Re: PIONEER CONCRETE (N.T.) PTY. LIMITED
And: WATKINS LIMITED; RANGER URANIUM MINES PTY. LIMITED; CALCARIA PTY.
LIMITED; NORTHERN CEMENT PTY. LIMITED; WRIGHT ENGINEERS PTY. LIMITED; DAVEY
McKEE PACIFIC PTY. LIMITED; COFFEY & PARTNERS PTY. LIMITED; READYMIX CONCRETE
PTY. LIMITED
(1983) 66 FLR 179
No. N7624 of 1982
Practice
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Smithers J.(1), Franki(2) and St. John(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS
Practice - Third party procedure - application for directions pursuant to O.20 r.7 for trial in appropriate manner of question or issue - whether question or issue is "proper to be so tried" - construction of O.20 r.7 by reference to O.20 r.1 - whether issue or question is "substantially the same matter" as the subject matter of the principal action - exercise of discretion - role of Judge in managing the total litigation.
Supreme Court Rules (Northern Territory)
Practice - Third party procedure - Summons by defendant for trial of third party actions at same time as principal action - Whether question or issue is proper to be so tried - Whether issue or question is substantially same matter as subject matter of principal action - Exercise of discretion by trial judge - Rules of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory, O.20, rr.1, 7(1).
HEADNOTE
The first respondent had commenced an action in the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory arising out of the performance by it of concreting work for the second respondent which the second respondent alleged to be defective. The first respondent alleged that the concrete had been purchased from the appellant as it was obliged to do pursuant to the contract with the second respondent and that if the concrete were defective the appellant's failure in this regard constituted a breach by the second respondent of its contract with the first respondent, it being a term of that contract that the concrete supplied by the first respondent would be tested by the fifth and sixth respondents and would conform to the standard specified in the contract.
The first respondent sought damages against the second respondent and the appellant and certain declarations and also sought relief against the third respondent. The appellant and second respondent issued a notice claiming contribution or indemnity from each other. The appellant was granted leave to join the fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth respondents as third parties. A summons by the appellant for an order under O.20, r.7(1)(b) of the Rules of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory that the issues set out in the third party notices be determined at the trial of the principal action was dismissed with costs.
On appeal,
Held: (1) Per Smithers and Franki JJ. - Order 20, r.7 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory did not require that the court be satisfied that there was a prima facie case of entitlement to the relief claimed in the third party notice.
(2) Per Smithers and Franki JJ. - Order…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pioneer Concrete (NT) Pty Ltd v Watkins Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1983] FCA 122
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with interpreting the rules governing third-party procedures, particularly rule 7 of Order 20, in relation to rule 1 of the same order. It needed to determine if the question or issue in the third party's application was substantially the same as the subject matter of the main action. Additionally, the court had to consider the discretion exercised by the trial judge in managing the overall litigation and the appropriate role of the judge in this context.
In its reasoning, the court found that the trial judge's decision to dismiss the third party's application for directions was flawed. The court highlighted the importance of interpreting the rules in a manner that aligns with the overarching principles of justice and the efficient management of litigation. It emphasised the need for the judge to exercise discretion in a way that ensures fairness and that the litigation process progresses effectively. Consequently, the court decided to set aside the orders dismissing the application for third party directions and to remit the summons for directions back to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory for reconsideration.
The court's final orders were to uphold the appeal, set aside the orders dismissing the third party's application for directions, and remit the matter back to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory for further hearing. Additionally, it was ordered that the respondents pay a portion of the appellant's costs of the appeal, while the costs of the summons for directions before the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory were to be determined by that court.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be upheld and that orders 1 and 2 of 29 October 1982, namely that the appellant's application for third party directions be dismissed and the appellant pay the costs of and incidental to the application for third party directions, be set aside.
2. The summons for directions be remitted to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory for hearing in accordance with the principles adverted to by this Court.
3. Each respondent pay one eighth of the appellant's costs of the appeal.
4. The question of costs of the summons for directions before the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory be determined by that Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially arose in the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory where Pioneer Concrete (NT) Pty Ltd sought to join a third party, the principal contractor, in proceedings against Watkins Ltd. The Supreme Court dismissed Pioneer's application for third-party directions, ruling that the issue was not "proper to be so tried" under the rules. Pioneer appealed this decision to the High Court of Australia. The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the Supreme Court's orders and remitting the summons for directions back to the Supreme Court for further hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the question or issue sought to be tried by the third party is "proper to be so tried" under Order 20 rule 7 of the Northern Territory Supreme Court Rules.
2. Whether the issue or question is "substantially the same matter" as the subject matter of the principal action.
3. What is the role of the Judge in managing the total litigation when considering applications for third-party directions.
Held
1. The court concluded that the question or issue sought to be tried by the third party was "proper to be so tried" under Order 20 rule 7 of the Northern Territory Supreme Court Rules. The appeal was upheld, and the orders dismissing the appellant's application for third party directions and requiring the appellant to pay costs were set aside.
2. The court found that the issue or question was not "substantially the same matter" as the subject matter of the principal action, leading to the dismissal of the appellant's application.
3. The court emphasised the role of the Judge in managing the total litigation when considering applications for third-party directions, and remitted the summons for directions to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory for hearing according to the principles outlined by this Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the construction of Order 20 rule 7 by reference to Order 20 rule 1 in determining whether the third-party question or issue was "proper to be so tried". It was established that the issue should be assessed based on whether it is substantially the same as the matter in the principal action. The court held that the Judge's discretion in managing the total litigation is significant and should be exercised with consideration of these principles. The decision recognised that the third-party issue needed to be substantially different from the principal action to warrant separate proceedings. The court departed from the lower court's decision that had denied the application without adequately considering the discretionary aspects of the rule. The binding legal principle established is that the Judge must properly exercise discretion in determining whether a third-party issue is substantially the same as the principal action, taking into account the overall management of the litigation.