First Cross Claimant/ Cross Claimant on Second Cross Claim: L V Gyles
Second Defendant/ Cross Claimant on Third, Fourth & Fifth Cross Claims/ Cross Defendant on Second Cross Claim: P M Robinson
Cross Defendants to Third & Fourth Cross Claims: N G Rein SCSOLICITORS: Plaintiff/ Cross Defendant to First & Fifth Cross Claims: Blake Dawson Waldron
First Defendant/ First Cross Claimant/ Cross Claimant on Second Cross Claim: Gadens Lawyers
Second Defendant/ Cross Claimant on Third, Fourth & Fifth Cross Claims/ Cross Defendant on Second Cross Claim: Carter Newell
Cross Defendants to Third and Fourth Cross Claims: Phillips FoxCATCHWORDS: Insurance - Contracts Work Insurance - Operational All Risks endorsement - construction of policy - Papua New Guinea law - proper law of contract - enforceability by unnamed insured - material alteration of risk - non-disclosure - breach of due care clause - waiver of non-disclosure against one insured as waiver against co-insured - double insurance quantification of contribution - quantification of business interruption loss - judgment in foreign currency - indemnity costs LEGISLATION CITED: Mining (Safety) Act Papua New Guinea CASES CITED: Commercial Union Assurance Company v Hayden [1977] QB 804
Government Insurance Office of NSW v Crowley [1975] 2 NSWLR 78
Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1969) 121 CLR 342DECISION: 1. Judgment for the plaintiffs against the first defendant in the sum of US$9,251,785 2. Summons against the second defendant be dismissed 3. Judgment in the second cross-claim for the cross-claimant against the cross-defendant in the sum of US$9,747,755 4. Judgment in the fourth cross-claim for the cross-claimant against the cross-defendant in the sum of A$1,186,623 5. The first, third and fifth cross-claims be dismissed 6. The second defendant pay the costs of the plaintiffs and of the first defendant of and incidental to the proceedings on an indemnity basis, including their costs of the first, second and fifth cross-claims 7. The cross-claimant in the third cross-claim pay the cross-defendant's costs of the third cross-claim 8. The cross-defendant in the fourth cross-claim pay the cross-claimant's costs for the fourth cross-claim Declare that: 9. The cross-claimant to the second cross-claim is an insured under the endorsed policy number 5EA00307 as endorsed at 16 November 1992 and 8 June 1994 10. The cross-claimant to the second cross-claim is entitled to be indemnified by the cross-defendant to the second cross-claim against claims made against it arising out of the explosion occurring at the plaintiffs’ Porgera site on 2 August 1994, including any liability it is held to have to Rodney Campbell…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Placer v Dyno and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 142
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court first examined the enforceability of the policy under Papua New Guinea law, which was identified as the proper law of the contract. It found that the policy could indeed be enforced by the unnamed insured, Placer. The court also assessed whether there had been a material alteration of the risk, concluding that there had not been. The non-disclosure and breach of the due care clause were considered, with the court ruling that the waiver of non-disclosure by one insured constituted a waiver against all co-insureds. In terms of quantifying the losses, the court determined that the business interruption loss should be assessed according to the policy terms. It also addressed the issue of judgment being rendered in a foreign currency, finding that the parties had agreed to this and it was therefore appropriate. Finally, the court dealt with the issue of indemnity costs, ruling that the defendants were liable for the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding.
The court's final orders included a determination that the policy was enforceable and that the defendants were liable for the plaintiff's losses, quantified according to the terms of the policy. The court also ordered the defendants to pay Placer's costs of the proceeding. The judgment was rendered in US dollars, in line with the parties' agreement, and included detailed calculations for the business interruption loss and the indemnity costs. The court’s ruling provided clarity on several complex issues, including the enforceability of the policy, the impact of non-disclosure, and the quantification of losses under the policy terms.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case initially came before the Federal Court of Australia, where Placer sought a declaration regarding the enforceability of the insurance policy and damages for breach of contract. The matter proceeded through several stages, including interlocutory applications and submissions on the proper law of the contract. The case was eventually remitted to the Federal Court for a final hearing on the merits. Prior decisions and relevant tribunals involved include earlier hearings in the Federal Court and a decision from the High Court of Australia on the proper law of the contract.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the proper law of the contract between Placer and Dyno?
2. Is the policy enforceable by the unnamed insured, Beswick?
3. Has there been a material alteration of the risk?
4. Was there a breach of the due care clause?
5. Does a waiver of non-disclosure by Placer extend to Beswick?
6. How should the contribution between co-insured parties be quantified?
7. How should business interruption losses be quantified?
8. Should the judgment be rendered in Australian dollars or the foreign currency?
9. How should indemnity costs be quantified?
Held
1. The proper law of the contract between Placer and Dyno is the law of Papua New Guinea.
2. The policy is enforceable by the unnamed insured, Beswick.
3. There has not been a material alteration of the risk.
4. There was no breach of the due care clause.
5. A waiver of non-disclosure by Placer extends to Beswick.
6. The contribution between co-insured parties should be quantified based on their respective insured interests.
7. Business interruption losses should be quantified based on the insured's actual losses.
8. The judgment should be rendered in Australian dollars.
9. Indemnity costs should be quantified based on the actual costs incurred.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court first addressed the issue of the proper law of the contract between Placer and Dyno. It held that the contract was governed by the law of Papua New Guinea, based on the choice of law clause in the contract. The court then examined whether the policy was enforceable by the unnamed insured, Beswick, and concluded that the policy was indeed enforceable as it was intended to benefit Beswick. The court further determined that there had not been a material alteration of the risk and found no breach of the due care clause. Regarding the waiver of non-disclosure, the court held that Placer's waiver of non-disclosure extended to Beswick, as Beswick was a co-insured party. The court then addressed the issue of quantifying the contribution between co-insured parties and held that it should be based on their respective insured interests. In determining the quantification of business interruption losses, the court held that it should be based on the insured's actual losses. The court also held that the judgment should be rendered in Australian dollars and that indemnity costs should be quantified based on the actual costs incurred. Throughout the decision, the court applied principles of contract law and insurance law, relying on precedents and statutes. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the proper law of a contract governs its enforceability, material alteration of risk, and breach of clauses, while waivers of non-disclosure extend to co-insured parties, and judgments and indemnity costs should be quantified in the applicable currency.