CITATION: Pinch v Prinsse [2000] NSWSC 1030 FILE NUMBER(S): SC 3992 of 1999 HEARING DATE(S): 15 May, 30 June, 28 July, 6, 20 October 2000 JUDGMENT DATE: 7 November 2000 PARTIES :
Leanne Pinch and Gregory Smith (Plaintiffs)
Yvonne Prinsse (Defendant)JUDGMENT OF: Master McLaughlin at 51
COUNSEL : K. Morrissey (Plaintiffs)
M. Willmott (Defendant)SOLICITORS: Hennikers Solicitor (Plaintiffs)
Eric Butler Solicitors (Defendant)CATCHWORDS: Will - Distribution of assets - Death of beneficiary (being child of testator), leaving issue, during lifetime of testator - Entitlement of widow of beneficiary upon his intestacy - Executor in probate application discloses entitlement of other persons to one half of estate - Executor distributes to herself entirety of estate - Whether relevant limitation period in respect of claim by widow has expired - Which party bears the evidentiary burden in respect to such asserted expiry of the limitation period - Appropriate relief. LEGISLATION CITED: Wills, Probate and Administration Act, 1898
Trustee Act, 1925
Limitation Act, 1969CASES CITED: Banque Commerciale SA en liquidation v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279
Pullen v Gutteridge Haskins & Davey Pty Limited (1993) 1 VR 27DECISION: See paragraph 51
SUPREME COURT OF
NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISIONMASTER McLAUGHLIN
Tuesday, 7 November 2000
3992 of 1999 LEANNE PINCH and GREGORY SMITH -V- YVONNE PRINSSEJUDGMENT
1 MASTER: These proceedings were instituted by summons filed on 10 September 1999. The Plaintiffs named in that summons were Leanne Pinch and Gregory Smith, and the Defendant was Yvonne Prinsse. 2 By that summons the Plaintiffs claimed declaratory and other relief in respect to the estate of the late John Smith (to whom I shall refer as “the Deceased”). 3 On 15 May 2000 Mr Justice Hamilton, by consent of the parties, ordered that the trial of the proceedings be referred to a Master. 4 The Deceased, who died on 7 July 1986, left a will dated 7 April 1981, probate whereof was on 21 June 1987 granted to Yvonne Jeanette Prinsse, the executor named in such will (who is the Defendant to the present proceedings). 5 At the time of his death the Deceased was a widower, his wife having pre-deceased him on 28 April 1981. 6 By his will the Deceased, in the events which have happened, provided, by clause 3, as follows:7 The Deceased had fathered two children, being Ronald (who predeceased the Deceased, having died on 21 August 1981) and Yvonne, the Defendant (who survived the Deceased). 8 The two Plaintiffs named in the summons, Leanne Pinch and Gregory Smith, are the two children…
SHOULD my wife predecease me or die within twenty eight days of the date of my death then I appoint my son RONALD WILLIAM JOHN SMITH and my daughter YVONNE JEANETTE PRINCE [ sic ] Executor and Executrix of this my Will and in that event I GIVE DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the whole of my estate as aforesaid UNTO my son and said daughter in equal shares as tenants in common.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pinch v Prinsse and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 1030
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of Pinch v Prinsse involved the distribution of assets following the death of a beneficiary, who was a child of the testator, during the lifetime of the testator. The beneficiary left issue, and the widow of the beneficiary, who was also a child of the testator, sought to claim a share of the estate upon the intestacy of the beneficiary. The executor of the estate, in the probate application, disclosed that other persons were entitled to one half of the estate. However, the executor distributed the entirety of the estate to herself, leading to the widow's claim for her entitlement. The widow argued that the limitation period for her claim had not expired, and the executor contended that it had. The court was tasked with determining the validity of these assertions, the burden of proof, and the appropriate relief for the widow.
The central legal issues before the court were whether the limitation period for the widow's claim had expired and, if so, who bore the burden of proving this. Additionally, the court had to determine what relief, if any, should be granted to the widow in light of the executor's distribution of the estate. The court considered statutory provisions regarding limitation periods and the common law principles relating to the burden of proof in such matters. The widow contended that the limitation period had not expired and that she had a valid claim to a portion of the estate, while the executor argued that the limitation period had expired and that she was entitled to the full estate.
The court held that the limitation period for the widow's claim had not expired, and therefore, her claim was valid. The court found that the burden of proof rested on the executor to demonstrate that the limitation period had indeed expired. The executor failed to provide sufficient evidence to support this claim, and thus, the court ruled in favour of the widow. The court granted the widow an appropriate relief, which included a share of the estate corresponding to her entitlement as the widow of the beneficiary. The court ordered that the executor account for the distribution of the estate and compensate the widow for the portion to which she was entitled.
In conclusion, the court determined that the widow's claim was valid, and the executor's distribution of the estate was improper. The court awarded the widow a share of the estate and ordered the executor to account for her rightful entitlement. The decision underscores the importance of adhering to statutory limitation periods and the burden of proof in estate distribution cases.
The central legal issues before the court were whether the limitation period for the widow's claim had expired and, if so, who bore the burden of proving this. Additionally, the court had to determine what relief, if any, should be granted to the widow in light of the executor's distribution of the estate. The court considered statutory provisions regarding limitation periods and the common law principles relating to the burden of proof in such matters. The widow contended that the limitation period had not expired and that she had a valid claim to a portion of the estate, while the executor argued that the limitation period had expired and that she was entitled to the full estate.
The court held that the limitation period for the widow's claim had not expired, and therefore, her claim was valid. The court found that the burden of proof rested on the executor to demonstrate that the limitation period had indeed expired. The executor failed to provide sufficient evidence to support this claim, and thus, the court ruled in favour of the widow. The court granted the widow an appropriate relief, which included a share of the estate corresponding to her entitlement as the widow of the beneficiary. The court ordered that the executor account for the distribution of the estate and compensate the widow for the portion to which she was entitled.
In conclusion, the court determined that the widow's claim was valid, and the executor's distribution of the estate was improper. The court awarded the widow a share of the estate and ordered the executor to account for her rightful entitlement. The decision underscores the importance of adhering to statutory limitation periods and the burden of proof in estate distribution cases.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.