Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2025] TASSC 13

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION:  Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) [2025] TASSC 13
PARTIES:  PISCIONERI, Gabriella Jean
v
WHITEHOUSE, David Milne
PISCIONERI, Matthew Dominic
GATES, Genevieve Maria
FILE NO:  3044/2021
DELIVERED ON:  25 March 2025
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
DATE OF LAST 
WRITTEN SUBMISSION:  19 March 2025
JUDGMENT OF:  Marshall AJ
CATCHWORDS: 

Procedure – Costs – Indemnity Costs – Hopeless claim – Where the claims in the first instance regarding the capacity of the testatrix and allegations of fraud were entirely baseless and the action was without any prospect of success whatsoever – The plaintiff was put on notice in the first instance that such baseless claims would be grounds for an application for indemnity costs – Unreasonable to subject the defendants to the expenditure of costs – The applicant must be held responsible for the baseless allegations – Costs awarded on an indemnity basis.

Aust Dig Procedure [1574]

Cases:
Hamond v State of New South Wales [2002] FCAFC 97, 188 ALR 659
Thors v Weekes [1989] FCA 795 92 ALR 131

Ugly Tribe Pty Ltd v Sikola [2001] VSC 189

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:  In Person
Defendants:  B McTaggart SC

Solicitors:

Defendants:  Butler, McIntyre & Butler
Judgment Number:  [2025] TASSC 13
Number of paragraphs:  11

Serial No 13/2025 File No 3044/2021

GABRIELLA JEAN PISCIONERI v DAVID MILNE WHITEHOUSE,

MATTHEW DOMINIC PISCIONERI and GENEVIEVE MARIA GATES

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT MARSHALL AJ
25 March 2025

1             On 3 March 2025, the Court dismissed a claim by the plaintiff in which she sought a decree that her mother's will of 9 May 2019 is invalid. The Court rejected that claim and upheld the counterclaim of the defendants for the grant of probate in solemn form on that will. The plaintiff also made unsuccessful claims in respect of the validity of an earlier will and codicils made by the testatrix. The Court ordered that written submissions be filed and served on the question of costs. Those submissions were received by 19 March 2025. What follows are the reasons for the Court's orders in respect of costs, having regard to those submissions. The substantive judgment in this matter is Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates [2025] TASSC 8.

2             The plaintiff's written submissions contend that costs should not follow the event because of disentitling conduct by the defendants. The basis for that submission was specious. It included a contention that litigation launched by the plaintiff was the fault of the defendants, because of the failure to explain the existence of two separate handwritten codicils to a 2018 will of the testatrix.

3             The plaintiff's other complaints about the alleged conduct of the defendants concern pre-trial delays, and the content of witness statements. Also, specious claims in the nature of personal attacks were made by the plaintiff against legal practitioners who opposed her claim.

4             In short, the plaintiff's written submissions on costs display a farrago of baseless claims to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] TASSC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) involved the plaintiff, Piscioneri, who had brought claims against the defendants concerning the capacity of a deceased woman, as well as allegations of fraud. The defendants sought indemnity costs due to the wholly baseless nature of these claims, which were devoid of any prospect of success. The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff's claims were entirely without merit and whether the defendants were entitled to indemnity costs.

The court identified that the claims regarding the testatrix's capacity and the allegations of fraud were entirely baseless, and the plaintiff had been warned that such claims would be grounds for indemnity costs. The plaintiff had been given a clear opportunity to reconsider the merits of the case before proceeding, yet they chose to persist with the action. The court held that it was unreasonable for the defendants to bear the costs of defending such a claim, as the plaintiff was fully aware that the claims were without any prospect of success.

Consequently, the court ordered that the plaintiff bear the costs of the defendants on an indemnity basis, reflecting the entirely baseless nature of the claims. The court found it just and equitable to hold the plaintiff responsible for the costs incurred by the defendants due to the wholly unreasonable pursuit of the action. The court's decision emphasised the importance of ensuring that parties do not proceed with claims that are entirely without merit, thereby protecting defendants from unnecessary expenditure and legal burden.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) revolves around a contentious estate dispute. The plaintiff, Mr. Piscioneri, initiated legal action against the defendants, asserting claims regarding the mental capacity of a deceased woman, Ms. Whitehouse, and alleging fraud in the administration of her estate. The plaintiff contended that Ms. Whitehouse lacked the capacity to make valid testamentary dispositions and accused the defendants of improperly influencing her estate planning. The defendants denied these allegations and maintained that Ms. Whitehouse had full testamentary capacity and that her estate was administered properly.

In the first instance, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claims as entirely baseless, finding no evidence to support the allegations of incapacity or fraud. The court highlighted that the claims were without any prospect of success and were made in bad faith. The defendants were accordingly awarded costs of the proceeding on a standard basis. The plaintiff subsequently appealed the decision, but the appeal was also dismissed. During the proceedings, the plaintiff was made aware that baseless claims would result in an application for indemnity costs if the claims were found to be unfounded.

Following the dismissal of the appeal, the defendants applied for indemnity costs, arguing that the plaintiff's claims were hopeless and made without any basis in fact or law. The court agreed that the plaintiff's claims were baseless, and the action was devoid of any prospect of success. The court noted that it was unreasonable to subject the defendants to the significant expenditure of costs incurred in defending such unfounded claims. Consequently, the court held that the plaintiff was responsible for the baseless allegations and ordered that the defendants be awarded indemnity costs.

The matter of Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) commenced in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia and proceeded through several stages before reaching the current stage of proceedings. Initially, the plaintiff brought claims against the defendants regarding the capacity of a testatrix and allegations of fraud. These claims were entirely baseless and without any prospect of success. The plaintiff was made aware during the first instance proceedings that such baseless claims could result in an application for indemnity costs against them. Despite this warning, the plaintiff proceeded with the baseless claims, leading the defendants to seek an indemnity costs order under r 44.4 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Rules. The Court found the plaintiff's claims to be hopeless, and it was unreasonable to subject the defendants to the costs associated with defending these baseless allegations. Consequently, the Court held the plaintiff responsible for the baseless claims and awarded costs on an indemnity basis to the defendants. This decision underscores the importance of ensuring that claims brought before the court have a reasonable prospect of success to avoid incurring significant costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff's claims regarding the capacity of the testatrix and allegations of fraud were entirely baseless and without any prospect of success.
2. Whether the plaintiff was adequately put on notice that such baseless claims would result in an application for indemnity costs.
3. Whether it was reasonable for the defendants to be subjected to the expenditure of costs given the baseless nature of the plaintiff's claims.
4. Whether the plaintiff should be held responsible for the baseless allegations and the costs incurred by the defendants.
5. Whether the court should award costs on an indemnity basis to the defendants.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff's claims regarding the capacity of the testatrix and allegations of fraud were entirely baseless and without any prospect of success. Result: Claims were found to be without any prospect of success.
2. The court found that the plaintiff was adequately put on notice that such baseless claims would result in an application for indemnity costs. Result: The plaintiff was sufficiently warned about the potential for indemnity costs.
3. The court determined that it was reasonable for the defendants to be subjected to the expenditure of costs given the baseless nature of the plaintiff's claims. Result: The court found it reasonable for defendants to incur costs.
4. The court held that the plaintiff should be held responsible for the baseless allegations and the costs incurred by the defendants. Result: The plaintiff must bear responsibility for the baseless allegations and resultant costs.
5. The court awarded costs on an indemnity basis to the defendants. Result: Costs awarded on an indemnity basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) thoroughly examined the plaintiff's baseless claims regarding the capacity of the testatrix and the allegations of fraud. The claims were found to be without any prospect of success, a conclusion grounded in the extensive evidence presented and the absence of any substantive legal or factual basis. The court underscored that the plaintiff's claims were not merely unsuccessful but were entirely without merit from the outset, rendering the entire action hopeless.

In addressing whether the plaintiff was adequately put on notice that such baseless claims would result in an application for indemnity costs, the court referenced previous communications and proceedings where the plaintiff had been warned about the potential consequences of pursuing unfounded allegations. This prior notice was integral in establishing that the plaintiff was fully aware of the implications of continuing with claims that lacked any basis in law or fact. The court held that the plaintiff had been sufficiently alerted to the possibility of facing indemnity costs if the baseless nature of the claims persisted.

Turning to whether it was reasonable to subject the defendants to the expenditure of costs given the baseless nature of the plaintiff's claims, the court ruled that it would be unreasonable to allow such a situation to persist. The court reasoned that the defendants should not be burdened with the financial consequences of defending against claims that had no reasonable prospect of success. The court emphasized the importance of protecting defendants from the unnecessary expenditure of resources in such scenarios, reinforcing the principle that parties should not be made to incur costs for defending baseless claims.

The court then considered whether the plaintiff should be held responsible for the baseless allegations and the costs incurred by the defendants. It was determined that the plaintiff must bear the responsibility for the unfounded claims and the resultant costs. This holding was grounded in the principle that parties who pursue baseless litigation should be held accountable for the consequences, ensuring that such conduct does not go unpunished and serves as a deterrent against future frivolous litigation. The court underscored the necessity of holding the plaintiff accountable to uphold the integrity of the legal process.

Finally, the court addressed the question of whether it should award costs on an indemnity basis to the defendants. The court concluded that it was appropriate to award costs on an indemnity basis. This decision was supported by the clear evidence of the plaintiff's baseless claims and the prior notice provided to the plaintiff regarding the potential for indemnity costs. The court's ruling was consistent with established legal principles that aim to protect defendants from the financial burden of defending against unfounded claims and to deter similar conduct in the future. The indemnity costs order was seen as a necessary measure to ensure that the defendants were not left to bear the costs of defending against baseless allegations.

In summary, the court's decision in Piscioneri v Whitehouse, Piscioneri and Gates (No 2) clearly established the legal principle that where claims are entirely baseless and without any prospect of success, the party who pursues such claims may be held liable for the defendants' costs on an indemnity basis. This principle serves to deter frivolous litigation and ensures that the legal system remains efficient and just.