Pili v Ayers Rock Resort Company Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

DECISION NO:294/97

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT OF AUSTRALIA

INDUSTRIAL LAW - Alleged UNLAWFUL TERMINATION - whether VALID REASON for termination - alleged MISCONDUCT outside of work hours - fighting - whether conduct had relevant connection with employment - whether BREACH OF CONTRACT - whether contractual regulation of conduct after hours was reasonable - SUMMARY DISMISSAL - whether WAIVER of misconduct -whether breach of award term that dismissal not be harsh, unjust or unreasonable - whether employee was given OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND.

Industrial Relations Act 1988 (now Workplace Relations Act 1996) - ss 170DB, 170DC, 170DE, 170EA, 170EDA.
Trespass Act 1987 (NT).
Yulara Tourist Village Management Act 1984 (N.T.).
Tourist Village Management Act 1984 (N.T.)
Hotel, Motels, Wine Saloons, Catering, Accommodation, Clubs and Casino Employees (NT) Consolidated Award 1986.

Hussein v Westpac Banking Corporation (1995) 59 IR 103.
HEF of Australia v Western Hospital (1991) 4 VIR 310.
Dunning v Neata Glass Service Pty Ltd (unreported, IRCA No. 630 of 1995, Blockland JR, 17 October 1995).
Cook v Commissioner of Police (1996) 66 IR 361.
Osbourne v Woolworths SA Ltd (1992) 59 SAIR 600.
Re: Transfield Pty Limited re dismissal of a Union Delegate [1974] AR (NSW) 596.
Warner v Commissioner of State Revenue (unreported, IRCA No. 269 of 1997, RD Farrell JR, 16 September 1997).
North Australian Workers’ Union v Newcastle Protective Coating Pty Ltd  (1971) 13 AILR 603.
AWU (WA Branch) v Argyle Diamond Mines Pty Ltd 73 WAIG 2650.
Western Mining Corporation Limited v The Australian Workers’ Union (WA) 77 WAIG 1079.
Hallam v St Barbara Mines Ltd (unreported, IRCA No. 286 of 1997, RD Farrell JR, 29 October 1997).
AEEFEU (WA Branch) v Rottnest Island Authority 74 WAIG 130.
Jupiters Ltd v Thirkettle and McGinness (unreported, IRCA No. 258 of 1997, Madgwick J, 25 July 1997).
Nettlefold v Kym Smoker Pty Ltd (1996) 69 IR 370.
Wadey v YMCA Canberra (unreported, IRCA No. 542 of 1996, Moore J, 12 November 1996).
Westen v Union des Assurances de Paris (unreported, IRCA No. 660 of 1996, Madgwick J, 17 December 1996).

EKA JOSIE PILI -v- AYERS ROCK RESORT COMPANY LIMITED
DI 1096 OF 1996

JUDICIAL REGISTRAR:  R.D. FARRELL JR
PLACE:  PERTH (HEARD IN ALICE SPRINGS)
DATE:  13 NOVEMBER 1997

GENERAL DISTRIBUTION

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

  DI 1096 of 1996   

BETWEEN:            EKA JOSIE PILI
  APPLICANT

AND:  AYERS ROCK RESORT COMPANY LIMITED
  RESPONDENT

JUDICIAL

REGISTRAR:

R.D. FARRELL, JR

DATE OF ORDER:

13 NOVEMBER 1997

WHERE MADE:

PERTH (HEARD IN ALICE SPRINGS)

THE COURT ORDERS:

1.       The application is dismissed.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Industrial     Relations Court Rules.


GENERAL DISTRIBUTION

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

DI 1096 of 1996

BETWEEN:             EKA JOSIE PILI
APPLICANT

AND:  AYERS ROCK RESORT COMPANY LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDICIAL
REGISTRAR:         R.D. FARRELL, JR

DATE:  13 NOVEMBER 1997

PLACE:                   PERTH (HEARD IN ALICE SPRINGS)

REASONS FOR DECISION

This is an application under Section 170EA of the then Industrial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pili v Ayers Rock Resort Company Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] IRCA 294
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court was an application for reinstatement or compensation under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (the Act), arising from the dismissal of Ms Eka Josie Pili (Ms Pili) by the Ayers Rock Resort Company Limited (ARRC). ARRC owns and runs a resort complex at Yulara, in the Northern Territory. The resort is isolated, being 445 kilometres by road from Alice Springs. People working at the resort rent accommodation owned by the Northern Territory Housing Commission. The resort also has staff facilities such as bars and a gymnasium, a school, a medical centre, a police station, and a fire station.Ms Pili was employed by ARRC as a receptionist at its campgrounds in June 1996. She had previously been employed by ARRC for 18 months up to June 1995. She was encouraged to return to ARRC by her former supervisors and it was not in dispute that she was good at her job. She was 29 years of age at the time of her dismissal. The incident that led to her dismissal arose from an altercation she had with another of ARRC’s employees, Ms Melody Catling, in the early hours of Sunday, 27 October 1996. Ms Pili attended the Residents Club on the evening of Saturday 26 October 1996, and, while intoxicated, went to Ms Catling’s unit, forcible entry was gained, the fly-screen door was deliberately damaged, and Ms Pili grabbed Ms Catling by the collar, grabbed her by the throat, scratched her neck, and pushed her into the bedroom and onto her bed, holding her down. The altercation was broken up by Ms Catling’s friend, Ms Etepo.Ms Catling reported the incident to Mr Darren Porter, a security guard employed by ARRC. Ms Catling was witnessed by Mr Porter in the minutes following the incident to be “very upset, with marks around her neck, face and arms’. She visited her doctor on Monday 28 October 1996. The notes of that visit record bruising on back of right upper arm, bruising and scratches on back of left upper arm, scratches at the base of neck, back and front, complaints of pain on movement of right and left trapezius, scratches left thumb, pain right and left thenar eminence from resisting assault, consistent with alleged assault (no major injuries, 100% recovery expected), and emotionally upset. Not sleeping at her own place at present.Ms Catling rang in sick for work on Sunday 27 October 1996, and resumed work the following day. Ms Catling has since requested new accommodation.Ms Pili was charged with assault and with unlawful damage to property. The Court hearing was scheduled for 14 November 1996 before the Court of Summary Jurisdiction, sitting at the resort.ARRC’s Response to the IncidentMr Porter reported the incident to Ms Deborah Kerrins, and Mr Glenn Cameron, ARRC’s then Human Resources Managers at about 11.30am on the morning of Monday 28 October 1996. The Human Resources section was in a period of transition at the time. Ms Kerrins was leaving ARRC for other employment. Mr Cameron had been employed as the new Human Resources Manager. The incident concerning Ms Pili occurred during their “hand-over period”. Mr Porter reported the incident to Ms Kerrins and Mr Cameron and made his incident report available to both of them. It was agreed after discussion between Mr Cameron, Ms Kerrins and Mr Porter that Ms Pili should be interviewed about the matter, so that she had an opportunity to respond to Ms Catling’s allegations. Mr Cameron says he was of the view that, if the allegations appeared to be factually based, then Ms Pili should be at least suspended pending further investigations.Ms Pili worked on Monday, 28 October 1996 as rostered, from 12.00pm until 8.30pm. She told the managers of the campground, Mr and Mrs Rudy and Anne Krepelnik, about the incident and the charges. Mrs Krepelnik volunteered in evidence that she found it difficult to believe that Ms Pili could do such a thing.At about 4.20pm on Monday, 28 October 1996, about a day and a half after the incident, Mr Porter and Ms Kerrins interviewed Ms Pili at work at the campground reception for about forty minutes; Mr Cameron had an appointment elsewhere. Based upon the oral evidence of the participants, and upon notes made by Mr Porter and Ms Kerrins soon after, I find that the interview proceeded as follows.Mr Porter and Ms Kerrins asked Ms Pili to provide them with a written statement about the incident. She replied that she had been advised by the police not to talk, write or sign anything until the criminal charges against her had been heard. Ms Pili understood that Ms Kerrin’s enquiry was directed at the consequences of the incident upon her employment; Indeed, she queried what business it was of “security”, given that the incident happened outside of work.Ms Kerrins advised that if Ms Pili did not respond, then that would mean that ARRC would only have one side of the story to act on. She asked that Ms Pili tell them her account of what happened, suggesting that she just talk about it.After some initial reluctance, Ms Pili explained that the conflict between she and Ms Catling had begun over a spilt drink three weeks before and had been building ever since. She said she had gone to the Residents Club and had drunk until she became intoxicated. She admitted she went to Ms Catling’s unit and damaged the fly-screen door. She offered to pay for the damage caused, and was advised she would be invoiced. She admitted to entering Ms Catling’s unit without her permission, in order to sort out her grievance with her. She admitted grabbing Ms Catling by the throat at one point and pushing her onto her bed, but denied striking her. Ms Kerrins noted that Ms Pili cried as she recounted the incident, and appeared to be regretful of her actions. Mr Porter agrees that Ms Pili appeared upset and genuinely sorry. ARRC does not dispute that Ms Pili is genuinely remorseful about her conduct.When asked by Ms Kerrins about the risk of it happening again, Ms Pili offered not to return to the Residents’ Club. She pointed out that she had been charged with assault, that the hearing was scheduled in two weeks’ time and that she would not want to jeopardise that. She said she knew that what she did was wrong, but that she couldn’t change it.Mr Porter then served Ms Pili with a notice banning her from the Residents’ Club. The notice was in a standard form, adapted from a form recommended by the Northern Territory Hotels and Hospitality Association, and was in the following terms:“NOTICE TO STAY OFF PREMISES“THE RESIDENTS CLUB (THE PREMISES)TO:       Name:            Josie Pili Address:       Gregory Staff Flats Unit #20A 1.          BECAUSE of your:              *Present/Previous              *

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.