Pisaneschi and K&S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Pisaneschi and K&S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2023] AATA 2997 (19 September 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2021/10046

Re:Moreno (Tim) Pisaneschi

APPLICANT

AndK&S Freighters Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT    

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:19 September 2023  

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review dated 9 December 2021 is set aside and, in substitution, it is decided that the Applicant is entitled to compensation for permanent impairment in respect of his psychiatric injury pursuant to ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 and that the degree of permanent impairment is 10% and the degree of non-economic loss is 76%.

.......................[SGD]........................

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – permanent impairment – accepted claim for hernia injuries – accepted claim for psychiatric injury – multiple prior claims for permanent impairment – whether all reasonable rehabilitative treatment undertaken – applicant not likely to undertake rehabilitative treatment for substantial period – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (Cth)

Cases

Comcare v Filla [2002] FCAFC 61

Filla v Comcare [2001] FCA 964

Secondary Materials

Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment, Edition 2.1

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

19 September 2023

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Pisaneschi applied on 20 December 2021 for review of a decision of a delegate of the Respondent, dated 9 December 2021, which affirmed a determination dated 12 November 2021 denying his claim under sections 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (the Act) for compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss in respect of a psychological injury.

  2. Both this decision and the original decision, dated 12 November 2021, maintain that, notwithstanding the assessment of a whole person permanent impairment of 10%, Mr Pisaneschi had not undertaken ‘all reasonable rehabilitative treatment for the impairment’. This language directly reflects one of the factors a decision-maker must consider pursuant to s 24(2)(c) of the Act, and this was considered a sufficient basis upon which to deny liability.

  3. The matter has its origins in an incident in mid-2017 during Mr Pisaneschi’s duties as a truck driver, leading the Respondent to accept a claim for compensation in respect of bilateral groin pain. Mr Pisaneschi had surgery for bilateral hernia repair in 2013, and a further hernia procedure some years prior. His work history with the Respondent goes back to 2004.

  4. Shortly prior to making the claim for groin pain, Mr Pisaneshi failed a workplace drug screening. This led the Applicant to be banned from the premises of a client business where he had been assigned, and he was stood down by the Respondent. Mr Pisaneschi was then issued with a warning, and transferred to alternative duties. He has not returned to driving, but continues to be employed by the Respondent.

  5. Mr Pisaneschi made a series of claims for permanent impairment through 2020. The first three claims were based, respectively, on pain, scarring, and nerve damage in the context of the Applicant’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pisaneschi and K&S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2997
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Pisaneschi against K&S Freighters Pty Ltd for compensation for permanent impairment arising from accepted claims for hernia injuries and a psychiatric injury. The core dispute revolved around whether Mr Pisaneschi had undertaken all reasonable rehabilitative treatment and whether his impairment had reached a permanent state, thereby entitling him to compensation for non-economic loss. The case was heard by Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were threefold: first, whether Mr Pisaneschi suffered a permanent impairment in respect of his injury, considering the factors stipulated in the relevant Act; second, if so, whether this impairment met the required threshold for compensation; and third, the Applicant’s entitlement to compensation for non-economic loss. The Tribunal was required to assess the evidence regarding the applicant's physical and psychiatric conditions, his engagement with past and potential future treatments, and the opinions of medical professionals.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the applicant's assertion that he had undertaken all reasonable rehabilitative treatment and that no further treatment would yield improvement. Drawing on principles from *Filla v Comcare* and *Comcare v Filla*, the Tribunal acknowledged that determining reasonable rehabilitative treatment is a question of fact, considering risks and benefits. Crucially, the Tribunal noted that if an employee's refusal to undertake available treatment is likely to persist for a substantial period, this supports a finding of permanent impairment. Despite the respondent's contention that further treatment for groin pain was reasonable and available, and that the applicant's psychiatric condition was influenced by his physical state, the Tribunal found that the applicant's intention not to pursue further treatment, coupled with medical opinions suggesting limited benefit from further interventions, indicated that his impairment was permanent.

The Tribunal set aside the decision under review dated 9 December 2021 and substituted a new decision. It found that Mr Pisaneschi was entitled to compensation for permanent impairment in respect of his psychiatric injury under sections 24 and 27 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988*. The degree of permanent impairment was determined to be 10%, and the degree of non-economic loss was assessed at 76%.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues for determination in this matter are:(a)whether Mr Pisaneschi suffers an impairment in respect of his injury that is permanent, taking into account the factors specified in the Act; (b)if so, whether that impairment reaches the required threshold; and(c)the Applicant’s entitlement to compensation for non-economic loss.EVIDENCE I summarise here pertinent aspects of Mr Pisaneschi’s written statement dated 13 February 2023 (JHB10):(a)he suffers ‘severe, wide ranging physical problems’ as a result of his 2013 injury [3], and has had ongoing pain in the groin following the insertion of mesh in the subsequent surgery [9];(b)he developed neuropathic pain, erectile dysfunction, and has had extensive treatment for pain relief, but is not presently under active treatment for his pain [10], [11], [18];(c)symptoms from his injury affected his previously active lifestyle, his sense of self and his social life [12];(d)he attended two psychologists, each on two occasions in 2018, and ‘both thought that [he] already had any coping mechanisms that they could teach [him], and that there was nothing further they could offer… by way of treatment’ [15]; and(e)he has ‘no intention of obtaining any further treatment’ for either physical or mental pain as none of the further options offered can guarantee an improvement [21]. Mr Pisaneschi gave evidence that he had tried multiple pain relief treatments for his groin which had no effect, including physiotherapy and drug treatments. He understood the chances of success for surgical interventions raised with him were less than 30%, and stated that every pain specialist told him that ‘nothing can be done.’ Mr Pisaneschi also considered that failure in further physical treatments would worsen his mental health condition. He considered the impact of reduction in work, recreation and social life made him ‘half a human being’. Mr Pisaneschi stated he is no longer able to be intimate with his wife and his sleep is affected by pain and worry. Mr Pisaneschi described feelings of lack of motivation and self worth, which intensified after being told by medical practitioners that they cannot help him. He understood the psychologists he had seen to have told him that his coping strategies were effective, and did not consider any further treatment would offer any benefit. In cross-examination, Mr Pisaneschi acknowledged playing nine holes of golf recently which he managed with pain medication, and stated he had played four rounds so far in 2023. He also acknowledged that his prior sporting pursuits were casual and informal in nature. Mr Pisaneshi also admitted to riding his motorbike in the street for short stretches only. Mr Pisaneschi was questioned about his statement that he is not interested in ‘talk therapy’, ‘listening to music’, or ‘sniffing flowers’ [17]. This reflected his understanding that his coping mechanisms were as beneficial as these kinds of treatment, providing the example that he would ‘jump in the car and go and have a good cry’. The Applicant was unable to recall when he first experienced suicidal thoughts, but thought it could have been after taking the medication Lyrica in 2017. He stated that he has to be ‘extremely low’ for such thoughts to recur now.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on my findings above and following the calculation scheme provided at B6 of the Guide, I find that an overall score for non-economic loss of 11.4 is achieved. When converted to a percentage following Step 2, this results in a degree of non-economic loss of 76%.DECISION For the reasons given above the Tribunal decides that the decision under review dated 9 December 2021 is set aside and in substitution decides that the Applicant is entitled to compensation for permanent impairment in respect of his psychiatric injury pursuant to ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 and that the degree of permanent impairment is 10% and the degree of non-economic loss is 76%.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Medical records produced under summons from Mr Pisaneschi’s GP reveal consultations in which references are made to groin pain in: early 2015; 2016 contemporary with the Applicant’s presentation to his surgeon; late 2017; early and late 2018; through late 2019 and 2020; and, again during 2021. CONSIDERATION The Applicant contends in the ASFIC that he has undertaken all reasonable rehabilitative treatment, and that there is no evidence any further treatment will result in any improvement to his psychiatric condition [12]. It is contended that Mr Pisaneschi suffers a whole person impairment of 10%, under Table 5.1 of the Guide, and attaining a maximum score of 15 for non-economic loss [15]-[16]. The Applicant refers to Filla v Comcare [2001] FCA 964 and Comcare v Filla [2002] FCAFC 61 (AS [13]-[17]). The Full Court determined that it is a question of fact as to what might constitute reasonable rehabilitative treatment, taking into account a range of factors including risks and benefit [11]-[13]. In the earlier decision, Katz J considered that if an employee’s refusal to undertake currently available treatment, regardless of its reasonableness, is likely to continue for a substantial period, this tends toward a finding that impairment is permanent [63]-[65]. It is submitted that the written opinions of both Dr Cohen and Associate Professor Rachberger were maintained under cross examination at the hearing; in short, absent any further treatment, Mr Pisaneschi’s psychiatric impairment is permanent [24], [35]. Extensive references are made to other medical evidence about the Applicant’s physical injury to the effect that further pain management is unlikely to benefit him [25]-[27]. More specifically, it is contended that further pain management should not be understood as being ‘reasonable rehabilitative treatment’ in respect of Mr Pisaneschi’s psychological impairment [31]. Further, given the Applicant’s intention not to pursue further psychological or physical treatment, his impairment should be seen as permanent [34]-[36]. The Respondent’s written submissions state briefly that Ms Pisaneschi’s psychiatric injury is not permanent (RSFIC [5]). At the hearing, the Respondent pointed to further observations in Comcare v Filla at [13], to the effect that the findings made in any particular case were not necessarily relevant, as questions of fact lie with the Tribunal. Attention was drawn to several medical opinions about options for treatment of Mr Pisaneschi’s physical injury said to demonstrate that rehabilitation for groin pain is both reasonable and available (JHB 128, 130, 134). In addition, it was contended that the report of Dr Szoeke should be interpreted as indicating that the physical condition was not in fact stable. In short, it was submitted that the Applicant had not requested approved treatment and there is no evidence a multidisciplinary pain program would not be beneficial. This contention was said to be particularly relevant in the light of the medical evidence that Mr Pisaneschi’s psychiatric condition was influenced by his physical state. Moreover, the witnesses had simply accepted the Applicant’s own assessment that further treatment would not rectify his situation.