PKT Technologies Pty Ltd (formerly known as Fairlight.Au Pty Ltd) v Peter Vogel Instruments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PKT Technologies Pty Ltd (formerly known as Fairlight.Au Pty Ltd) v

Peter Vogel Instruments Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1587

File number: VID 784 of 2012
Judge: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 23 October 2018
Catchwords:

DAMAGES – damages for wrongful repudiation of agreement by cross-respondent – reliance damages – where agreement would not have been profitable for cross-claimant – where cross-claimant not likely to recoup all of its expenditure – where not possible to determine what proportion of cross-claimant’s expenditure would have recouped but for repudiation – reliance damages assessed by reference to cross-claimant’s loss of opportunity to recoup its expenditure – cross-respondent awarded 30% of its expenditure in respect of loss of opportunity

DAMAGES – damages for copyright infringement under s 115 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) – where damages under s 115(2) assessed at $3,000 – whether there should be an award of additional damages under s 115(4) – where there was a reckless disregard for rights of cross-claimant as copyright owner or a person who had strong grounds for asserting ownership of copyright – additional damages assessed at $50,000

TRADE MARKS – account of profits – where registered trade mark infringed by respondent by offering to supply and supplying applications for use on electronic devices – where trade mark used in relation to sales made both in Australia and other countries – whether profits recoverable by registered owner in respect of sales made in other countries – whether sales made in other countries shown to be attributable to infringing use of registered trade mark in Australia

TRADE MARKS – account of profits – whether respondent entitled to allowance for general business overheads when calculating profits payable to applicant for infringement of registered trade mark – where no evidence to show what proportion of overheads attributable to relevant profit – no allowance made  

Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) s 115

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 20(1) 120, 126

Cases cited:

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited (ACN 001 660 715) v D.A.P. Services (Kempsey) Pty Limited (in liquidation) (ACN 055 803 542) (2007) 239 ALR 702

Barcelo v Electrolytic Zinc Co of Australasia Ltd (1932) 48 CLR 391

Colbeam Palmer Ltd v Stock Affiliates Pty Ltd (1968) 122 CLR 25

Commonwealth of Australia v Amann Aviation Pty Limited (1991) 174 CLR 64

Dart Industries Inc v Decor Corporation Pty Ltd (1992) 179 CLR 101

Enzed Holdings Ltd v Wynthea Pty Ltd (1984) 57 ALR 167

Fairlight.AU Pty Ltd v Peter Vogel Instruments Pty Ltd (No 3) [2015] FCA 1422

Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Ex 341

Jumbunna Coal Mine, NL v Victorian Coal Miners’ Association (1908) 6 CLR 309

Malec v JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638

Peter Vogel Instruments Pty Ltd v Fairlight.Au Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 172

Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332

Ward Group Pty Ltd v Brodie & Stone Plc (2005) 215 ALR 716

Davison M J and Horak I, Shanahan’s Australian Law of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PKT Technologies Pty Ltd (formerly known as Fairlight.Au Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1587
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

PKT Technologies Pty Ltd (formerly known as Fairlight.Au Pty Ltd) was involved in a legal dispute with Peter Vogel Instruments Pty Ltd, which was heard by the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issues at hand were the determination of damages for wrongful repudiation of an agreement, damages for copyright infringement under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), and the account of profits for trade mark infringement. The court was tasked with assessing the appropriate amount of reliance damages for the wrongful repudiation, determining whether additional damages should be awarded for copyright infringement, and deciding if profits from sales in other countries could be attributed to the trade mark infringement in Australia.

The court ruled that the reliance damages for the wrongful repudiation should be assessed based on the loss of opportunity to recoup expenditure. Since it was not possible to determine what proportion of the cross-claimant’s expenditure would have been recouped but for the repudiation, the court awarded 30% of the cross-claimant’s expenditure as the loss of opportunity. For the copyright infringement, the court found that there was a reckless disregard for the rights of the cross-claimant as the copyright owner, warranting an additional award of damages under s 115(4) of the Act, which was set at $50,000. Regarding the trade mark infringement, the court held that profits from sales in other countries were not recoverable unless it was shown that those sales were attributable to the infringing use in Australia. Additionally, the court denied any allowance for general business overheads when calculating the profits payable to the applicant, as there was no evidence to show the proportion of overheads attributable to the relevant profit.

The final orders included judgment for the first respondent/cross-claimant against the applicant/first cross-respondent in the amount of $383,956, with the first respondent/cross-claimant to pay $9,808 to the applicant/first cross-respondent. The applicant/first cross-respondent was entitled to set-off the amount against the judgment. The parties were required to confer on the s 51A interest calculations and file written submissions regarding the interest and costs of the proceeding. The case was to be listed for further orders relating to interest, costs, and the final disposition of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. There be judgment for the first respondent/cross-claimant against the applicant/first cross-respondent in the amount of $383,956 (exclusive of interest).

2. The first respondent/cross-claimant pay to the applicant/first cross-respondent the amount of $9,808 (exclusive of interest).

3. The applicant/first cross-respondent is entitled to set-off the amount referred to in order 2 (and any interest thereon) against the judgment referred to in order 1.

4. Orders 1-2 are made without prejudice to the right of the parties to seek interest on the amounts referred to in those orders pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“s 51A interest”).

5. The parties are to confer for the purpose of reaching agreement in relation to s 51A interest calculations.

6. Within 14 days the parties are to file and serve written submissions (limited to 3 pages in length) in relation to:

(a) the amount of any s 51A interest that should be awarded; and

(b) the costs of the proceeding generally including the costs of and incidental to the remittal hearing (but excluding the costs of the appeal from Edmonds J’s orders of 17 December 2015).

7. Within 21 days the parties are to file and serve any written submissions in reply (limited to 2 pages in length).

8. The proceeding be listed before Nicholas J at 9.30am on 22 November 2018 for the purpose of making further orders relating to interest, costs and the final disposition of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Full Court set out the terms of the written agreement entered into between PVI and Fairlight.Au at [10]:This Agreement is made on 15th August 2010 between:Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd (ACN 140 173 397) of 10 Whitney Street, Mona Vale, New South Wales, 2103, Australia (“FI”); andFairlight.au Pty Ltd (ACN 104 307 888) of Unit 3/15 Rodborough Road, Frenchs Forest, New South Wales, 2086, Australia (“F.au”).Background1.FI is a corporation established by Peter Vogel to develop and commercialise electronic musical instruments and related products.2. F.au is a developer of technology for the audio and film industry.3. FI wish to produce:(1)a 30 Year anniversary model of the Fairlight CMI referred to as the “CMI-30A” and (2)a PC compatible version known as the “Series IV”, referred to collectively as the “CMI Products”.4. F.au will provide FI with:(1)certain hardware and technologies including customised software development for the CMI Products(2)a license for the use of the name “Fairlight” for the CMI Products during the term of this agreement; and(3)supply of core components including sound library, on the terms contained in this agreement.5.FI will raise the required development funds, manufacture, market and distribute the CMI Products internationally. FI warrants that it has sufficient capital to commit to contract F.au to carry out the development contemplated herein.Operative provisionsObligations of FI6. FI will pay F.au a total of $200,000 (plus GST) for:(1)the development of the Fairlight CMI Software; and(2)worldwide use of the “Fairlight” name and brand for marketing purposes for the CMI Products developed and/or marketed by FI pursuant to and during the term of this agreement.(3)Use of Fairlight name and brand cannot be sold or transferred to any other party without written agreement by F.au.(4)F.au reserves the right to withdraw the right for FI to use the Fairlight name and brand, should the name and brand be used in any way which F.au deem to be damaging to the Fairlight Brand reputation.7. FI will make the payment to F.au required by clause 6 by way of four payments, each of $50,000 (plus GST) (total of $200,000) against F.au’s demonstrated meeting of milestones as agreed between the parties before commencement of the development project.8.Based around the hardware and software provided to FI by F.au as described herein, FI will package, develop, manufacture and market Fairlight branded musical instruments.9.FI will package, develop, manufacture and market Fairlight branded musical instruments at its own cost, pay F.AU a one-off fee for development of the software as specified below, and purchase F.au custom components including Crystal Core and SX-x devices.10.FI will develop the necessary components of the CMI Products including the retro keyboard and CMI box ready to accept the F.au boards and software. FI will also undertake all aspects of the marketing of the CMI Products, including but not limited to:(1)direct sales;(2)sales channel management; and(3)promotional activities.11.FI will market and sell the CMI Series IV in a “sound-module” form, ie without a keyboard, but as CC-1 and Fairlight CMI software only.12.FI will assist in the specification and testing process, and in gathering market feedback.Obligations of F.au13.F.au agrees to produce a software application emulating the sounds and user interface of the Fairlight CMI running on a PC using a CC-1 card.14.In addition to hardware and software provided by F.au to FI, F.au will include a licensed version of the Fairlight CMI sound libraries.15.F.au will supply the following products and technology to FI for the CMI Products:(1)“Fairlight CMI Software” application;(2)CC-1 card; and(3)SX-8 or similar input/output device.16.A detailed specification for the final CMI-30A product will be produced by the parties prior to commencement of development.17.F.au agrees to complete the necessary CMI Hardware and Software within four months from order. ‘Order’ being defined as: signed agreement, signed specification of product, signed list of monthly milestones, signed definition of transferred IP, and receipt of first $50K.18.F.au reserves the right to extend the 4 month delivery period should FI not make its stage payment in a timely manner.19.F.au agrees that in the event that it is unable to supply hardware or software as contracted within a commercially reasonable time, or if an administrator or receiver is appointed to F.au, FI is automatically granted an immediate perpetual, royalty-free licence to use anything belonging to or controlled by F.au necessary for FI to complete the development or manufacturing contemplated by this agreement. This is provided that full payment for any work completed up to that point has been provided by FI to F.au.Intellectual property rights20.Upon receipt of the final payment-from FI, F.au agrees that the software and its source components developed by F.au pursuant to this agreement will transfer to FI. The exact definition of IP to be transferred will be defined in a separate document.21.F.au does not own any of the FI business that commercialises the CMI Products and related products and technology.22. FI will own the Fairlight CMI Software application and all its specific source code including elements of the Crystal Core source code. There are no other IP implications.Sale of CMI Products23.By default, a CC-1 card sold for use in a CMI system cannot run Dream II software without additional licensing. Likewise, a CC-1 card sold for use in a Dream II system cannot run CMI software without additional licensing.24.All licensing will be handled through F.au, with appropriate and timely reporting to FI.25.F.au will have the opportunity to purchase Fairlight CMI Software licenses to sell with existing and future F.au products at a price to be negotiated in the order of AUD $1,500.00 per license.26.The Parties agree the following cost of components for the CMI-IV, subject to negotiation and based on exchange rates and discount for product volumes:(1)Package 1 (CC-1, SX-8) AUD $2,542.00(2)Package 2 (CC-1, SX-20) AUD $3,977.0027.FI is licensed to offer CMI-30A customers an upgrade path to full Dream II capability, through purchasing a license from F.au at a price to be negotiated, in line with the prevailing list price.28.F.au will also be able to market the CMI Products through its distribution channel.General.29. This agreement is governed by the laws of New South Wales, Australia. 30. All references to “$” are to Australian dollars.31. This agreement binds the parties and their successors.Term32.After one year from signing, this agreement can be terminated on three months written notice by F.au if FI fails to purchase from F.au products to a minimum value of $50,000 per annum (calculated annually in arrears, commencing from the date of completion of the development contract contemplated herein).33.This agreement can be terminated by FI by giving three months written notice.34.Otherwise the agreement is ongoing unless terminated by agreement between the parties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established