PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Pine Mountain Court Pty Ltd & Ors v Valente & Anor [2000]
QPE 015PARTIES: PINE MOUNTAIN COURT PTY LTD
(ACN 010 179 745)
AND
IAN DUDLEY LOW
AND
IRENE LOW, GEORGE NICHOLAS JAMES AND
CHRISTINE JAMES
AND
NICKITA ANTHONY ANGELOS
AND
KATRINA ANGELOS
(Applicants)
v
NICHOLAS VALENTE
AND
PATRICIA ANN VALENTE
(Respondents)FILE NO/S: No 4932 of 1999 DIVISION: Planning and Environment Court PROCEEDING: ORIGINATING Brisbane COURT: DELIVERED ON: 3 March 2000 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARING DATE: JUDGE: Quirk DCJ ORDER:
CATCHWORDS:
COUNSEL:
SOLICITORS:
In this matter declaratory relief is sought in respect of the legality of building work
being carried out on land at Carina Heights. The work involves the construction of
a dwelling house approval for which was the subject of an appeal heard in this
Court in May of 1998. Consequent enforcement orders are also asked for. At the
conclusion of the hearing I indicated that the application would be refused and that I
would deliver written reasons for so deciding as soon as I could.
As can be seen from the written judgment dismissing the objector appeal (Londy &
Jones v Brisbane City Council & Ors, 1998 QPELR 492) the need for town
planning consent arose because the height of the proposed dwelling exceeded 8.5
metres. Important issues in the appeal were whether the views and outlook of
adjoining residents would be affected to an unreasonable degree and whether the
design of the proposal was sufficiently in keeping with other development in the
area.
Before the Court at the time was a set of drawings the identifying numbers of which
were prefixed by the letters SK indicating that they were schematic rather than
working drawings. The approval that was given was that the development was to
be generally in accordance with the drawings which were before the Court.
Since the appeal a further set of drawings has been submitted for private
certification pursuant to Pt 3 of Ch 5 of the Integrated Planning Act. These were
working drawings and were identified as such. They were duly approved. It is
noted that s 5.3.4 requires the private certifier to be satisfied that the plans are not
inconsistent with the necessary Town Planning approval.
It is not suggested that the work is being undertaken other than in accordance with
the plans approved by the private certifier but it is argued that those drawings
indicate a form of development that is not generally in accordance with those
considered by the Court.
It should be added that the complaints were made to the Brisbane City Council
which looked into the matter. On 5 November 1999 the Council officer dealing
with the officer wrote, in response to the relevant complaint:
“With regard to your recent inquiry regarding the development occurring at 91 McGahn Street, Carina Heights please be advised as follows:
Extensive investigations by several development and regulatory services personnel has resulted in Council forming the opinion that this development…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pine Mountain Court Pty Ltd v Valente and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QPEC 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court examined the arguments presented by both parties and considered the implications of the changes made to the building plans. The Court noted that the need for town planning consent arose because the height of the proposed dwelling exceeded 8.5 metres. It was crucial to determine whether these changes, particularly those related to the height and the impact on adjoining residents, would have influenced the original Court decision. The Court referred to previous cases, such as Grace Bros. v Willoughby Municipal Council, to understand the criteria for assessing deviations from earlier approvals. The Court concluded that the changes made to the plans, while altering some architectural details and minor dimensions, did not significantly impact the overall height or the considerations relevant to the original decision. The Court was satisfied that the current construction complied with the earlier approval and that the changes did not affect the planning considerations that were originally addressed.
The Court determined that the proposal, as approved by the private certifier, was generally in accordance with the earlier approval. The Court found that the changes made to the building plans were minor and did not alter the significant considerations that led to the original approval. The application for declaratory relief and enforcement orders was refused. The Court's decision was based on the conclusion that the current construction did not deviate in a manner that would have affected the original decision, and therefore, the proposal remained compliant with the earlier approval.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi